SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I find it funny that everyone is catching these "so called" overfished flounder. The flounder fishing in NC has been better the last 2 years than it has in the previous 10 and we are the only state that has closed them on the east coast. The commercial sector is still open because they still have not met their "reduced" quota, once they do they will be closed as well. A very large portion that was open to the commercial harvest will be filled by ocean trawlers returning from the NE and the flounder they harvest are not even from NC but from VA. Instead of fighting with the other user group, commercial vs. recreational, we should be fighting the state as to why their numbers are so bad from their studies. Prime example, according to the NC DMF the charter industry harvested roughly 2,000 lbs of flounder for the entire year for the entire coast. Overfishing and commercial gear are not the problem, distorted studies and their conclusions are.
Two things on this:
1) If i have to pick between a study and a "my buddy is catching more flounder than ever", gotta go with the study. I've been catching a ton lately too, but that flounder had probably been caught by 4 other people that day. Flounder are stupid.
2) People keep on mentioning the NCDMF distorting their studies. What's the incentive for them to fudge the numbers, fishing fine revenue?
The primary reason that southern flounder are still classified as overfished in NC waters is due in no small part to the decision of some of the staff over at the DMF to increase the spr (spawning potential ratio) requirements after these flounder came close to be declared not overfished back in 2010 based on that stock assessment. The spr was raised almost 30% which more or less insured that flounder would always be defined as overfished. Now as to why they did this? who really knows for sure other than they simply have no idea how to properly manage our fish and just pulled some random number out of their arse and went with it. What really ticked me off was when they said that according to their latest assessment flounder were in terrible shape from NC all the way down to Florida and is why the drastic reductions were made this year with more drastic measures being proposed for next year. I am seeing good numbers of flounders along with many other fishermen so I am not buying that BS that southern flounder are almost extinct. I also noticed that SC , Georgia , and Florida are not buying that BS either.
Lol well Juan I don’t know who is doing the “ study’s” but I can tell you from first hand and if you look at any of my post you can see that me and my “Buddys” are still catching these extinct flounder just like we always have in our area..
I find it funny that everyone is catching these "so called" overfished flounder. The flounder fishing in NC has been better the last 2 years than it has in the previous 10 and we are the only state that has closed them on the east coast. The commercial sector is still open because they still have not met their "reduced" quota, once they do they will be closed as well. A very large portion that was open to the commercial harvest will be filled by ocean trawlers returning from the NE and the flounder they harvest are not even from NC but from VA. Instead of fighting with the other user group, commercial vs. recreational, we should be fighting the state as to why their numbers are so bad from their studies. Prime example, according to the NC DMF the charter industry harvested roughly 2,000 lbs of flounder for the entire year for the entire coast. Overfishing and commercial gear are not the problem, distorted studies and their conclusions are.
Two things on this:
1) If i have to pick between a study and a "my buddy is catching more flounder than ever", gotta go with the study. I've been catching a ton lately too, but that flounder had probably been caught by 4 other people that day. Flounder are stupid.
2) People keep on mentioning the NCDMF distorting their studies. What's the incentive for them to fudge the numbers, fishing fine revenue?
I don't think that the DMF is fudging their numbers,but the numbers and studies they are using is what I am questioning. Exactly where are the rec numbers coming from and what percent error is there? When is the last time you were surveyed for your catch? The rest of the east coast is still open, and we are the only state closed.
I even cited that the DMF states that the charter industry caught 2,000 lbs of flounder last year. Where did they come up with this number? This is what we should be concerned about, garbage numbers in, garbage results out.
It's not just flounder they are keeping. I've personally seen a large number of undersized black drum and sheepshead taken home this year and several 40+ inch
redfish get to take a ride too. There are only 3 DMF officers in Brunswick County and they have to patrol from near Little River to Wilmington plus all of the piers and
boats in those areas, both day and night. And only recently get did they get the third officer. People are greedy and many have no idea what the size or creel limits
are. It's a no win situation for them and it's up to ethical fishermen to advise them or even report them.
