SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I have been to the Big Rock 3 times. Caught a few fish each time. Also been to the Rise, 90 Ft Drop, Far East Tanker, and each time I swore I'd never go back. Last time I went I kept that promise. Never in my life seen such a crowd of boats. Unreal!!!!!
Might be a little longer ride from Carolina Beach (48 nm's) but not near as crouded, and from what I see a much better class of fish. The Fall/ Winter run of Wahoo down here will put Morehead to shame!!!! And don't give me all this charter boat crap, we are out there, not just reading some internet report.Nothing against Morehead, but don't give me this bull crap that it's better than here.
Big Blue, you really need to hire a Captian or a local to go with you. I promise you that it will help you.
Good Luck
I will agree with that 1000%.
I have been to the Big Rock 3 times. Caught a few fish each time. Also been to the Rise, 90 Ft Drop, Far East Tanker, and each time I swore I'd never go back. Last time I went I kept that promise. Never in my life seen such a crowd of boats. Unreal!!!!!
Might be a little longer ride from Carolina Beach (48 nm's) but not near as crouded, and from what I see a much better class of fish. The Fall/ Winter run of Wahoo down here will put Morehead to shame!!!! And don't give me all this charter boat crap, we are out there, not just reading some internet report.Nothing against Morehead, but don't give me this bull crap that it's better than here.
Big Blue, you really need to hire a Captian or a local to go with you. I promise you that it will help you.
Good Luck
"We are out there, not just reading some internet report". Apparently it's more like "we are out there, just not giving a fishing report". You will never hear Carolina Beach and world class offshore fishing in the same sentence. MHC? absolutely. Did you ever think that there might be a reason you see a lot more boats while fishing in MHC?
Why is it people feel it necessary to get into a pissing contest? I can guarantee Midnight knows more about this state and fishery than most anyone on this board. He's been at this game a whole lot longer.
Many quit posting on here because of all the crap like in this thread and being attacked for giving an honest opinion.
MHC may be a good fishery but it is not the holiest of holiest. There are plenty of other places all along this coast.
Mhc is closer to certain areas but those areas aren't the best producers of fish. The places most my buddies that fish out of there are south and still around 60 miles. Most people don't run to those areas since the 90 and big rock are closer.
care to share a few of these? i would love to try and produce some results for this claim next year.
^^He's the one that stated CBI will put MHC to shame during the Wahoo "run". That is just not true. Both areas are good areas to fish for Wahoo in the fall but stating that CBI will put MHC to shame is false. It wasn't a "pissing match" until this was posted and he made an "attack" on Robeward for posting a report from a Charter Captain. Which you agreed with BTW.
As far as Robeward putting Dancin Outlaws post up, the original poster specifically stated he wanted to catch Blackfin. He was showing that they killed the Blackfin just last weekend.
I don't see where midnight attacked anyone. The charter boat reference is just that. Not geared towards one person.
Did MHC have a run on blackfin, Yup. Was it a lot closer in than what you will more than likely find out of CB, I even agree to that. But that still doesn't mean MHC is the greatest fishery in NC.
Let's revisit the OPs actual question and give him honest facts that no one should be able to deny:
"I'm currently keeping my boat at Carolina beach and our lease runs up in December so my question is are both places similar fishing grounds I've been to the stream once but not real crazy about the 64 mile trip!! Our target fish are blackfin tuna (most important) wahoo and mahi !! If you're fishing out of Beaufort inlet do I still have to go 60 plus miles,we've caught mahi from 10-30 miles out of cb this year so I assume that will be close to same there, but really would love to catch tuna and wahoo I would appreciate any advice we live 3 1/2 hours from cb so I know it may take longer to travel to mhc"
If you fish out of Beaufort inlet you do not have to go 65 statute miles to catch those fish. There are places to go that are closer. You will more than likely be fishing against 90% of the folks fishing out of that inlet when you choose to go to the famous places mentioned in this post, ex: big rock. And you may wonder why only 10% actually catch the fish. lol. You will lessen your chances to actually catching fish bc there are many more people in those areas. Can you still catch the fish you are after, more than likely. As you learn the fishery out of there you will find yourself going to other places that are back in that same distance as you would travel out of CB. In the end it's all about reading the water for the area you plan to fish.
