SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
My feathers arn't ruffled, I just think its stupid to let
divers take advantage of hog snappers stupidity.
We have a good stock of them that arn't use to commercial divers beating the hell out of them. I realize they are having a bad year raping there
bottom down in fla. But that shouldn't give them the right to put this
type of pressure on North carolinas fishery. I'm just sick of everytime
a fishery gets good here, we get invaded by boats from everywhere.
As for them doing this for years, yes they have been historically doing
this stuff in FLA.(But not here) and thats where the bad stock assements came from, that has placed all these restrictions on us. Obviously they are
part of the problem will our fish stocks decline.
Send them home before they screw our fish stocks up like they did
theirs. As far as them following the rules, I'll beat you that they aren't
following the rules at all, they are greedy people who don't care at all.
Go home!! Your not welcome here.
I'll bet you if they had to piss in a jar that would take care of them, why in the hell has a Fla. bunch of rapists been allowed a nc commercial license so they can even sell here?
It's not about ruffled feathers or whats legal. It is about doing whats right. They come here with no regard to the future of the fishing in this area, because they are not from here. Why do you think they are here in the first place ? Because they have already decimated the fishing in the area they live in through the same process they are doing here. When they have wiped this area clean of marketable fish they will slide into some other area that the cloudy gray area of the law will protect them. If a local commercial fisherman or dive boat or charter sat in a area like they are and raped the area of anything boatable that the geniuses with the DMF allow there is a good chance the multitude would have some words with the few. It has always been the fishers of the seas have policed thier own, why is it not so in this case ? Why are they allowed to come here with no regard to whats right !!!!
My feathers arn't ruffled, I just think its stupid to let
divers take advantage of hog snappers stupidity.
We have a good stock of them that arn't use to commercial divers beating the hell out of them. I realize they are having a bad year raping there
bottom down in fla. But that shouldn't give them the right to put this
type of pressure on North carolinas fishery. I'm just sick of everytime
a fishery gets good here, we get invaded by boats from everywhere.
As for them doing this for years, yes they have been historically doing
this stuff in FLA.(But not here) and thats where the bad stock assements came from, that has placed all these restrictions on us. Obviously they are
part of the problem will our fish stocks decline.
Send them home before they screw our fish stocks up like they did
theirs. As far as them following the rules, I'll beat you that they aren't
following the rules at all, they are greedy people who don't care at all.
Go home!! Your not welcome here.
They have been making this trip up the Carolina's coast for 10 or more years. It is nothing new. I think it is the first time they have packed out in CB. Do you even know the break down of what type of fish they are packing out? How many boxes of hogs have they packed? Would it surprise you that they catch more on hook and line than they do shooting? Come on guys, you are being silly. If you complain about them, then you are going to have to apply it ot all commercial fisherman. Or how about a head boat? All the b-liners that get cut up for bait. All the short fish that get thrown back after they have set in a bucket too long. If you know anything about spearfishing then you know those fish only going to stick around so long. Take a look at how many fish were landing by spearing for the whole South Atlantic region. It is NOTHING compaired to hook and line. But you guys just keep on ranthing with basically no real information.
As of 12:01am Sunday it looks like they wont have more than a box and half of hogs per trip....15 boxs of grouper total per trip, no more than 5 boxes of gags per trip if I read it right...
Tighter trip limits would definately be the easiest way to send them packing and protect the locals.
This is a very clean fishery!!! You see the fish and only take it if it is of size. With tighter net laws get use to "green" fishing. What is everyones problem with this i just don't understand? Where do all the fish and other seafood you go out and eat come from? ole yea commercial fisherman!!!!
I personally care most about the Hogs. We have the bast fishery for them in the world unless I hear otherwise and that epicenter is centered around FP shoals. They fall under reef complex species and are not regulated and it takes them many years to mature. The only reason there are so many is lack of pressure. If you see a picture in a FL fishing magazine a trophy hog will maybe push 10 pounds. Here nobody hardly catches or selectively spears one under 10. There are plenty of 20+ pounders down there if we police the fishery. It makes me mad when people come up here and put a hurting on them with no benefit to NC natives. You won't even see them in local fish markets because they get shipped up north to some fancy resturaunt first.
