SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

What would you do? (Illegal fishing)

93 Posts
48 Users
0 Reactions
4,305 Views
scott Evans
(@mzbhavn)
Eminent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 36
 

I can understand all perspectives and I have been a police officer so my experience may differ. I like others consider each situation, it's consequences to me or others, any known legal considerations and then follow my gut and never worry about or ask others if the decision was right or wrong as only I can make that decision based on my knowledge and experiences.

As to your question this is how would have handled it. "Man that's awesome looking catch and trip, but you may want to check into it because I am not sure your allowed to clean on the way back in as well as the boat may have over fished, I just don't want to see you get in trouble bud for the actions of others.... I would consider that my part, giving someone some info and looking out for my friends back.

Now if I was on the trip, I most certainly would have voiced up to any actions I knew were illegal or concerned about and maybe tried to get a picture or two and would turn him in. This is not to be policing those around me but to NOT be an accessory or charged with crime that someone else committed especially because I never know who is watching. By doing so it would also give him the opportunity to tell me of something I didn't consider or throw me overboard!

http://www.tampafishingoutfittersradio.com/federal-agents-cited-15-charter-boat-companies.html

Lastly I will say that everyone's moral compass will be different and that's ok as it would be boring if we all thought like each other. BUT KEEP THIS IN MIND. It is ALWAYS easier to turn a blind eye and do nothing then it is to do what is right. You only need to justify your actions to yourself, but understand you will be judged, scrutinized and picked apart by everyone after the fact.

By the way, my windows on my glass house have some spots.....if you see me speeding down hwy 70 get the hell out of the left lane your slowing me down, no need to call 911 as I have my own cell phone and if I want them to know I will turn myself in!!!



   
ReplyQuote
Craig
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 349
 

WAHOONBOX probably made a bad analogy with the "speeding" comment. I get his point but we are talking about 2 different things.

Lets try this ................. stealing inventory from work, at least that is how I see it. If you come in my shop and try walking out with product, regardless of whether it is $ 5 or $ 500, we are gonna have a problem.

Taking fish that don't belong to you, same deal......... stealing from the masses.

It was the charters responsibility to throw the fish back and uphold the regs, it is their neck on the line.

I don't condone taking it if the season is closed. Granted, the season being closed is BS but it is what it is. Are there guys that do it, obviously, am I gonna fish with them, not knowingly.

Capt of the boat is liable, boat owner or driver ... # 2.

We should all be playing by the same rules. If you want to risk it, potentially getting caught, that is your call. I got too much at stake to fish on a boat like that.

You won't find any fillets on my boat, then again, I will admit my boat doesn't run nearly as much as I used to since the regs are killing us.

You think $ 20 a pound for grouper is alot of money when you figure out how much gas you burn, wait till they hit you with all the fines, will be more like $ 200 a pound......... not worth the risk.

If you think it is, you are probably better at the casino than I am.....



   
ReplyQuote
Capt Bud Wegner
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 65
 

Marlin Maniac made some really valid points. If we were all in charge of paying the government out of our wages, a lot of this crap would have stopped decades ago, but here we are with no real way to show our disdain for the regulations being put on us, so some make their own rules. When it comes to fishing it's a lot like dog hunting, they claim tradition and it's how we've always done it, and fishing is no different, lifetimers that make their living on the water tend to do like they want. The smart ones NEVER open their mouth about it. The rest of us who look upon fishing as a priviledge and I'm sure many LEO's will say that it is, tend to at least want to believe that our tax dollars are paying for information and data to be collected that's even half right.
Problem is, it's not! Even when we try to prove it, the powers that be poo poo, us.
So it comes down to doing what you believe is right, and the others will do what they do. But to think anyone is stealing from anyone else is crap also. None of us own the damn fish, we have dominion over them. Problem is we've allowed our tax dollars to proxy our rights. That's gotta change fellas!!!



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

I don't condone it and my boat is not gonna do it, even though I can understand why some would want to, I'm not a big fan of the rules but I haven't ever stooped to taking undersize fish or fish that are closed, no matter how tempting, but I'm not gonna rat a guy out either, I've saw it happen and that leaves a bad taste in your mouth too, really hard to believe a charter guy would do it so blatantly, he's asking for trouble.



   
ReplyQuote
charlie neal
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 231
 

It might be time to look at ARS stamps..........Just like in FL for the snook.JMI.We have been doing a few bottom trips this yr and i know that i have seen 3 30in ARS flot off never to swim again.



   
ReplyQuote
Scott Armstrong
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 967
 

We release them per the regs, vent, circle hooks, etc..they rarely survive. We had one a few weeks ago that took a 8/0 circle to the gills, bled out before we even could get the hook out. Floated away, could do nothing about it. At least a cuda or a shark will have a tasty snack!

Allow a 2 fish per vessel, per trip. That would satisfy me. The fish yield allot of meat and 4 fillets is plenty.



   
ReplyQuote
warren barton
(@rockhound)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 946
 

Thats Sucks...I'm sorry but they will go home with me before they float off.I try to do everything I can to let them survive,but if they are gill hooked,dead at boat,they are in for a boat ride!



   
ReplyQuote
Tommy
(@shocktreatment)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 606
 

So what do you say if the man catches you with the fish rockhound? No matter what you tell them they will not believe you and you hold a ticket, At some point I can see them wanting to take a person's boat is fish are taken out of season, sorta like deer hunting where they will take you truck and guns.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris Zoubek
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 2585
Topic starter  

So what do you say if the man catches you with the fish rockhound? No matter what you tell them they will not believe you and you hold a ticket, At some point I can see them wanting to take a person's boat is fish are taken out of season, sorta like deer hunting where they will take you truck and guns.

Im fairly certain they already have the right to do that



   
ReplyQuote
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 1034
 

So what do you say if the man catches you with the fish rockhound? No matter what you tell them they will not believe you and you hold a ticket, At some point I can see them wanting to take a person's boat is fish are taken out of season, sorta like deer hunting where they will take you truck and guns.

Im fairly certain they already have the right to do that



   
ReplyQuote
warren barton
(@rockhound)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 946
 

Sure they do!.they damn can near about do what they want.But i'm talkin bout a single fish.I don't know who said it but "fillet and release".comes to mind.I'll take the chance"roll the dice"as they say.I much rather feed myself before I release a doomed fish.Damned if you do!damned if you don't!.



   
ReplyQuote
Scott Armstrong
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 967
 

With the amount of $$ I just invested into a new boat, the gear, the time and effort involved, I am not going to jeapordize all of that for a fish. Law is Law, they can keep the fish. Besides we catch plenty of Grouper, Snapper and Mahi to keep the cooler full. So until the rules change, people will make a decision at that time that is best for them, they take the risk, I will not judge if they take a dead fish, but to fill a secret hold? thats a wide open 'F YOU' to the law. Not saying taking A (1) dead one is ok, let me close that opening before anyone takes that angle, but I wouldnt be mad if someone told me they took one fish that didnt make it..

We discussed the subject this morning, my offshore guys and I did some early Flounder fishing, we all agreed that even 1 fish per boat per day would be a start. Let us keep 1. Something has to give

It is such a touchy subject, I can not lean either way. But I get both sides......

Man, I cannot wait to eat an ARS, hopefully this fall!!!



   
ReplyQuote
james34
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 234
 

With the amount of $$ I just invested into a new boat, the gear, the time and effort involved, I am not going to jeapordize all of that for a fish. Law is Law, they can keep the fish. Besides we catch plenty of Grouper, Snapper and Mahi to keep the cooler full. So until the rules change, people will make a decision at that time that is best for them, they take the risk, I will not judge if they take a dead fish, but to fill a secret hold? thats a wide open 'F YOU' to the law. Not saying taking A (1) dead one is ok, let me close that opening before anyone takes that angle, but I wouldnt be mad if someone told me they took one fish that didnt make it..

We discussed the subject this morning, my offshore guys and I did some early Flounder fishing, we all agreed that even 1 fish per boat per day would be a start. Let us keep 1. Something has to give

It is such a touchy subject, I can not lean either way. But I get both sides......

Man, I cannot wait to eat an ARS, hopefully this fall!!!

Secret hold?? Pretty sure they just stashed it in the bilge.



   
ReplyQuote
Barry Turano
(@barryturano)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 2720
 

,

With the amount of $$ I just invested into a new boat, the gear, the time and effort involved, I am not going to jeapordize all of that for a fish. Law is Law, they can keep the fish. Besides we catch plenty of Grouper, Snapper and Mahi to keep the cooler full. So until the rules change, people will make a decision at that time that is best for them, they take the risk, I will not judge if they take a dead fish, but to fill a secret hold? thats a wide open 'F YOU' to the law. Not saying taking A (1) dead one is ok, let me close that opening before anyone takes that angle, but I wouldnt be mad if someone told me they took one fish that didnt make it..

We discussed the subject this morning, my offshore guys and I did some early Flounder fishing, we all agreed that even 1 fish per boat per day would be a start. Let us keep 1. Something has to give

It is such a touchy subject, I can not lean either way. But I get both sides......

Man, I cannot wait to eat an ARS, hopefully this fall!!!

Secret hold?? Pretty sure they just stashed it in the bilge. that is still a "Secret hold"it is not holding the other fish caught. And the fish were deliberately put there to keep them out of sight.



   
ReplyQuote
Barry Turano
(@barryturano)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 2720
 

,

With the amount of $$ I just invested into a new boat, the gear, the time and effort involved, I am not going to jeapordize all of that for a fish. Law is Law, they can keep the fish. Besides we catch plenty of Grouper, Snapper and Mahi to keep the cooler full. So until the rules change, people will make a decision at that time that is best for them, they take the risk, I will not judge if they take a dead fish, but to fill a secret hold? thats a wide open 'F YOU' to the law. Not saying taking A (1) dead one is ok, let me close that opening before anyone takes that angle, but I wouldnt be mad if someone told me they took one fish that didnt make it..

We discussed the subject this morning, my offshore guys and I did some early Flounder fishing, we all agreed that even 1 fish per boat per day would be a start. Let us keep 1. Something has to give

It is such a touchy subject, I can not lean either way. But I get both sides......

Man, I cannot wait to eat an ARS, hopefully this fall!!!

Secret hold?? Pretty sure they just stashed it in the bilge. that is still a "Secret hold"it is not holding the other fish caught. And the fish were deliberitly out there to keep them out of sight



   
ReplyQuote
Page 5 / 7
Share: