SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

hero2

33 Posts
14 Users
0 Reactions
1,446 Views
Larry Rowland
(@lwr37)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 2552
 

So grouper your point is if you can steal from someone and get away with it, go ahead? Good luck with that.

Heck, China is doing it ever day!



   
ReplyQuote
John
 John
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 165
Topic starter  

I love how all of you are fighting over patent infringement. Last I checked the man doesn't have a patent on it! Its pending. Plus my design has so many differences that it makes no where like the original "TrollPro" that is over proced and rediculous. $150 for pvc pipe!?! I dont care how long someone takes to put some PVC cement on some pipe fittings to have a "invention" maybe you should peruse the internet for all the "patent infringements" as you call them. Just to let people know I did make this housing differently than the "original". I actually just put the finishing touches on mine tonight and have created a piece to help give people a better piece of mind about thwir camera when it goes under the water, as far as losing it. Last time.I checked whether you have the $199 Hero or the $299 Hero2 like me...you want some added insurance to help prevent losing the camera.

I am sorry aome of you feel I am stepping on someones toes because I know how to use PVC Cement and putting some fittings together. Not everyone has $150 to spend on that!



   
ReplyQuote
Larry Rowland
(@lwr37)
Famed Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 2552
 

I love how all of you are fighting over patent infringement. Last I checked the man doesn't have a patent on it! Its pending. Plus my design has so many differences that it makes no where like the original "TrollPro" that is over proced and rediculous. $150 for pvc pipe!?! I dont care how long someone takes to put some PVC cement on some pipe fittings to have a "invention" maybe you should peruse the internet for all the "patent infringements" as you call them. Just to let people know I did make this housing differently than the "original". I actually just put the finishing touches on mine tonight and have created a piece to help give people a better piece of mind about thwir camera when it goes under the water, as far as losing it. Last time.I checked whether you have the $199 Hero or the $299 Hero2 like me...you want some added insurance to help prevent losing the camera.

I am sorry aome of you feel I am stepping on someones toes because I know how to use PVC Cement and putting some fittings together. Not everyone has $150 to spend on that!

I'm going to buy some pipe and start experimenting! 😆



   
ReplyQuote
John
 John
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 165
Topic starter  

I love how all of you are fighting over patent infringement. Last I checked the man doesn't have a patent on it! Its pending. Plus my design has so many differences that it makes no where like the original "TrollPro" that is over proced and rediculous. $150 for pvc pipe!?! I dont care how long someone takes to put some PVC cement on some pipe fittings to have a "invention" maybe you should peruse the internet for all the "patent infringements" as you call them. Just to let people know I did make this housing differently than the "original". I actually just put the finishing touches on mine tonight and have created a piece to help give people a better piece of mind about thwir camera when it goes under the water, as far as losing it. Last time.I checked whether you have the $199 Hero or the $299 Hero2 like me...you want some added insurance to help prevent losing the camera.

I am sorry aome of you feel I am stepping on someones toes because I know how to use PVC Cement and putting some fittings together. Not everyone has $150 to spend on that!

I'm going to buy some pipe and start experimenting! 😆

All you need is a 2" coupler, 2" cap, 2-4" adapter and two pieces of 2" pvc pipe. Finish it off with your keel weight and an eyebolt. I was thinking about putting pics on here of some pipe bombs...wait I better not...thats probably patent infringement too...lol! I bet I could make a set of outriggers out of pvc pipe and post pics of them...wait no...too close like other cheap outriggers.

I am happy to say that my finished product is top notch and its itching to be pulled in the water.

Let me know how your pipe experimenting goes! 😆



   
ReplyQuote
Grouper Sandwich
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1213
 

So grouper your point is if you can steal from someone and get away with it, go ahead? Good luck with that.

The patent only protects items specifically and properly written in the patent. If it is different it is not stealing in any way. Honestly the guy should give him a free Liscense to copy the design, improve on it and sell his product. A royalty will be paid of course... Then all are happy

The laws over patent infringement suck, but only a court will decide what is infringement and it cost big $$$. The only people making money with patents are the attorneys writing them and the ones enforcing them!



   
ReplyQuote
George Golinski
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1371
 

Maybe you're right Grouper, I'm not a lawyer and I didn't stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night. I just see a buddy of mine getting what I believe to be a raw deal so I defend his interests. I think most of you would do the same. Do I think copying his design, even if modified, is morally wrong and illegal? Absolutely. But the individual in question will have to bear the responsibility for his actions, as we all do.



   
ReplyQuote
(@offshore)
Honorable Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 469
 

Trolling housings have been around even before the troll pro so you could reverse the tables on protecting interest. Threatening people on a web site does not serve your purpose or the business well at all. I have a housing at the house that was made out of a 1 liter coke bottle for a small video camera that we used in a lake. It was made well before the troll pro and GoPro cameras. Although I am all for patents and our company owns a few design patents I would be careful making blanket statements on a forum like this. It could come back and bite you at a later date. The world is full of people trying to make a better mousetrap and there is nothing wrong with that.



