SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

An answer for the n...
 
Notifications
Clear all

An answer for the net ban and gamefish status

86 Posts
27 Users
0 Reactions
57.3 K Views
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

I like it as long as there is a provision for recs to be able to use cast / seine nets, clam rakes/tongs, and crab pots



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

allenj, your suggestions make much more sense than game fish status. I could go along with gear endorsements that phase out some nets with high by-catch rates while allowing the spot nets like you mentioned and maybe a few others. Fishermen could switch gear and learn to work it over a three year period.

Would you support science based size limits as a way to reduce Regulatory Discards in both sectors? Would you be willing to work with commercial fishermen on something that could get broad support from all interested parties?

Is anyone else interested in working out something that most people can support? There will always be a few that refuse to except anything other that 100% of what they want. It looks like there are some open-minded people on this site. We need to work together toward what should be our common goal of healthy fisheries that can be responsibly harvested forever. There are forces outside of NC that we need to fight with a united front or we will all lose.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

I completely agree with allenj. Furthermore, I do not and will never support inshore gill nets for anyone. How RCGL allows gill nets is beyond comprehending. I think the biggest point, and the point these groups are totally missing (as with no gamefish so we will go after nets ๐Ÿ™„ ) is they are wanting to get rid of nets at the state level. The easiest way is to sue at the federal level under the ESA. ESA is so broad and comprehensive there is no way to allow an inshore gill net. Here's to a bunch of whiners that don't know a real means to an end. I hope they fail because what they want is wrong and they could achieve conservation without gamefish status (as noted above). I also hope they fail because they are throwing a tantrum (that is not a good character trait for adults). I also hope they fail because their thought process isn't rational..... just a bunch of misguided fools.



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Smith
(@wildcard)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 1573
 

Sound's like the line's at the Social Security Office, Food Stamp, Welfare Office, are fixing to get just abit longer. I guess you guy's are right, Commercial Fisherman have alway's been and alway's will be the most destructive force on Earth. Absolutely amazing.

So I guess all the "water front" home's, condo's, development from the Coast to Raleigh have had no effect here. Where does the run off go from these development's, fertilizer's, weed killer's, golf course up keep, oil from the parking lot's, sewage treatment plant'xs (I know that stuff is clean enough to drink. Problem is, I've yet to see ANYONE that makes that claim drink a glass), etc........... Where are the sore's coming from on our bait fish (you know the bottom of the food cxhain), what's making the oyster's die in bulk, etc........

Truth be known, I remember back in the day when we headed South in our "deadly" shrimp boat's. From Adam's Creek, to nearly Myrtle Beach, on through Charleston, down To Fernidina, It was "hook her up" the whole way down(just about). Yes there were place's you had to slow down, but now it is a complete NO WAKE ZONE. These mile's and mile's of marsh and saw grass, "WAS" the estuary, not any more. Imagine that, build all your high priced retirement home's on the bank with all the run-off, then add on top of that all of your Stupid assed law's (to make it like "it" was where you came from") and you're all suprised there's a "problem".

Guess your right, it's the Commercial Guy's, has to be. Cause it sure as HELL can't be US! Are you kinding me??? I'm gonna need a good dose of sedative's, if I keep reading these post's. Seriously, you guy's need to take a little time and study the "history" of this area. It was pretty much, farming or fishing, until the recent past. Common sense is a dead animal, I guess I need to quit trying to feed it.

My response's may come across "personal", they are not meant to be. I guess I just can't let go of the idea, of what this place "used" to be. Sorry guy's, but I make no appologies's about who I am. This stuff isn't something I "read" somewhere, I've lived it and lived it hard! I'll will continue standing up for what North Carolina "used" to be, until the day I die! You cannot change the truth, it stand's on it's own! Frank



   
ReplyQuote
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 3032
 

Sound's like the line's at the Social Security Office, Food Stamp, Welfare Office, are fixing to get just abit longer. I guess you guy's are right, Commercial Fisherman have alway's been and alway's will be the most destructive force on Earth. Absolutely amazing.

So I guess all the "water front" home's, condo's, development from the Coast to Raleigh have had no effect here. Where does the run off go from these development's, fertilizer's, weed killer's, golf course up keep, oil from the parking lot's, sewage treatment plant'xs (I know that stuff is clean enough to drink. Problem is, I've yet to see ANYONE that makes that claim drink a glass), etc........... Where are the sore's coming from on our bait fish (you know the bottom of the food cxhain), what's making the oyster's die in bulk, etc........

