SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
While my buddy and I were trolling for kings saturday we noticed a boat bottom fishing close by and as we got near they would pick up and move. We were fishing the South Rock area off of Topsail. As we circled around we saw three undersized gags floating on the surface. I don't know how many more there were that we didn't see but it sure was a shame to see those fish wasted. These were good size fish but obviousley not legal. I guess they needed to be vented to survive and this boat didn't do that. It's a shame.
Lovely........dumbasses giving bottom fisherman a bad name.
I've seen that before and it is a shame. Ignorance.
While my buddy and I were trolling for kings saturday we noticed a boat bottom fishing close by and as we got near they would pick up and move. We were fishing the South Rock area off of Topsail. As we circled around we saw three undersized gags floating on the surface. I don't know how many more there were that we didn't see but it sure was a shame to see those fish wasted. These were good size fish but obviousley not legal. I guess they needed to be vented to survive and this boat didn't do that. It's a shame.
Did you try and vent them?
If I see that, I dip net them and vent-em.
While my buddy and I were trolling for kings saturday we noticed a boat bottom fishing close by and as we got near they would pick up and move. We were fishing the South Rock area off of Topsail. As we circled around we saw three undersized gags floating on the surface. I don't know how many more there were that we didn't see but it sure was a shame to see those fish wasted. These were good size fish but obviousley not legal. I guess they needed to be vented to survive and this boat didn't do that. It's a shame.
Did you try and vent them?
If I see that, I dip net them and vent-em.
They weren't moving at all, just floating and appeared to have already died. I just can't believe that a boat would keep on doing that if they see the fish are floating. I hope they read this and get some sort of concience and educate themselves on venting techniques.
Just wait till this fall around Yaupon when the big bulls show up--25ft cubby C-Hawk threw back couple 30 lb+ plus floaters---ding-bats are everywhere. Same area saw Capt Jimmy Price take about 5 min to help bulls swim off alive. Experience makes the difference.
Just curious,
How deep was the water where you saw this?
Thanks
Just curious,
How deep was the water where you saw this?
Thanks
I believe we were in 75 feet if you're asking me the question.
For all the other nübs who have to admit they have no idea how to vent a fish:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=heffqxMb-6g&feature=related
on The Continental Shelf featuring a South Chatham Tackle product.
Venting should only be used as a last resort.
(If the fish fails to make it on its own.)
The survival rate is much higher if the fish
can make it without venting.
Alot of times the fish is just suffering from the stress of the "Catch"
and venting them just furthers the trama.
I try and revive the fish by moving water across their gills first.
I also check to see if the pressure around their Air Bladder seems
to be easing off(If it is thats a good sign), If it seems really tight like a bubble after reviving them
& they try to go, but their air bladder is stopping their progress, only then do
I vent. Some fish just die from the trama of the catch.
From what you say this does not sound like a venting issue to me. Sounds like someone who was throwing undersize fish overboard, hence the boat picking up and leaving once you got near.
From what you say this does not sound like a venting issue to me. Sounds like someone who was throwing undersize fish overboard, hence the boat picking up and leaving once you got near.
I really don't know. There were other boats fishing in the area besides us and it was pretty obvious that we were trolling. They didn't leave the area just moved to a different spot. I wish I had paid more attention to them at the time but we didn't see the dead fish floating until after we had circled back and were ready to leave. I will pay more attention next time I see something like this. Probably should have circled around again to get a boat name or number. Whatever the cause I just hope this thread brings an awareness to this shameful waste. Thanks for reading.
Those floaters will get eaten just not by the top of the food chain.The predators that eat juvenile fish 24/7 will eat them too.I hate actually seeing small fish float off,maybe 2 or 3 sometimes none in a10hour day,but can only guess how many juveniles are eaten by predators in their world.No,it weren"t me.
It's funny that you think that venting would assure their survival. Most released fish are eaten by bigger predators once you turn them back. They are stunned and disoriented by the trauma of being caught and released and once slowed down, the big fish pick them off. It's not cool to talk trash about someone for doing the same thing as you just without a venting tool. You also, for some reason, see no problem with circling in on someone's fishing spot close enough to see what they are and are not doing. Being hooked and pulled up from the depths against your will having the hook ripped out leaving gaping wounds, or just leaving hooks in the throat....is a very rough experience for any living thing and to suggest that you are doing it in a more kind and gentle way is kinda dumb if you ask me. Fish are food. Either for us, or for other fish, or for crabs or whatever. When you hook them, you condemn them to death in most cases. Dont be a hypocrite by accusing others of killing in an inhumane way. Killing is killing.
The thing that I hate about throwing back the small ones is the fact that it shuts the bite off. When the little grouper swims back to the bottom, you can believe that he is hauling ass and swims right through the others and goes under the ledge. This spooks the other fish and the bite shuts off. I like to leave the throw backs on the deck until the bite is over and then toss them back.
This guy might have just kept them out a little too long or let them lay in the sun. Eighter way, they do not go to waste. fish do eat other fish.