I find it funny that everyone is catching these "so called" overfished flounder. The flounder fishing in NC has been better the last 2 years than it has in the previous 10 and we are the only state that has closed them on the east coast. The commercial sector is still open because they still have not met their "reduced" quota, once they do they will be closed as well. A very large portion that was open to the commercial harvest will be filled by ocean trawlers returning from the NE and the flounder they harvest are not even from NC but from VA. Instead of fighting with the other user group, commercial vs. recreational, we should be fighting the state as to why their numbers are so bad from their studies. Prime example, according to the NC DMF the charter industry harvested roughly 2,000 lbs of flounder for the entire year for the entire coast. Overfishing and commercial gear are not the problem, distorted studies and their conclusions are.
Two things on this:
1) If i have to pick between a study and a "my buddy is catching more flounder than ever", gotta go with the study. I've been catching a ton lately too, but that flounder had probably been caught by 4 other people that day. Flounder are stupid.
2) People keep on mentioning the NCDMF distorting their studies. What's the incentive for them to fudge the numbers, fishing fine revenue?
I don't think that the DMF is fudging their numbers,but the numbers and studies they are using is what I am questioning. Exactly where are the rec numbers coming from and what percent error is there? When is the last time you were surveyed for your catch? The rest of the east coast is still open, and we are the only state closed.
I even cited that the DMF states that the charter industry caught 2,000 lbs of flounder last year. Where did they come up with this number? This is what we should be concerned about, garbage numbers in, garbage results out.
The post I was referring to mentioned "distorted" studies. But I hear you. I'm catching more than ever as well, but I guess everything after the closure is a bit muddled because we're all catching the same fish over and over (assuming less people are keeping them).
I'd definitely be down with an audit of the estimates/forecasts that they are using. I was just saying that it seems like these threads end up with a lot of people referring to the dreaded "them" as a bunch of idiots in a place like Raleigh who are out to get all of us. Most of the marine fisheries guys I've met are fishermen just like me.
I also know that there will always be fools complaining about anything that equals less keeping of fish no matter what the numbers say and no matter how reliable they are. I do think that if things are as bad as they claim, then commercial should be shut down as well. It would likely have both rec and comm keeping again sooner.
Lot's of ignorance here, The closure is not because a single soul has said "Flounder are almost extinct" if you say that, I can't take you serious any further down. The reason NC is in this predicament now is because of failures to manage over the last 15 years. If you don't want the Federal Government to step in and do what they do, you better be glad NC is doing something. If the Federal Gov decides to step in, sue the state, you won't even be able to fish for a flounder.
Another ignorant posting here says "why leave commercial fishing open"? It doesn't take an IQ of 10 to see that if you close it in August, the majority of the commercial harvest comes in the fall. That's unfair to the commercial guys, and doesn't give them a realistic amount of time to pivot to make a living. You have to at least give them fair warning, which is why the season will be closing for them as well shortly.
It pays to read and understand before you post ignorance on the internet.
Don't consider myself a genius by no means but what I have read looks like to me NCDMF are saying the flounder population is "Almost extinct"......
Reductions in harvest are required because a 2019 South Atlantic Southern Flounder Stock Assessment found that southern flounder is overfished and overfishing is occurring throughout the region (North Carolina through the eastern coast of Florida). Overfished means the population is too small. Overfishing means the removal rate is too high.
North Carolina law mandates that fishery management plans include measures to end overfishing within two years of adoption and rebuild the stock to achieve sustainable harvest within 10 years of adoption of a fishery management plan. NCDEQ-NR-45-2019
"Over fished means the population is to small"
Small population size
Small populations can behave differently from larger populations. They are often the result of a population bottlenecks from larger populations, leading to loss of heterozygosity and reduced genetic diversity and loss or fixation of alleles and shifts in allele frequencies.[1] A small population is then more susceptible to demographic and genetic stochastic events, which can impact the long-term survival of the population. Therefore, small populations are often considered at risk of endangerment or extinction, and are often of conservation concern.
Don't consider myself a genius by no means but what I have read looks like to me NCDMF are saying the flounder population is "Almost extinct"......