Head Boats provide an experience for everyone on board not fortunate enough to have the means to do it themselves. They pump money into the NC economy.
I hear the FL guys have been spending more of their time here in recent years because SC has gotten more restrictive and as others have repeatedly said, The FL fishery has already been cut down to a fraction of what it once was.
Hogwild you are right there are fisherys that need the laws changed to protect the fishery or to allow more fish to be taken. Bluefin is the big one (not the commercial guy fault if the fishery is open and thay can support there family thats what you do, limit the fishery not the fisherman). I was just trying to point out that this fishery is very green and will be used more and more as the federal DMF pushes for low/no bycatch. This fishery has lower bycatch than with a rod and reel.
Fellas,
I am trying offer assistance and advise to Louis Daniels on this project and giving him several suggestions and avenues to confront it with. Keep in mind we need to stop excessive influx of boats from coming into our region yet we still look out for the locals that are already here and making a living.
One thing I will say, he has given myself and others, his "ear" and is in full agreement that we need to protect our stock and our local fishermen, both hook & line and diving.
Louis asked if I would like me to go meet with the commission in Aug for input recommendations on how to write the future regulations and wording, which I obviously agreed to.
I have a unique perspective since I am both recreational and commercial and my primary concern is.................. THE GROUPER AND HOGFISH STOCK.
For those of you that don't know me, I speardive and hook & line, both commercial and recreational and want to protect what we have in our own back yard. I am a limited part time commercial shooter / hooker.
I wrote the grouper study a couple of years ago to show what our stock is to the South Atlantic council. I don't commercial and abuse our stock, I set personal guidelines about size and quantity that are much stricter than the fisheries does.
You guys that know me, know this already. I only do day trips 95% of the time with the occasional "over-nighter".
I talked to both the DMF and Wildlife about the commercial boat diving here and the possibly of other boats coming in and decimating our stock. I was referred to Lt. Kelley to discuss. Lt. Kelley was already involved with this and he had already gotten the ball rolling for us on the hogs. He investigated and then made a recommendation. He wrote a report recommending a new measure to be addressed and sent it to Daniels to be reviewed.
With several of you guys also piping in, we have gotten the attention and a response from the fishery in record time.............. GREAT JOB.
Louis and I talked 3 times yesterday and the proclamation was signed yesterday early afternoon.
The NEW proclamation included grouper, which I didn't realize was being addressed, and is a 1500 lb grouper / hog limit per trip with 150 lb of that being a hog limit STARTS 7 - 25.....IN 2 DAYS!!!! Talk about fast.
If they take any hogs, that will be counted in the 1500 lb limit. Another words, 1350 grouper, 150 hog. Right now, it is unlimited for both until the entire commercial quote is met. The problem is, our stock isn't used to this much pressure and won't recover on a yearly basis if we don't address it IMMEDIATELY.
This proclamation isn't the solution but it will at least slow the resource take down. Now we have to get creative and work on this from nontraditional avenues. Otherwise, they will just come in every 2 days.
We don't want that cap to be on all 73 species of the reef complex or we will essentially shut down our entire NC fishery and that would be a terrible thing for us to loose.
I am talking to the local "hook & line" commercial fleet to get a base line to work off of so I can supply the commission with data.
The discussion for the use of powerheads came up. At this point they said they are thinking about reciprocating SC law saying that they are illegal. I am going to fight that on the basis of personal protection. I also don't think there is enough of a commercial take that uses powerheads to warrant an outlaw of them.
Louis said that made sense. He also understood the security issue in the event there was a threatening shark, predominantly to spearfishing, either commercial or recreational.
I realize some of you don't carry a powerhead for protection now, I want you to have the right to if you should so desire.
The average small hook and line commercial boat, fishing the same 5 day trip is averaging about 600 - 1,000 of grouper right now, for this time of year, from the ones I have talked to.
When the fish move shallow in Sept - Nov, the H & L boats will do 15 - 20 boxes average. It will be catastrophic the damage they will do having the fish when they move in close, both to the docks and in shallow diving water, if we have an influx of boats come into the area.
