SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Agree with many of the comments. Suspect if you move the fisheries management debate out of "On the Hill" then those that don't care about won't vist and continue to use On the Hill for fishing related posts that don't fit in the other forums.
I personally like having a name associated with your posting name and have always provided when an option.
But do like the more diverse group of posters vs other websites. :spin:
Many of us I am sure are just tired of reading the bla bla bla that some of the so called commercial shit stirrers actually do ,,,, There are a couple on here that they copy & paste and run around in a circle but never says a thing but a bash on the Rec Fisherman ,,,, It has gotten old ,,,,,,, If I look on the thread and I see their name in the thread I don't read it any more ,,,,, Really the only people they impress are themselves cause to most of us in the fishing world they are a has been that are searching for their last air bubble
Thanks for the reality check John, it can be hard to see how one's posts are perceived by others. I am more guilty than most of perpetuating some of these arguments. I try to support constructive dialog and respond to insults with facts supporting my position, rather than with worse insults. That doesn't seem to be working for the most part.
If you don't want to read the arguments don't click on the thread. Problem solved.
ADMIN goes on deleting things and regulating what you can and can not say (outside of the existing rules agreed to on site registration) then we have NCW PART II
Buc that is kinda what happened when some of those came here after getting the Hammer from the waterman
One of the other things I have thought about is the use of REAL NAMES.
Dave
:wtg: Best idea IMHO
I just don't add to the argument most of the time. If I disagree with someone, I generally just move on but I can understand how some people don't like reading it.
Someone PM'd me one time on here when I got into one of the arguments and made me realize, not everyone is going to see things my way and once an argument gets to insults, best thing to do is ignore the post. Best advice ever.
My real name is Wesley Atkins and I live in Danville VA and fish out of Oak Island. I ain't scared for anyone to know who I am. 🙂
I was going to suggest real names, as well, but it was late.
Buddy Roe., I know that avatar is not your real pic, but if I thought you were in the room, that is who I would be looking for.
Two things surprised me this morning:
The ON THE HILL forum link says,"Let's Talk Fishing". I thought it was more of a general forum.
I seldom look at STICKYS, because they seldom change, but there are no OTH Forum Guidelines.
Actually, a third thing, I never knew a lot of the other forums even existed, until I just read the whole list.
Dave, just an after thought.
Is there an option available the author of the topic could select that as a prerequisite requires real name disclosure in order to post on a particular topic ?
Buddy Roe., I know that avatar is not your real pic, but if I thought you were in the room, that is who I would be looking for.
Thanks for the compliment, will surely keep it in mind.
Perhaps the picture is easily recognized, I just don't know the character. It was not meant to be a negative comment, but more to illustrate the power of association, and perhaps the false impressions related to anonymous screen names.
Real names would be fine, except that there have been threats issued by some. Here and on other forums by same individuals using different handles on various other forums. You kind of figure out who is whom.
Maybe they only threaten because they can hide behind a keyboard, but the old "meet me down at the docks" comment can only be construed as a threat IMHO.
And I don't take kindly to being theatened.
Maybe a Responsible Fishing section would help. I only visit a couple specific sections on the site but usually look at New Forum Posts 1st, which gets a little of everything.
And, I can and do just ignore threads and individuals I have no interest in reading.
I don't see backing down though, just because one group is beating you down for your views. That is un-American.
One of the other things I have thought about is the use of REAL NAMES. No hiding allowed. The majority of us are not hiding at all. I personally stand behind every word I have ever said and all it takes is 2 seconds on Google to find me.
Dave
Dave,
This! Not being able to hid behind a computer would eliminate 95% of the problems. It would also bring having respect to the fore front of these heated discussions as everyone would then be accountable for what they say and do.
I watched as NCwaterman and sportfishing.com went down the drain over a few bad apples when their non-stop trolling ran off the good fisherman, professional captains & watermen. Once a forum loses these assets the deal is done... game over. This is one step I feel would really save FPT from going down the same path.
Capt. Jon Tennant
In general there are a bunch of good people on this forum and I have met a couple in person that proved the point. Namely, Pucker and Bharbaugh. We all will always have different views about things but most of us all have one thing in common. We love to fish. My name is Johnny Carpenter, I fish out of Harkers Island, I drink beer and love dogs, although my name says otherwise. I actually carried it over from a predator forum as I am pretty good at calling them critters to the gun. I am an electrical contractor by trade. Here I am with my girlfriend Paige and my little buddy Rocky. I have a camper at Cape Point Marina. So if you are in the area and see us, stop by, introduce yourself, and have a cold one. Everybody but Pucker, He drinks too much. LOL
Some very good suggestions.
I like the separate forum for those that wish to argue a subject into the ground, just keep it off Up on the Hill. That one is for fishing related questions, tips, etc.
I in no way think anyone should not be allowed to express their opinion, or disagree, but at a point it becomes a shouting match with no good outcomes. I think Dave's reference to RESPECT hit the nail on the head.
Also, there are a whole lot of great people on this site. Heck, I've fished with over a hundred of them, and made a lot of good friends.
Let's keep FPT the best fishing site anywhere.
Thanks,
John McDow
It's not just you John as this thread demonstrates ... I myself voiced fustration a month or 2 on ago on a thread with two trollers who have not demonstrated any added value with posts (in the 000's) to any Forum on this board ... alluded in some previous posts on this thread is "bad apples" brought down several other sites ... it is getting close here and I will support real names and plucking the bad apples out of the barrell before it all spoils. Tight lines and enjoy fishing as it may be your last trip ...
Gary Gilbert