Reductions in harvest are required because a 2019 South Atlantic Southern Flounder Stock Assessment found that southern flounder is overfished and overfishing is occurring throughout the region (North Carolina through the eastern coast of Florida). Overfished means the population is too small. Overfishing means the removal rate is too high.
North Carolina law mandates that fishery management plans include measures to end overfishing within two years of adoption and rebuild the stock to achieve sustainable harvest within 10 years of adoption of a fishery management plan. NCDEQ-NR-45-2019
"Over fished means the population is to small"Small population size
Small populations can behave differently from larger populations. They are often the result of a population bottlenecks from larger populations, leading to loss of heterozygosity and reduced genetic diversity and loss or fixation of alleles and shifts in allele frequencies.[1] A small population is then more susceptible to demographic and genetic stochastic events, which can impact the long-term survival of the population. Therefore, small populations are often considered at risk of endangerment or extinction, and are often of conservation concern.
Over fished is the precursor to "almost extinct", if you continue over fishing, you will deplete the stock, look at all the other mess ups in human history, how many people thought there were plenty of this or that? Continue to over harvest, and now they are either endangered or extinct? Sometimes you have to suffer today for a better tomorrow, people say "oh it's the best fishing in years" but that's no measure to what the fishing was 50-60 years ago. We are probably still paying for the wild west days where people could keep whatever.
"DO NOTHING and FLOUNDER DISAPPEAR IN ABOUT TWENTY YEARS", This is copied from part of the NCDMF report on southern flounder and is available to anyone that wishes to read it. My interpretation of that is that if nothing changes in our southern flounder fishing then flounder will disappear from NC waters within 20 years.
"DO NOTHING and FLOUNDER DISAPPEAR IN ABOUT TWENTY YEARS", This is copied from part of the NCDMF report on southern flounder and is available to anyone that wishes to read it. My interpretation of that is that if nothing changes in our southern flounder fishing then flounder will disappear from NC waters within 20 years.
It is also plausible that even if we do something they could disappear if the water warms to temperatures we can't predict or control. There are plenty of things we can control, and plenty of things we cannot control. We have to find a happy balance somewhere, and it will never be a win-win for anyone. There will ALWAYS be moaners, there will ALWAYS be complainers, and there will ALWAYS be unhappy people.
Yep , the nc waters will be void of flounder in about 20 yrs if we don't stop the harvesting now ; the Va flounder won't cross the state line and migrate south , and the SC flounder won't cross the state line and migrate north 🙄 Lets face it folks if you're gonna set the rules what ever they are then fair is fair ; shut it down for all , rec and com , and put teeth in the penalty for a violation ; ie example ; loss of license for extended time or forfiture of vessel .. It was used for the illegal harvesting of deer ,,, just saying !!!
Well I really cant speak any on what it was like "50-60" years ago because i was not around, but again I can tell you first hand we and we meaning me and all the guys I know and fish around still catch flounder in SE N.C just like we did over 30 yrs ago so with that being said that's really all the "Facts" i can contribute to this topic...You gentlemen carry on.
Lot's of ignorance here, The closure is not because a single soul has said "Flounder are almost extinct" if you say that, I can't take you serious any further down. The reason NC is in this predicament now is because of failures to manage over the last 15 years. If you don't want the Federal Government to step in and do what they do, you better be glad NC is doing something. If the Federal Gov decides to step in, sue the state, you won't even be able to fish for a flounder.
Another ignorant posting here says "why leave commercial fishing open"? It doesn't take an IQ of 10 to see that if you close it in August, the majority of the commercial harvest comes in the fall. That's unfair to the commercial guys, and doesn't give them a realistic amount of time to pivot to make a living. You have to at least give them fair warning, which is why the season will be closing for them as well shortly.
It pays to read and understand before you post ignorance on the internet.
With this logic....does that mean the recreational side is better at catching flounder before August than the commercial segment? It's all fake numbers with dollars being stuffed in pockets.
BACK IN END OF OCT. I WAS GETTING FUEL AT HOMER SMITHS AND THE DOCK GUY SAID THEY JUST SENT A TRUCK TO DAVIS TO
PICK UP 4200 POUNDS OF FLOUNDER AND THAT IS FAIR TO ALL?