Truth be known, I remember back in the day when we headed South in our "deadly" shrimp boat's. From Adam's Creek, to nearly Myrtle Beach, on through Charleston, down To Fernidina, It was "hook her up" the whole way down(just about). Yes there were place's you had to slow down, but now it is a complete NO WAKE ZONE. These mile's and mile's of marsh and saw grass, "WAS" the estuary, not any more. Imagine that, build all your high priced retirement home's on the bank with all the run-off, then add on top of that all of your Stupid assed law's (to make it like "it" was where you came from") and you're all suprised there's a "problem".

Guess your right, it's the Commercial Guy's, has to be. Cause it sure as HELL can't be US! Are you kinding me??? I'm gonna need a good dose of sedative's, if I keep reading these post's. Seriously, you guy's need to take a little time and study the "history" of this area. It was pretty much, farming or fishing, until the recent past. Common sense is a dead animal, I guess I need to quit trying to feed it.

My response's may come across "personal", they are not meant to be. I guess I just can't let go of the idea, of what this place "used" to be. Sorry guy's, but I make no appologies's about who I am. This stuff isn't something I "read" somewhere, I've lived it and lived it hard! I'll will continue standing up for what North Carolina "used" to be, until the day I die! You cannot change the truth, it stand's on it's own! Frank

๐Ÿ˜€ ๐Ÿ˜€ ๐Ÿ˜€



   
ReplyQuote
Joe Hifko
(@roughandready)
Famed Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 2882
 

Frank, what bothers you so much about what allen proposes. Just the fact that it's not the way it use to be??? I'm not going to pretend to know if any of that is even needed, but what he's saying makes sense and if I'm not mistaken he's a comm fisherman. All the other stuff you mentioned is also true, but that doesn't mean we still can't improve other areas as well.

Maybe just maybe Allens proposes suite Allen, Not everyone else in the fishery. It will never work & if you think it will work commen sence has left your head. Its like making one shoe fit everybody. Everyone has a different size is that too hard to conceive? ๐Ÿ™„
If I was a master flounder gigger I'd love to get rid of nets where I gig.
Sounds like other people I know.... ๐Ÿ˜†



   
ReplyQuote
allenj
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1094
Topic starter  

Frank, what bothers you so much about what allen proposes. Just the fact that it's not the way it use to be??? I'm not going to pretend to know if any of that is even needed, but what he's saying makes sense and if I'm not mistaken he's a comm fisherman. All the other stuff you mentioned is also true, but that doesn't mean we still can't improve other areas as well.

Maybe just maybe Allens proposes suite Allen, Not everyone else in the fishery. It will never work & if you think it will work commen sence has left your head. Its like making one shoe fit everybody. Everyone has a different size is that too hard to conceive? ๐Ÿ™„
If I was a master flounder gigger I'd love to get rid of nets where I gig.
Sounds like other people I know.... ๐Ÿ˜†

Joe, I guess you did not read my proposal that carefully. My proposal does not deny fish to anyone. Just gear change.

Flounder nets do not bother me at all. I just gig down the outside of their nets, and I call DMF when I see 20-30 dead redfish in one. I don't care one way or the other on that, the flounder nets do not affect me. Most flounder netters do not have an understanding of how flounder move, when, where or how, and are not very successful anyway. And I repeat Joe, the flounder nets do not affect what I do.

This is what I was talking about, a proposal that makes sense, and just get thrown to the dogs.



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Smith
(@wildcard)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 1573
 

OK guy's let's break this down real simple. The ONLY problem WE have as USA fisherman rec and commercial, is simply this; WE are the only Country within several hundred's of mile's South that follow ANY guideline's or law's. I am not saying that anything "commercial" is OK, not by any mean's. Let me give you an example from "day's gone by" (remember I mentioned Historical practice's in year's past before). For many, many year's WE shrimper's sewed all the hole's we could find in our net's. Then the Federal Gov't came along (because of outside pressure's) and said that we HAD to use turtle excluder device's. Which were in essence a large grid, with a flap ove a large hole that turtle's could escape from. OK, I'm not about killing turtle's, but would you even believe me IF I told you how many turtle's that have died on my deck's??? Seriously, would you believe me? WE (the responsible guy's) knew how to revieve turtle's and WE did. It really was a point of pride, when we caught that one or possibly two turtle's for the year shrimping in Pamlico Sound. Notice I did not state any area I didn't shrimp in, again MY experience.

