SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
With all the knowledge that is available at the click of a mouse, you'd think kids would start school "smarter" and advance more rapidly than the old days when you had to go to a library to satisfy your curiosity or research for a paper, etc. Any parent that wants to take the time to spend with their child, has exponentially more resources at their disposal to prepare their child for school than my parents, and especially my grandparents.
But they show up dumb. They show up with no basic social skills. They show up with no respect for authority, much less the other children. The teachers aren't failing these kids, the parents are failing these kids. The teachers have become babysitters, law enforcement officers, child psychotherapists, school fundraisers, and translators, leaving little time for them to "teach".
The status of the education system is little more than a symptom of a decaying society, not a cause.
My son has been teaching math in a Durham high school for 5 years and was teacher of the year this year. I don't think he has missed 5 days in five years, and when I asked him about taking a Friday off for a family get-together, he said that he would have to pay $100/day for a substitute out of his own pocket. So, I'm not buying all the free sick leave and 'personal days' off bullshit.
As far as getting summers off, he has to sign a contract each year, from the first day of school to the last. Then he is LAID OFF FOR THE SUMMER, and has to hope that he has his job in the fall, every year for 25-30 years. How's that for job security?My favorite bumper sticker is, "My kid is an honor student, my Governor is a moron."
The handbook states that teachers must pay 50 bucks per day for a substitute to fill in. That does not apply for leave taken on teacher workdays. Substitutes are required if students are in school. 11.1.5 Deduction from the Teacher’s Salary
When a deduction is required to be made from the teacher’s salary, the deduction shall be $50.00 per day.
Jason, I think what is actually happening is that the gap between the top and bottom of the class has just gotten much larger. There are many who do take advantage of the opportunities that you suggest, and in reality, those students are smarter, better educated, more socially aware, and better prepared for the future than we ever were. What magic advantage did our summer jobs mowing grass, pumping gas, working tobacco or textiles ever give us, that we should look down our noses at recent generations, and wish for the good old days. Growing up poor in a small NC town in the 50's and 60's, you had to do something major, even if only join the military, to escape the cycle and see some of the world with your own eyes. Sadly, and obviously, too many did not take advantage of the opportunity, even if they took the step.
Jason, I think what is actually happening is that the gap between the top and bottom of the class has just gotten much larger. There are many who do take advantage of the opportunities that you suggest, and in reality, those students are smarter, better educated, more socially aware, and better prepared for the future than we ever were. What magic advantage did our summer jobs mowing grass, pumping gas, working tobacco or textiles ever give us, that we should look down our noses at recent generations, and wish for the good old days. Growing up poor in a small NC town in the 50's and 60's, you had to do something major, even if only join the military, to escape the cycle and see some of the world with your own eyes. Sadly, and obviously, too many did not take advantage of the opportunity, even if they took the step.
Back in the good ol' days, you didn't have as many broken homes, or drug addicted parents. Blaming the teachers, or the kids for that matter, is misguided. Like I mentioned, the state of education is a symptom, not a cause, in my opinion.
I am not comparing class room sizes. For instance the elementary school down the road from me has 11 full time teachers and 108 students. To me that works out to be about a 9 to 1 ratio. Perhaps California is out of compliance, but if they are getting the job done with far less teachers then whats the problem? I will end this on my part by simple saying that it looks like some teachers are underpaid for sure but there are obviously more than a few that are overpaid.
Pretty sure not all of those teachers are teaching one classroom so your premise is faulty. At least 2-4 of those 11 teachers are teaching special education which is now divided into about 4 main areas with mandatory specialists in each area to include learning disability, behaviorial, autism, speech just to name a few etc.
My wife retired two years ago from special ed and her last year she had she did not have the mandatory planning period or lunch. She ate going from one room to the other.
She had to write multiple Individual Development Plans for about 20 kids up to twice a year late at night as no time at school.
However, the system is loaded with bureacrats at the school boards.
Definitely one of the best paying part time jobs anywhere.
Definitely one of the best paying part time jobs anywhere.
You are totally clueless making that statement.
4 year Bachelors degree, salary just raised to $35,000 and 45,000 after 20 years.
Mandatory summer classes and training throughout the year year to maintain teaching certificate. Many districts are on all year calendar and you still have to take the mandatory training at nights or weekends.
Every special ed student has to have an IEP updated 2x a year that is after an evening meeting with the parents and you stay up late writing 10-15 pages on each IEP. You have to have written lesson plans for every hour of every day.
If it is so great a deal, get off your butt and get certified. They are always short teachers as "it is such the best paying part time job."
Definitely one of the best paying part time jobs anywhere.
You are totally clueless making that statement.
4 year Bachelors degree, salary just raised to $35,000 and 45,000 after 20 years.
Mandatory summer classes and training throughout the year year to maintain teaching certificate. Many districts are on all year calendar and you still have to take the mandatory training at nights or weekends.
Every special ed student has to have an IEP updated 2x a year that is after an evening meeting with the parents and you stay up late writing 10-15 pages on each IEP. You have to have written lesson plans for every hour of every day.