If another 2 or 4 of boats came up, our local stock will be crushed in under 6 months.
Things I have already tried running up the flagpole.
1. We can't raise the license price for out of state boats to sell their catch, I tried that avenue.
2. We can't restrict a federal licensed boat not based, owned, operated and moored in NC from selling or unloading in NC, I tried that avenue.
We can get creative in other areas and any ideas you have, shoot them over. I will see if it is a viable avenue to pursue.
IF YOU KNOW ANY COMMERCIAL FISHERS, EITHER HOOKER OR SHOOTER, TELL THEM TO CALL ME. I am getting data from them to present to the fishers or the commission, either one. It will only take them 5 minutes on the phone. This is their chance to have input on the new regs.
I have a few other things that I will be presenting Louis and the commission in Aug. Will keep you guys posted.
Again................. GREAT JOB.
Craig
910-209-2920
I think that we all will do what it takes to feed our families, and to get your feathers ruffled at someone or some group doing the same is a waste of time and energy. From what I know they are playing by all the rules.
So...... we just made new rules..... in a record 2 weeks. ๐
Effective Sunday, 7/25
Do you even know the break down of what type of fish they are packing out? How many boxes of hogs have they packed? Would it surprise you that they catch more on hook and line than they do shooting? Come on guys, you are being silly.
Are you on crack?
" catch more on hook and line" comment clearly states you education in this matter. As for the pack out, yes, and it is going to kill the stock if they keep it up.
This is brought about since the Rolling Thunder said " we are staying as long as we can keep getting fish. "
This isn't a 1 - 2 week trip. They have been here almost 6 weeks that I know of.
Maybe you desire is to have your viewpoint valued, you should do a bit of research before you start spouting an uneducated, knee jerk opinion.
Just sayin'
Commercial Spearfishing should be OUTLAWED....
Hook and Line can not hurt tha Ocean....Spearfishing Can.
Dave
A touch extreme don't you think?
No bycatch, selective, w/ no shorts, etc.
It has been fine for years till we get a jack leg here from out of town that doesn't have the mindset of taking care of our fish resource.
Until now, most local commercial spearos have regulated themselves to make sure we still had fish to shoot later. Breaking it up and taking other things like AJ's, etc.
I can't believe I am saying this , but, for once, we needed some regs because of a rotten apple.
Sad but true and coo-dos to Louis for cutting through red tape and implementing the new regulations this fast..
KillerandGriller,
louis and the group at NCDMF does a great job for the most part as is proof by our fishery. Most of the fish that need protection is regulated by the feds. Just so everyone knows who I am I fish both rec and commercial, I Fish all the time so I see alot of the problems and know how hard some are to fix (Guys fishing in federal water off NC from FL.) or many other problems. I think you are the right path we need to regulate the fishery not the fisherman, this is what I posted the first time. I fish for Bluefins each season and I know the fish need protection but it is not the fishermans job to protect the fish its the dmf job. Fisherman catch fish thats what we do, DMF needs to protect the fish that are overfished, and we need to start a large scale fish farm to add to our fish stocks. Brunswick co. has had there scool kids do this for years for flounder (Flounder biggest problem is due to runoff witch kills small fish and shrimp in the channels and kills the food chain, Just go gigg and look how dead the bottom is in some areas where the runoff is high).
Funny no one has said a word about bluefin and 1/2 the fish are landed by boat not from NC.
James
to the poster who brought up gigging, it's far worse than gigging a flounder, now that there are limits on flounder.
If you would like to compare it to something that blindly rapes the fishery that so many care about then set your sites on gill netting. So many of the species that we all cherish breed inshore and then get caught and wasted as by-catch when the spot rodeo kicks off in the fall.
Have you ever watched someone clean their net of short flounder, trout, reds, juvy grouper, etc. etc. etc. Anyone who cares about the waters and actually sees that happen will begin to understand why gill netting needs some serious scrutiny.
One of my favorite quote from a gill netter.... "I don't waste my time with no hook and line fishing. I can set a net and kill more fish in a morning than most people kill in a year."