After several year's between using "hard and soft" TED's (as mandated to us by the NMFS), trying to help "them" figure out how to make them work, all WE did was to save the TURTLE'S for the table of ourf Southern Neighbor's. Yes Mexico and South, would catch em' on the beach, flip em' over on their back's (so they would sufficate and not escape) till they had a Toyota Pick Up load to carry back to the village. This same EXACT scenerio has played out for just about any specie's WE commercial guy's have been accused of decimating over the year's. Let me cite a few for you, BFT, YFT, swordfish, marlin (yes they eat em in other part's of the World). Any fish trhat school's and swim's the Ocean is "regulated" by US and decimated by "them". How about one more example of how you are finally exposed to the same injustice of "ignorant" hinking the commercial guy's have had to deal with since, well forever. Black Sea Bass, any shortage of them out there?????? Well no, but YOU are "percieved" to be the problem of "over-fishing". You are cast as the problem, because anyone that has an "education" know's they are in dwindling supply and over-fished, right? How about the rest of the bottom fish that are stacked up out there, but YOU are part of the percieved problem, therefore, don't catch em!

One more instance, the Golden Tile. According to my latest Soth Atlantic Marine Fisheries News Letter, the Golden Tile is considered "not overfished-overfishing ended", since the last assessment in 2004. This assessment came primarily from SE Florida. Therefore all were lumped together in the "percieved" problem pool. I have just one question for any "old timer" on here, that actually know's what a Golden Tile look's like. What is their migration pattern??? I can answer that tune in 2 note's or less! My question is simply this, what does a fishery, that doesn't have a huge migration route in SE Florida, have to do with US? The simple answer is this, YOU are the percieved problem and will suffer accordingly. It matter's not whether you guilty or not! This is simply one of those time's (as with the BSB) that the "shoe is on the other foot". Doesn't make it right, but the judgement has been passed! Frank



   
ReplyQuote
Joe Hifko
(@roughandready)
Famed Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 2882
 

Allen I read it real carefully. As for your complaints they are self serving.
Unlike You I have nothing to gain from this. But All the changes you propose will make fishing more profitable for You, good luck in your crusade. Greed gets You nowhere.



   
ReplyQuote
allenj
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1094
Topic starter  

Allen I read it real carefully. As for your complaints they are self serving.
Unlike You I have nothing to gain from this. But All the changes you propose will make fishing more profitable for You, good luck in your crusade. Greed gets You nowhere.

???????????????????The reason I proposed this is a answer to the gamefish and net ban. I don't agree with either one. They deny part of the population access to these fish. I have nothing to gain at all from these proposals. What do you think I have to gain?

This is nothing but a simple answer to a problem in which no one is denied access to the resource. I am going to support my family running charters and gigging flounder whether striper/drum/trout are made gamefish or not. I am going to support my family running charters and gigging flounder whether nets are banned or not. I don't really care either way.

There is still a commercial fishery with my proposal.

A CLEAN commercial fishery.



   
ReplyQuote
Joe Hifko
(@roughandready)
Famed Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 2882
 

Frank, what bothers you so much about what allen proposes. Just the fact that it's not the way it use to be??? I'm not going to pretend to know if any of that is even needed, but what he's saying makes sense and if I'm not mistaken he's a comm fisherman. All the other stuff you mentioned is also true, but that doesn't mean we still can't improve other areas as well.

Maybe just maybe Allens proposes suite Allen, Not everyone else in the fishery. It will never work & if you think it will work commen sence has left your head. Its like making one shoe fit everybody. Everyone has a different size is that too hard to conceive? ๐Ÿ™„

Joe, not looking for an argument. You know what....just forget I posted.....

Fishfindertoo, Its not an argument, I'm just saying that this one shoe fits all
across a broad region isn't going to work. Theres alot of guys to the north of us that don't get the proper conditions to gig. Also alot of people don't work good at night. I know alot of older guys(that hate the dark) But, that flounder fish during the day in the pamlico to make ends meet.Taking away what they do is wrong in my book. They have worked all their life and if they get some joy outa flounder netting after they retire, they should be able to do it. Old man Mr. Pete loved it outa hampstead. Hate to see people like him lose it.



   
ReplyQuote
allenj
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1094
Topic starter  

Frank, what bothers you so much about what allen proposes. Just the fact that it's not the way it use to be??? I'm not going to pretend to know if any of that is even needed, but what he's saying makes sense and if I'm not mistaken he's a comm fisherman. All the other stuff you mentioned is also true, but that doesn't mean we still can't improve other areas as well.