   
ReplyQuote
Eric Knight
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 878
 

I have an example, or allegory or whatever you want to call it: Removable surfboard fins.
There were a couple companies a little over a decade ago that started experimenting with removable fins on high performance short boards for ease of travel and to change the fins to adjust the performance of the board depending on the waves. Mind you, removable fins have been around for a long, long time--mostly seen on longboards (start thinking about waterproof camera housings and other camera accessories like a tripod), and fins on surfboards have been around even longer (start thinking about cameras). The original removable fins on longboards were patented, or at least the system for securing and removing them is/was.
Enter the high performance shortboard: much more advanced foil, many more options for design and much, much lower tolerances for fine tuning--the wave (pun intended) of the future (now start thinking GoPro Cameras and others like it). All of a sudden, with the advent of a new product there are many new options for its use--many that had not even been thought of yet. The point is, it opened up a whole new world of options to be explored.
So, some industrious folks began to explore ways to add variety to one board and also prevent the most common damage a surfboard experiences--a broken out fin(s) from travel--AND ways to try fins with different foil and flex characteristics on one board (think about different MOUNTS for the GoPro). These designs all followed the same basic idea, BUT they designed their own mounting system. Heck, they even had the SAME fin manufacturers making their prototype fin systems, so the fins were the same but the mount was different. Eventually two major companies became the most used (and there are a hand full of smaller companies with their own systems patented), both with different patents for their mounting systems. These companies are now doing very well with their products--with zero patent infringement issues--AND the fin market is better for it because there are multiple design choices for the consumer to pick.
The long-winded point I am trying to make is more in the form of a question: Given the process of product evolution and, more importantly, market demand for innovative niche products--where exactly does someone start "stepping on toes" or infringing on a patent?

In the case of GoPro: Underwater video has been around a long time, special housings for cameras have been around a long time, even TROLLING CAMERAS and things like them have been around for quite a while. The only thing original about the TrollPro design is the system used to pull your camera behind your boat--it's a specific design, which is what the patent is for. There are obviously more ways to skin a cat and more ways to pull a GoPro in your spread. So, how can you call it patent infringement if it is expanding upon an already ubiquitous idea?

Marlin, no one can fault a man for protecting his friend's interests. But you don't patent a generalized idea, you patent a specific product. The free market depends on groups of innovators to produce multiple solutions based on an idea in order to make effective and relevant products.

Disclaimer: I'm most definitely not a lawyer, but my best friend is and I am sure he will let me know all the different levels on which I may be wrong in drawing this parallel--this is just my take on it.

But really, straight up threatening another FPT member with a lawsuit because he's stoked on creating a product to put to market that may or may not become popular, be at all effective or even work once mass produced (IF it ever gets that far)? Come on man.

JWPGA: I mentioned my best friend is a lawyer. IF, in fact, you need a GOOD ONE, PM me and I will give you his number. I think he knows a couple good lawyers around town he can refer you to! (yes, I am busting my buddies balls here):P



   
ReplyQuote
Eric Knight
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 878
 

Oh yeah, prime example of Patent being used as cronyism:

Dow Chemicals: Car A/C refrigerant. The EPA miraculously changes their requirements for freon to Dow's newly patented produce EVERY TIME a Dow patent expires on the old product.

You know, their "new" freon about to come out is highly explosive!



   
ReplyQuote
George Golinski
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1371
 

If I threatened anyone, I apologize, that was not my intent. I'm expressing my opinions and I don't speak for anyone but myself. I have no financial interest in TrollPro or GoPro or any other such product. eKnight, business and government in cahoots to rob the taxpayer of their money? Say it ain't so! LOL! The original post mentioned TrollPro by name and stated he could build this cheaper, listed a price range and asked if anyone would be interested in buying one. That's what got my attention. He has since changed the post and the title of this thread.



   
ReplyQuote
Grouper Sandwich
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1213
 

eknight... very well put!

marlin... if it were my buddy id probably be pissed too.

bottom line is first one to market will have a far better chance of establishing a "brand" , however they will spend the rest of their days fending off the up and coming competition. in fact there are probably dozens out their trying to build /rebuild the better system. and getting a patent on the "different" but same system is as easy as spending $15k on a good patent attorney.

like it or not this is business. i wish your buddy the best of luck... but he will have competion, patent or not.



   
ReplyQuote
John
 John
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 165
Topic starter  

I appreciate those of you who have in a sense "defended" my excitement about the housing that I have built, created, and drawn up.

Marlin: As far as stepping on your friends toes on his design, that never was my intention or my goal. After watching hundreds of videos online of people and underwater video I decided to take the leap and create something myself to get my own underwater footage. I did change my post due to your rude, vulgar threats. I was mearly showing my idea to people on FPT and seeing their thoughts, as many others do on this forum. Last I checked this is what a forum is for, sharing thoughts, creations, methods and expertise.

eknight: I love your example of allegory or whatever as you put it. Another great example is Berkley's Green Machine; look at how many companies/businesses have copied that idea.



   
ReplyQuote
George Golinski
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1371
 

Rude and vulgar? Me? LOL! Now that stings.



   
ReplyQuote
Brian Eber
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 180
 

I've seen guys making home made trolling housings for go pro cameras on another website long before I ever heard of TrollPro.

Also as part of Patent Law its up to the Patent holder to sue for damages, against the infinger. So lets say the OP sells 50 of his "knock off" housings. Realisticly the only damage to TrollPro would be lost sales ie 50 units x troll pro's price of $200= $10,000 in damages. I'm sure the legal fees would cost so much more than reward that any laywer would say its not a case worth pursuing.



   
ReplyQuote
George Golinski
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1371
 

I don't know that producing something for your personal use is even an issue. But selling them is. Once again posting on a public forum like this, naming the product by it's brand name, saying you are copying it for a lesser price, listing the price, soliciting buyers and posting pictures of the copied product is almost a Keystone Cops level incident. It's like the little kid with his hands and face covered in chocolate denying he ate the candy bar. But what do I know. I'm trying very hard to dissuade this person from a course of action that might damage the business of a friend of mine and get him in trouble to boot. And I'm failing miserably. But then again I am rude and vulgar.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 3
Share: