SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

Inshore Nets

205 Posts
52 Users
0 Reactions
8,044 Views
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

What is the end goal with a net ban? Is it a reduction in commercial landings and increase in recreational landings? :chin:

Seriously? It is the end of the indiscriminate massacre and destruction of everybody's resource.

And the re-building of fish stocks.

Other states can't be wrong; they have a successful commercial fishery, a successful recreational fishery, and a healthy fish population.

You know what we have in our inshore waters, Chris? Tons and tons of free swimming baitfish - with few predators in sight.

Sickening and so is the continuation of this senseless slaughter for the benefit of so few. And those few can follow the lead of successful fishing practices proven in other states.

And we can terminate this out-dated, destructive practice.

Now Chris, are you baiting us with that question so that you can cherry pick your response?

Bottom Line:

We can make North Carolina's inshore fishing great again (paraphrasing a popular campaign promise), for everyone - but we need to ditch outdated practices.



   
ReplyQuote
Will
 Will
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 35
 

Abundance, Chris... Sure, it will lead to an eventual increase in Recreational landings. An increase that will have a great economic impact on the state (red drum, trout and flounder are worth many many more times their commercial price when caught by recreational fisherman), and the sustainable gig and pound flounder fisheries will benefit too. Hook and line commercial fishing for trout and red drum could be possible then also. Right now it's ILLEGAL to harvest red drum commercially with hook and line... Why? To preserve status quo and continued use of gill nets... NCDMF, under the leadership of Louis Daniel has a track record to prove it. The price would also go up for red drum, trout and even flounder, I'm sure, and the quality will be much better.

Abundance is good for everyone.



   
ReplyQuote
Will
 Will
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 35
 

Don't forget that many of the people crying out for the nets to be removed, especially the ones on here, just want more fish in the water. It's not just about recs wanting more fish to keep and eat. We want there to be red drum, trout, flounder, spots, croakers, gray trout etc. to catch 10 years from now. We want there to be fish to catch for our future generations.



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Smith
(@wildcard)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 1573
 

What is the end goal with a net ban? Is it a reduction in commercial landings and increase in recreational landings? :chin:[/quot

The same mind set when folks not originally from here buy a piece of land to retire on. The "posted" signs go up, regardless of what the Community has done for generations. Next they get into the local political scene and try to make it exactly like where they came from. The native population is thought to be dumber than a box of rocks, it's been that way for as long as I can remember. Then they wonder why we aren't all warm and fuzzy to outsiders. Not saying all are like this by any means, everyone wants their own utopia.



   
ReplyQuote
jonathan
(@jward87)
Estimable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 120
 

If all the other states have such good commercial fishing then why is it everybody say nc provide 90% of the seafood.



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

What is the end goal with a net ban? Is it a reduction in commercial landings and increase in recreational landings? :chin:[/quot

The same mind set when folks not originally from here buy a piece of land to retire on. The "posted" signs go up, regardless of what the Community has done for generations. Next they get into the local political scene and try to make it exactly like where they came from. The native population is thought to be dumber than a box of rocks, it's been that way for as long as I can remember. Then they wonder why we aren't all warm and fuzzy to outsiders. Not saying all are like this by any means, everyone wants their own utopia.

Which sector generates more $$$ and jobs? Commercial or recreational? Why should recreational businesses be punished for the greed of the few?

Let the people decide since it's their resource.

______________________________________________________________

** Source - Comparing NOAA’s Recreational and Commercial Fishing
Economic Data http://asafishing.org/uploads/Comparing_Recreational_and_Commercial_Marine_Fishing_Data_Report_May_2013.pdf

In 2011 recreational anglers landed 204.9 million pounds of saltwater fish. In pursuit of these fish, saltwater anglers spent $26.8 billion on fishing tackle and equipment and trip-related goods and services. Including multiplier effects, their spending generated $70.3 billion in economic output (sales), created $32.5 billion in value-added growth and supported 454,542 jobs with $20.5 billion in income.