Maybe just maybe Allens proposes suite Allen, Not everyone else in the fishery. It will never work & if you think it will work commen sence has left your head. Its like making one shoe fit everybody. Everyone has a different size is that too hard to conceive? ๐Ÿ™„

Joe, not looking for an argument. You know what....just forget I posted.....

Fishfindertoo, Its not an argument, I'm just saying that this one shoe fits all
across a broad region isn't going to work. Theres alot of guys to the north of us that don't get the proper conditions to gig. Also alot of people don't work good at night. I know alot of older guys(that hate the dark) But, that flounder fish during the day in the pamlico to make ends meet.Taking away what they do is wrong in my book. They have worked all their life and if they get some joy outa flounder netting after they retire, they should be able to do it. Old man Mr. Pete loved it outa hampstead. Hate to see people like him lose it.

I have gigged Pamlico just fine. They do get the conditions to do it up there. Joe they are not allowed to flounder fish Pamlico in the daytime. You can not set flounder gill nets in the daytime anymore. That whole region of the state is closed to flounder nets what now?? 6 months of the year?



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

Allen I read it real carefully. As for your complaints they are self serving.
Unlike You I have nothing to gain from this. But All the changes you propose will make fishing more profitable for You, good luck in your crusade. Greed gets You nowhere.

Maybe what Allen is trying to say since reds would be 10 hook and line and specks should be 25 hook and line and since flounder is probably the most highly sought after recreational and commercially inshore fish some where in between 10 and 25 would be a good number for commercially caught fllounder, hook and line. Or in other words 13 flounder per operation, I don't care how you slice the pie, none of us are going to be to happy, just read the book outlaw gunner.



   
ReplyQuote
carl rumley
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 519
 

Sound's like the line's at the Social Security Office, Food Stamp, Welfare Office, are fixing to get just abit longer. I guess you guy's are right, Commercial Fisherman have alway's been and alway's will be the most destructive force on Earth. Absolutely amazing.

So I guess all the "water front" home's, condo's, development from the Coast to Raleigh have had no effect here. Where does the run off go from these development's, fertilizer's, weed killer's, golf course up keep, oil from the parking lot's, sewage treatment plant'xs (I know that stuff is clean enough to drink. Problem is, I've yet to see ANYONE that makes that claim drink a glass), etc........... Where are the sore's coming from on our bait fish (you know the bottom of the food cxhain), what's making the oyster's die in bulk, etc........

Truth be known, I remember back in the day when we headed South in our "deadly" shrimp boat's. From Adam's Creek, to nearly Myrtle Beach, on through Charleston, down To Fernidina, It was "hook her up" the whole way down(just about). Yes there were place's you had to slow down, but now it is a complete NO WAKE ZONE. These mile's and mile's of marsh and saw grass, "WAS" the estuary, not any more. Imagine that, build all your high priced retirement home's on the bank with all the run-off, then add on top of that all of your Stupid assed law's (to make it like "it" was where you came from") and you're all suprised there's a "problem".

Guess your right, it's the Commercial Guy's, has to be. Cause it sure as HELL can't be US! Are you kinding me??? I'm gonna need a good dose of sedative's, if I keep reading these post's. Seriously, you guy's need to take a little time and study the "history" of this area. It was pretty much, farming or fishing, until the recent past. Common sense is a dead animal, I guess I need to quit trying to feed it.

My response's may come across "personal", they are not meant to be. I guess I just can't let go of the idea, of what this place "used" to be. Sorry guy's, but I make no appologies's about who I am. This stuff isn't something I "read" somewhere, I've lived it and lived it hard! I'll will continue standing up for what North Carolina "used" to be, until the day I die! You cannot change the truth, it stand's on it's own! Frank



   
ReplyQuote
Joe Hifko
(@roughandready)
Famed Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 2882
 

Allen I read it real carefully. As for your complaints they are self serving.
Unlike You I have nothing to gain from this. But All the changes you propose will make fishing more profitable for You, good luck in your crusade. Greed gets You nowhere.

???????????????????The reason I proposed this is a answer to the gamefish and net ban. I don't agree with either one. They deny part of the population access to these fish. I have nothing to gain at all from these proposals. What do you think I have to gain?

This is nothing but a simple answer to a problem in which no one is denied access to the resource. I am going to support my family running charters and gigging flounder whether striper/drum/trout are made gamefish or not. I am going to support my family running charters and gigging flounder whether nets are banned or not. I don't really care either way.

There is still a commercial fishery with my proposal.

A CLEAN commercial fishery.

I didn't say there wasn't, But your Proposal suits you, Not the rest of the community.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 6
Share: