SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
All we hear from the asshats at SAFMC is that they don't have the money to do this, don't have the money to do that.
So when their puppet masters at the radical eco groups push MPAs and some (Chris Mcaffity gets credit here) offer a solution that says instead of closing off known areas, create new ones and close them off the SAFMC falls back on the lack of funds effort.
Well... do they have a penny?
http://www.weeklystandard.com/blogs/us-sells-navys-first-super-carrier-one-penny_764632.html
Sure it would cost more than a penny to implement this as an artificial reef, but it could be a start
I saw that and what struck me was it looked as though the ship was decontaminated and stripped down for sinking. Someone may have paid a penny but I bet the kick back cost much more.
I saw that on the news and thought the same thing. The recycling company that paid a penny for the ship is probably the same one running the Idle Iron program that is blowing up decommissioned oil rigs along with all the marine life living around them. http://www.grindtv.com/outdoor/post/report-federal-government-is-killing-thousands-of-red-snapper-in-gulf/
We paid that penny....that is the Navy paid the penny. The ship was not sold we paid to have it taken away to be taken apart and resold! Source: Stars and Stripes editorial correction
I always thought it would be cool to let the Air Force sink a decommissioned ship by bombing it for practice. Boaters could pay to watch from a safe distance to cover the cost of stripping and cleaning the ship. That would be a great dive site and MPA. Divers could agree not to harm anything while taking photos and collecting data for being allowed to dive on the MPA. Mooring buoys could mark the MPA perimeter so no anchors would disturb the habitat.
I was thinking that the Forrestal would have made a great wreck. I was last on it in 2002 in Newport, RI. I was impressed by its size....I can only imagine the habitat it could provide.
Matador...I think you are correct. I'm pretty sure they moved it to Philly to the Navy Yard after Newport and decontaminated it.
If anyone has some extra bucks sitting around and wants a reef named after them it might not be a bad idea to see what other ships are sitting up in Philly that might get put to good use…after I typed this I figured I’d research it myself….here they are:
As of April 8, 2013:
USNS Hayes (T-AG-195) - Stricken, to be disposed of
USNS Mohawk (T-ATF-170) - Inactive, out of service, in reserve
USS Boone (FFG-28) - Inactive, out of commission, in reserve
USS Boulder (LST-1190) - Stricken, to be disposed of
USS Canon (PG-90) - Stricken, available for donation as a museum and memorial
USS Carr (FFG-52) - Possible foreign sale
USS Charles F. Adams (DDG-2) - Stricken, available for donation as a museum and memorial
USS Charleston (LKA-113) - Inactive, out of service, in reserve
USS Doyle (FFG-39) - Stricken, to be disposed of by the Security Assistance Program
USS El Paso (LKA-117) - Inactive, out of commission, in reserve
USS Forrest Sherman (DD-931) - Stricken, available for donation as a museum and memorial
USS Forrestal (CV-59) - Stricken, to be disposed of as scrap or artificial reef
USS Hawes (FFG-53) - Inactive, out of commission
USS John F. Kennedy (CV-67) - To Be Determined
USS John L. Hall (FFG-32) - Inactive, out of commission, in reserve
USS Klakring (FFG-42) - Possible foreign sale
USS Mobile (LKA-115) - Inactive, out of commission, in reserve
USS Nashville (LPD-13) - Inactive, out of commission, in reserve
USS Shreveport (LPD-12) - Stricken, to be disposed of
USS Stephen W. Groves (FFG-29) - Inactive, out of commission, in reserve
USS Thomas S. Gates (CG-51) - Stricken, to be disposed of
USS Ticonderoga (CG-47) - Stricken, available for donation as a museum and memorial
USS Underwood (FFG-36) - Possible foreign sale
USS Yorktown (CG-48) - Being scrapped
I imagine it would be a headache to get the permits to do such a thing. I’m going to research it more at ASMFC.org. Got my mind rollin now....
Here is an interesting link....a lot of bureaucracy:
http://www.navsea.navy.mil/teamships/Inactiveships/Artificial_Reefing/default.aspx
Ryan
Chris...in 2012 I think two or three ships were sunk out in Hawaii as part of a multinational naval exercise called RIMPAC. Here is more:
The Navy said the sink exercises provide “the opportunity to gain proficiency in tactics, targeting and live firing against surface targets, which enhances combat readiness of deployable units.”
The environmental groups Basel Action Network, Sierra Club, Earthjustice and Center for Biological Diversity have condemned the Navy's ship-sinking exercise.
The Navy said it follows Environmental Protection Agency regulations and that the target practice takes place at least 57 miles from land and in waters at least 6,000 feet deep.
Surveys are conducted to ensure that humans and marine mammals are not in an area where they could be harmed during the event, the Navy said.
http://www.navsea.navy.mil/teamships/Inactiveships/SINKEX/default.aspx
GreenMachine, do you have the link for those decommissioned ships that I could share with others?
The fact that those eco-charities oppose a solution with multiple benefits and very few if any negative impacts shows their bias. Why aren't those same groups aggressively opposing the Idle Iron program? Could the oil corporation "donations" to them have anything to do with their silence/support?
Chris,
The original listed was slightly dated and was from Wikipedia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naval_Inactive_Ship_Maintenance_Facility
Interestingly the NAVSEA link use to go right to a list of all the ships and their statuses at all of the demil sites. I believe they changed the site. It use to have in the spreadsheet what options were available for each ship as well. I have searched the site just now and no luck. I did find a .pdf that is not nearly as user friendly. http://www.navsea.navy.mil/teamships/Inactiveships/pdf/Inventory-19Jul2013.pdf
I also found out the requests have to come from the state artificial reef program manager (do we have one of these?).
Ryan
Thanks for the links GreenMachine. I think the guy's name is Jim that is in charge of artificial reef programs in NC. I will try to talk with him this week and let you know what he says.
Jim said some ships built before 1985 should not be used as artificial reefs due to high PCB levels. He also said funding was an issue. We need to look at ways to raise money to create the right kind of habitat.
Just think if the "ECO" groups would put their money and effort into creating habitat instead of closing it off. We would have an endless supply of new habitat. But then I'd just be making sense. Ok time to come back to reality
We could convince some eco-charities to help fund an artificial reef program IF enough fishermen would politely ask the right people. Oceana would be a good one to ask since fishermen help fund them with every purchase at West Marine.
My suggestion....... Create a narrow "mpa" as a test field with this ship. preferably between the 39320 and the 39345...... The preferred depthis in 80 to 90 fathoms of water.If this ship was sunk there, it would provide both the recreational fishermen with an abundance to troll over without cutting out the commercial fishermen that are trying to make a living........ Just a suggestion.
I read recently Miami/Dade ~ Broward Counties have 100 ARs within 20 miles of shore. have not been able to confirm and it sounds far fetched. There are a lot of natural reefs there and ARs, but that number seems high. Still, FL has found they make a lot more money and provide a lot of jobs from rec & tourist fishermen.