If it is so great a deal, get off your butt and get certified. They are always short teachers as "it is such the best paying part time job."
so why not pursue a different career path rather than enter education?
I don't understand why anyone would mind what a teacher makes or for what anyone makes. That's up to that person. Heck I don't think 40,000.00 is that much. A person can make more doing other things for sure but teaching is a calling and the good ones are drawn to it. Doctors are highly educated but not all doctors are good.
Just curious, how many folks that have posted and/or responded to this topic are actually teachers or have family members that are in the business? I am (over 20 years and its my second career) and can tell you that there is a lot of misinformation swirling around. Definitely not a "part-time job" and the pay is very marginal. Would not be there for the money for sure. But I love my job.
If you are a teacher, you do not do it for the money.. In fact the amount of money I spend yearly on children that aren't mine is a lot of fishing tackle! For a person with a masters degree 40-50k is nothing.
Like I stated, this is my second career. What I have realized in 47 years is that money is not everything. It is important due to feeding the family, taxes, mortgages, etc but peace of mind and enjoying what you do everyday is equally important. We all pay taxes that go to the school systems across the state and we all spend money on children that are not our own. It may very difficult to relate the feeling of seeing an underprivileged child go on to be a productive member of our society and just maybe you had a hand in the process.
About the 40-50K is nothing, the 2014 US census noted that the average per household income in NC was $53K and the average per capita income was 28K.
You seem to be an intelligent chap so maybe you can see both sides of the story.
Like I stated, this is my second career. What I have realized in 47 years is that money is not everything. It is important due to feeding the family, taxes, mortgages, etc but peace of mind and enjoying what you do everyday is equally important. We all pay taxes that go to the school systems across the state and we all spend money on children that are not our own. It may very difficult to relate the feeling of seeing an underprivileged child go on to be a productive member of our society and just maybe you had a hand in the process.
About the 40-50K is nothing, the 2014 US census noted that the average per household income in NC was $53K and the average per capita income was 28K.
You seem to be an intelligent chap so maybe you can see both sides of the story.
You missed my point/post, my wife is a teacher with a masters degree (so yes,36-40K for a masters degree is not a lot of money in mind. 50K by retirement for most teachers after 20 years?) And the money we spend in her classroom for her students supplies (that is what i was referring to when i said it was a lot of tackle, not my tax money) is a lot of extra money for someone who makes 36-40K. She does it because she loves it, not for the money.
And I do see both sides, we also sponsor children for the backpack program in her school every year.
I did miss your point and defer. You and your wife should be commended for your generosity. Teachers are the first ones that have to come up with funds to cover the lack of funding. Your wife can certainly relate and, as her husband, you become part of the process. God bless you and your family for what you do for the kids.
Dell Godwin
Douglas Byrd HS
Fayetteville, NC
I'm going to piggyback on some comments made in the other thread that touched on NC teachers.
First, thanks for the positive comments from several folks. It is appreciated.
A big part of the issue most teachers have with the current legislation is every term in the last several years, every time they "give" us something, they take something away.
-Teaching fellow scholarships (recognized nationally as a good thing-- was a great way to target some of our best and brightest students to bring them into the teaching profession). This was completely dissolved three years ago.
-Masters pay. One way teachers could increase their pay was by obtaining their master's degree. This was done away with three years ago as well. So now the only way a teacher can increase their pay in NC is get their National Board's Certification, or go into administration (which takes teachers out of the classroom).
-Longevity pay. This was taken away. Actually it was "rolled in" with our raises two or three years ago.
-Veteran teachers. These raises the last few years have gone largely to younger teachers. They deserve it. Most teachers leave the profession in the first 4 years, so that's where a lot of the raises were focused. Teachers with 20+ years of experience have received very little. So going back to the recession, I personally have seen very little increase. I think in the last ten years, I've gotten 1.3% one year, 1.7% one year, and nothing else since. Again, luck of the draw being one of the veterans (by the way..guess which teachers mentor the newbies, help with transitions of new administration coming in, and generally keep things running smoothly in the average school?).
And I keep beating this drum, but no one is listening. We are pushing away good candidates from considering teaching as a profession. Ask any administrator you know and as what their field of candidates is like now compared to 5 years ago, 10 years ago. Many of the best are going into other professions, private schools or out of state, and we have fewer entering the profession (see how our in-state schools teacher education programs enrollment has dropped). This at a time when teaching is harder than it's ever been.
I could give dozens of examples of teachers leaving the profession. I know one guy that quit teaching to start his own power-washing business a few years ago. We have a teacher that just retired and is going to teach in South Carolina-- he wanted to stay at our school but financially it was crazy for him to stay.
My wife left the public school and is teaching at a great private school and received a big raise, and has gotten a minimum 3.5% raise each year she's been there. They have recruited me like crazy-- I have six years left and I can retire and I'd be an idiot not to run then. It's a shame, because I love where I am but financially I really won't have a choice.
Sorry to get long-winded on this but as you can tell I'm pretty passionate about this topic.