Well here we go. Pass the popcorn please. :popcorn:
I would rather run MHC inlet over CB ever time. I think the fishing is better from MHC over CB/WB but plenty of fish are caught either place.
I have fished both areas with my homeport being MHC but went to school down there any years ago. Plain and simple fact to answer the original question.
No 64 mile run out of Morehead to fishing grounds most of time, exception is when the water you are looking for is just not there. After the earlier storm I did not find bluewater until 50 fathoms.
I have been fishing MHC for 30 years just as Midnight has fished CB many more than that (no offense) and if I went there he would school me just from knowing the area and places and past experiences will make him more effective and vice versa.
BOTH areas produce fish and some species are simply caught more. Both are great fishing areas and with produce fish. Your knowledge of the techniques and ability to read the water is what makes the difference
I have seen Midnight's posts and had the honor to share info at one of the MAD events in MHC and he knows his stuff. I have personally had stellar days at the 14 bouy, 90' Drop and the Big Rock BUT I have also had stellar days at the Far East Tanker, Swansboro Hole, Grouper Hole etc. I don't pick a spot on map to troll I pick a spot on a SST chart and use the know locations as reference point
Basically it is all in where you want to be when you return to dock that matters, where the family is happy as there are fish out there.
^Bingo. Saying (insert area) doesn't hold many fish in the stream is misinformation. And the day you are talking about running to 50 fathoms is probably the same day we were there. By the end of the day it had pushed in some but there was a pile of fish right on top of the BR on the color change. It was one of those oil/water type breaks.
As far as the areas argument goes, heck a lot of the fish we catch come from down there. Most people watch the SST to catch Eddys coming from down that way. Fish it starting down south and follow it north for a few days. It makes having XM weather a game changer.
Beaufort Inlet is within 50 nm of an awful lot of territory both north and south. If I were to move my boat north it would probably be Virginia Beach, or South Stuart Fl.
Didn't mean to cause a pissing match!! I've got a ton to learn,more than I ever imagined lol (sst) don't have a clue what that is and probably wouldn't even know what to look for!! Midnight wind is right I probably need to hire someone to go out with me actually I di even know you could do that.my family really wants to catch a blackfin and from what I'm seeing on this sight it's a Gulf Stream only fish!! Thanks for everyones opinions
Didn't mean to cause a pissing match!! I've got a ton to learn,more than I ever imagined lol (sst) don't have a clue what that is and probably wouldn't even know what to look for!! Midnight wind is right I probably need to hire someone to go out with me actually I di even know you could do that.my family really wants to catch a blackfin and from what I'm seeing on this sight it's a Gulf Stream only fish!! Thanks for everyones opinions
I will admit depending on the time of year. If you had went out of Beaufort last weekend you could have found an abundance of them in the 10-12 miles range. Good ones at that. But typically they are a targeted species in the gulf stream.
Didn't mean to cause a pissing match!! I've got a ton to learn,more than I ever imagined lol (sst) don't have a clue what that is and probably wouldn't even know what to look for!! Midnight wind is right I probably need to hire someone to go out with me actually I di even know you could do that.my family really wants to catch a blackfin and from what I'm seeing on this sight it's a Gulf Stream only fish!! Thanks for everyones opinions
Fish Here map. Capt Dave sells them up here. Well worth it esp in your position. He will pull the sea surface temperature (SST) shots and many other types for you. he will analyze them and tell you what you need to know. when you purchase you also specify what species you are after and he will take that into account.
i am sure there is a wealth of info on what spread is best for blackfin up here. don't think the spread of large ballyhoo and islanders will get their attention. green machines and smaller squid type baits i believe but let the pros weigh in on that.
Why is it people feel it necessary to get into a pissing contest? I can guarantee Midnight knows more about this state and fishery than most anyone on this board. He's been at this game a whole lot longer.
MHC may be a good fishery but it is not the holiest of holiest. There are plenty of other places all along this coast.
I will have to agree with Midnight on this one. Up until a few months ago, I have never caught a Grouper. He was kind enough to help me out with a location that would produce. Since then I have caught several. I am out of Beaufort inlet. Seems like he knows his way up and down the entire coast of NC. By him giving me advice out of Beaufort inlet and being "spot on" I could just imagine how the fishing is at his preferred locations, out of Carolina Beach. Everyone has his or her own preference. You may be the man out of Beaufort and Midnight may just be the Man period.