SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Ballyhoo or dead cigars? What's your choice and why? I have offshore fished for many years and know my way around about all aspects of fishing. I have trolled ballyhoo for kings in the past with success but I just can't shake that cigar minnow feeling. I have tried using them before and after about 5 minutes they turn to mush. I thaw them slowly and they never directly touch ice or fresh water. Even tried brining some. Don't break the skin when limbering them up either. I know my way around rigging baits so I'm sure that's not the problem. When I tried them, I tried them on hank brows, pirate plugs, and mackahoos. Also kept my trolling speed to 2-3 mph. (Boat was simply put in gear) I keep hearing how great they are and would like to use them as I can use them for bottom fishing as well. So, did I just get a bad batch? Anyone else have problems with this? Do dink hoos work just as good as cigars? I know it's loaded for my first post but plan on contributing where I can. Thanks in advance!
All I use are dink hoos now. A little more $$ but can troll faster and wash out less.. worth it to me
Recently weve had a bad batch of the Vietnam cigar minnows that just turned to mush.. the regular packs showed back up here, but I still prefer ballyhoo
I think maybe your right on the imported cigars. Seems like they mere from Vietnam. Thanks for the info. I'll just stick with hoos
Hoo's have worked well for me so far.
I've been sold on cigars for a long time, but yeah... after the "cigar shortage" last year, wherever these baits came from this season, they just weren't up to snuff. I've heard all the theories, and I couldn't debunk any of them... whatever it is, the baits wash out faster than I remember, and turn to mush after one trip.
I think I still have one more box to use, and hopefully next season they'll be back to normal quality.
I've had OK luck with ballyhoo further offshore (15-20 miles), but off the beach, I just haven't seen it. Could be just bad luck days, and the fact that I haven't pulled 'hoos a lot nearshore, but they haven't produced for me where cigars have.
Hopefully, we're going to see some decent numbers of pogies and some calmer seas before it gets cold this season... because live pogies are still my favorite way to go.
Normally cigar minnows!
But the quality of the cigar minnows we are getting from Vietnam (mush) they don't last long when pulling them.
Plenty of Pogies around Oak Island yesterday 10/4/20
can usually jig up live cigars also
Grandson caught his 1st King 27 lb "US Open Survivor" that we fooled Sunday.
Pulled it off Yaupon Reef!
Thanks for the info! If I can find some cigars from the USA I may give them another try. Going to give it a try Saturday for some king fishing and bottom bouncing. Got a guy going that's never done anything but surf fish so I hope we can find a few to put in the boat! I'll post report sunday
New River marina in Sneads Ferry has the same that Titan is showing. We picked up two boxes last Thursday from them. Haven't gotten the chance to use them yet, but they're the same old boxes we've always used without any troubles mentioned above.
New River marina in Sneads Ferry has the same that Titan is showing. We picked up two boxes last Thursday from them. Haven't gotten the chance to use them yet, but they're the same old boxes we've always used without any troubles mentioned above.
Looks like they are starting to get them back in stock.
If they are from Vietnam it will say it on the box
Are the kings moving into NW Places yet? Anyone heard or know first hand?