Commercial fishermen in the U.S. landed 9.9 billion pounds of fin- and shellfish in 2011 valued at $5.3 billion. Finfish represented 86 percent of the total commercial landings by weight and 49 percent of the total value, at 8.5 billion pounds and $2.6 billion respectively
.
Of the commercial sector’s landings, 4.9 billion finfish pounds were the same species frequently targeted by anglers, with a landed value of $2.1 billion.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenny
(@mojohalibut)
Reputable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 220
 

And there you have it........and I believe he speaks for the majority......its all about ending commercial fishing. Never mind the impacts of development and its associated storm water runoff, never mind the over all increase in pressure on the stocks from more and more people moving to the coast and fishing with the aid of the "net" and modern electronics and better gear. Its all about the money, right? Is it the money or who profits from this money? More money being made by dining at restaurants and purchasing tackle and boats etc.....is OK, but not OK if it is caught and sold to someone that cannot catch their own. Interesting how so many fisherman (fisher people?) are concerned about removing commercial fishing from being an impact on the fishery yet have no issue at all with the ever increasing numbers of those fishing or with the explosion of development at the coast. Commercial fishing and its methods can be modified but you cannot say the same for development and its impact.

There is a butt load more people here now than there used to be and it is not going to slow down. It seems to me that the vision of a red drum in a net is viewed the same way as a dead dog on the road while a drum laying in the sand or being handled for photos is harmless. We all have an impact. Answer this, can there be too many "non commercial" fisherman?



   
ReplyQuote
Kenny
(@mojohalibut)
Reputable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 220
 

We need real science, not govt BS and agendas. First and Formost we need to protect our fisheries. Second, we have to establish what is an allowable take from the resource. Third, we must now divide the allowable take amongst the two primary user groups. Without the fish we all lose.



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

"And there you have it........and I believe he speaks for the majority.."

Majority should rule.

Commercial is concentrated to a few business owners making millions off of OUR resource due to antiquated regulations and dirty politics.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenny
(@mojohalibut)
Reputable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 220
 

You just helped make my point. I have never made "millions" and am a 1 man business like so many others. I amazes me how many "experts" we have on the Internet.

"majority rule". Nice selfish attitude sport. Are you a charter captain? That is also commercial fishing buddy



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

First, I care as much about you guys as you care about sharing the catch.

Re-read the statistics above. Don't school me on caring.

Most of the 1 man operators do so in addition to their full time job. Recs net too. It's not just you.

Do you think the majority of the commercial harvest is done by 1 man operators?



   
ReplyQuote
Jim Bickerstaff
(@sobachka)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 222
 

What is the end goal with a net ban? Is it a reduction in commercial landings and increase in recreational landings? :chin:

I think that is an excellent question. Why does one have to exclude the other? I will state what my end goal would be and how I would approach it.

Let's start with some basic immovable objects:
1) It is unreasonable and unacceptable to expect a person to completely abandon his or her livelihood.
2) Recreational fishing and the economic tsunami that follows with it is not going away.
3) The only variable that we can influence is the number of fish available for both to survive and maybe flourish.

And add some facts:

1) If we keep going in the same direction and arguing over who is most at fault, none of us will have what we want and we will all be buying farmed fish from Indonesia ... or eating a hell of a lot more chicken.
2) Compromise means giving up something you want to get something you want even more.

To address the problem directly, I believe we have to protect the nursery and increase the output of juvenile fish at the same time.
1) Establish hatcheries for every species at risk and make these hatcheries nimble and flexible so that they can shift species with minimum cost and effort as weaknesses are identified. The availability of forage for this additional wave of predators must be a part of the equation. Oyster seeding is an example of money well spent in my opinion. Artificial reef programs is another. Issues of pollution and runoff have to be addressed as well but let's eat one elephant at a time.
2) Eliminate most commercial nets and trawls inside the Colregs line. There is no question in my mind that these mass and indiscriminate collection techniques are putting too much pressure on the resource when combined with all other pressures. By themselves these methods would never kill all of the fish but it is clearly the biggest impact with the lowest return (on whole) and it is the straw that is breaking the camel's back. A trial period would be something to consider if that is the compromise, say five years and see what happens to the populations.
3) Develop a fair method to determine exactly what a "commercial fisherman" is and eliminate casual (weekend warrior) commercial fishing. If this is truly your livelihood, fish on ... but if a license is being abused to kill 1000# of fish in a weekend just to support a fishing hobby and a 900 HP rocket boat, that is a problem. One solution, use whatever gear your license and income supports but the limits are the same as all recreational fishermen. Or quit your day job and dive in with the big boys. Maybe that is too harsh and not fairly considering your point of view. After all, you spend tons of cash in the local economies, far more than a weekend tourist. How about a weekend warrior "semi-commercial" license with an annual renewal rate of $XXX.00 for a starting point in a reasoned negotiation?
4) Fund enough officers and patrols to significantly increase box inspections and make the fines crippling on the first offense, terminal on second offense, both Rec and Com. If some will not play by the rules, they don't play at all in North Carolina and can buy their fish at Haag's and Clem's.
5) Establish a buy back program to reimburse commercial fishermen for their investments in gill nets and other banned equipment so that they can adapt by investing in technology that allows them to remain profitable. I don't know any rich commercial fishermen. But I do know their kids have to eat and go to college too.

Where do we get all that money?

Raise the price of licenses to whatever number is needed to accomplish the things presented. Legitimate commercial license fees should not be increased but it should take an act of God to get one and the licenses that are not part of a legitimate and ongoing livelihood investment should be purchased by the state at a set value and eliminated. Possibly an alternate and very expensive "high poundage" license can be created that allows sales. Piers and charters are already paying their way but a look should be taken at what is equitable. I think piers are probably overpaying considering what they return to the economy and many people who fish on piers simply can't afford a boat or a charter after they go to Joe Bob's Tackle and buy everything they need to fish on their only vacation of the year. The cost for tourist pier and beach fishing should not be increased in my opinion; they have negligible impact on the resource and bring plenty of money to the table.

That leaves me unfortunately ... and I will happily pay more if that is what it takes to do what I love more than any outside activity. The cost of my license pales in comparison to what I pay for gas, Mirrolures, Fluorocarbon line, Gulp shrimp, Beanie Weenies and countless other bullshit I take great pleasure in buying. If it takes $100 licenses to save the fisheries, count me in. I may have to take one less trip to BassPro, whatever. BUT, if I accept additional investment on my part, I demand accountability, not some slush fund that the government in Raleigh can raid every time they create an emergency from overspending on something else.

If a clear and fixed period of reduced recreational landings (and commercial for that matter) are considered to quicken the recovery, I can agree with that as well.

To answer the quoted question; I propose we increase both commercial and recreational landings in the best ways it can be done. That is my whole and only agenda in this conversation. All of my proposals have room for adjustment; How much? How fast? How do we define this or that? Fair enough but those questions must be answered with honest conversation and a willingness of everyone invested to approach this problem from the other person's point of view. One thing is clear to me and that is we need to solve this problem in North Carolina before some pompous ass in Nebraska or New York, with their own political agenda and no clue or care what this is really about, smells a profit in "helping" us solve it.

Increasing box weight for both commercial and recreational fisher-people will require shared pain to achieve shared gain. And anyone who is unwilling to help us shoulder the burden is simply holding their breath until Mom takes the Broccoli off the table. This broccoli ain't going nowhere brothers and sisters. Take a bite or starve.



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

I believe the best way to increase both commercial and recreational limits is to go to a strictly hook and line fishery for both groups, same size limits, same closure times, (which I do not believe will ever be needed again) this is where you will get your most bang for the buck, you do this and you will see more people willing to invest in hatchery's.

Offshore fishing would be even easier to increase the available fish.



   
ReplyQuote
Duane
(@rdnkvet)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 1403
 

And there you have it........and I believe he speaks for the majority......its all about ending commercial fishing. Never mind the impacts of development and its associated storm water runoff, never mind the over all increase in pressure on the stocks from more and more people moving to the coast and fishing with the aid of the "net" and modern electronics and better gear. Its all about the money, right? Is it the money or who profits from this money? More money being made by dining at restaurants and purchasing tackle and boats etc.....is OK, but not OK if it is caught and sold to someone that cannot catch their own. Interesting how so many fisherman (fisher people?) are concerned about removing commercial fishing from being an impact on the fishery yet have no issue at all with the ever increasing numbers of those fishing or with the explosion of development at the coast. Commercial fishing and its methods can be modified but you cannot say the same for development and its impact.

There is a butt load more people here now than there used to be and it is not going to slow down. It seems to me that the vision of a red drum in a net is viewed the same way as a dead dog on the road while a drum laying in the sand or being handled for photos is harmless. We all have an impact. Answer this, can there be too many "non commercial" fisherman?

Thanks for pointing out another reason to protect the estuaries. Pollution and nets needs to be removed. It amazes me how the netters on this forum realize that the stock needs to improve, but cannot understand how killing juvenile fish in the nurseries before they are able to spawn should be an acceptable practice. Maybe we should only shoot the deer with spots. Makes as much sense.



   
ReplyQuote
casey
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 453
 

Hahaha damn do any of you guys ever fish!? Beautiful yesterday and today, just saying......carry on with the debate.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 13 / 14
Share: