SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Ankle Bracelet Moni...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Ankle Bracelet Monitoring Devices for Recreational Fishermen

82 Posts
27 Users
0 Reactions
147.4 K Views
Andy
 Andy
(@ebbtideandy)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 655
 

I don't have an issue with the government tracking all the internet traffic in the world, most of the cell phone signals and most non-cash transactions if it will help keep us safe and economically secure.

Wow!
I find it extremely scary that there are Americans like this that are so willing to give up their personal liberties.

God help us!



   
ReplyQuote
QuickFix
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 245
 

Every time seacern sends a post I get throw up in my mouth

X2 - seacern is obviously clueless about the details of participating in federal fisheries within the EEZ!

seacern - Do you support catch shares either recreationally or commercially? If so why and if not why not?

Seacern - do you believe VMS is a viable tool for any hook and line fishery in the South Atlantic zone? If so why and if not why not?

Thanks in advance.

Seacern - if you don't mind sharing your beliefs by answering a few simple questions, please do so when you have a minute!

Again thanks in advance.

So first you insult me and then say thanks and please, class act!

You asked: "Do you believe VMS is a viable tool for any hook and line fishery in the South Atlantic zone? If so why and if not why not?"

It really doesn't matter what I think. It's here. But, just for grins (since you were so nice)- Catch in the hook and line fishery is highly variable. The VMS tool is going to be severely limited to mainly documenting effort based on the number of trips. I do see the possibility of electronic self-reporting requirements from VMS recorded trips providing data for management. I also see the possibility of a 100% commercial landing requirement with dockside monitoring providing better management analysis. Random at sea observers will be needed for validation.

I'm done with this one boys, heading southeast by east to wet a line. If you need me, call uncle sam he'll know where I am and what I'm doing.

Well I was not trying to insult you nor was I being arrogant and condescending like your responses to Squid's comments!

So I will rephrase using your own words to Eric - instead of you being clueless you are simply wrong and unrealistic! Your attempt at answering a simple question reveals exactly how little you know of federal fishing in the EEZ!

Your attempt to clarify your postion makes no sense but only serves to underscore your ignorance regarding federal fisheries management within the South Atlantic Zone!

As an aside, I feel certain nobody here will be needing you nor calling looking for you! But feel free to contact me if you would like accurate information regarding the topic of this post!I will be more than happy to clue you in!

In the meantime, stop by the Raleigh Farmer's market on your way out or on your way back in and pick you up some of that nice fresh gill net caught NC Bounty!

Thanks again for your insight!



   
ReplyQuote
Carlton Pittman
(@cap1)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 380
 

It's a fishing issue that has parts of the commercial sector partnering with far left environmental groups, who will limit all fishing, to limit growing recreational interest. The capitilized recreational charter sector has identified a need to split the recreational allocation.

Would not be surprised at this one.

I don't think cameras on buoys in the MPAs equipped with cameras would be viable as these are large areas, and it would take a mess of buoys.

Does the government monitor migratory bird species in this manner? Wonder how many waterfowl hunters would mount a tracker on their gun of choice. ?

Probably won't be having one of these devices on any of my boats. What if I had/have multiple boats. Do I need a monitoring device for each vessel? As a purely recreational fisherman?

Bad idea all the way around.



   
ReplyQuote
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
 

If my grandma (back in the sixties) would of told me that fishing was going get like this I would have been a foosball champion.



   
ReplyQuote
David Mcfadyen
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 269
 

Look we can't keep drugs from comming in on small boats with all the tech that law enforcement has. What you are talking about is a gps sat system you could never get the video part to work. Where i work we have 35 units on the road it takes three people to keep up with them and the units only go from point a to b. Can you imagine the manpower or tech it would take to keep up with thousands you ever looked at a radar screen at a airport.? Looks like balls of yarn



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Smith
(@wildcard)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 1573
 

Everyone I know that was around when the "black box" proposals first came out, said "no way I'm gonna put one of those things on my boat". If they are still fishing, they did. Not only did they have to purchase them, they have to pay the Sat Phone charges involved too. Any and all information gathered, "can and will be used against you in a court of law". I was called stupid and apparently didn't know how to construct paragraphs, on another matter. This ignorant fisherman, has been trying to warn you about this slippery slope. Our Gov't has already shown it can happen. As far as how much it'll cost the taxpayer, how big the Agency would have to get to keep up with all those fishermen, etc........ those are just details. Frank



   
ReplyQuote
eric broome
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1299
 

After reading seacern's rebuttals Iam completely inn the dark as to whether he was defending the vms and catch shares or against them. He seemed to jump the fence inn his last couple posts. He initially said we had nothing to fear, then said that having your spotsw stolen and sold to highest bidder was a real possibility. I re read them twice and it's so ambiguous that it still smacks of regulator speak to me. But I am completely wrong according to him so take that with grain of salt. I'll repeat the question asked by quickfix: Seacern, do you support catch shares and VMS? Not asking you if you are afraid of them, do you support them?

You may think I'm wrong about the two sectors and the effect that this tidbit may or may not have, but I still think that we all have more in common than we do opposed. I think a common enemy WILL bring us closer. May not be enough to stop a government steam roller, but just uniting the watermen would be enough for me. Too easy to pick us off divided.



   
ReplyQuote
Joe Hifko
(@roughandready)
Famed Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 2882
 

Everyone has been complaining how the Government "Guesses" at
how the recreational sectors share of fish are caught.
So in response to that, And the impending catch shares fish grab
taking place(On the commercial side), The recreational sectors catch, In their eyes, needs to be recorded. With Dick Brame appointed to the advisory committee and him wanting to distance hisself from Catch Shares
as a fit for both sides. I would fully expect a long drawn out battle that consists from monitoring fishermen to federal fish stamps or tags.
Or who knows, You might have to buy a federal recreational PERMIT for certain species and fill out paperwork like the commercial sector does.
Its all up in the air now, But one thing for sure, They are going to make recreational fishing more accountable.



   
ReplyQuote
David Plowden
(@mealonreels)
Prominent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 652
 

I can see where fish tags would result in rec accountability.If fish were landed without being tagged there would have to be a stiff penalty to keep it more honest.This compares to comm fishing where a trip ticket is needed to sell fish.



   
ReplyQuote
David Plowden
(@mealonreels)
Prominent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 652
 

South Atlantic Fishery Management Council The SAFMC submitted comments on the draft implementation plan to NMFS. The Council recommended discussing costs upfront in the document, and how the data should go through ACCSP. Additionally, the Council noted that they would be cautious of moving forward with electronic monitoring due to costs for fishermen, but that they are supportive of electronic reporting to meet the Council's goals.



   
ReplyQuote
Arlen Ash
(@double_a)
Eminent Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 30
 

Aside from the privacy and personal rights issue, let's not forget or overlook that VMS data would not be used just to monitor current MPAs but also to implement new ones. How many people fish currently "unprotected" natural bottoms such as 10mi rock, 23mi rock etc........



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Public Comments to NOAA Regarding Electronic Monitoring and Reporting

I am Chris McCaffity, a commercial fisherman who has been advocating for positive solutions to protect our fisheries and the public’s access to them. Please consider these public comments with an open heart and mind.

There has been a rush over the past few years to meet hard deadlines contained in the Magnuson-Stevens Act. This rush has created some severe negative impacts for fish, fishermen, and consumers. Before passing any more laws we need to Stop and Review existing regulations to see what’s working and what isn’t. We need to focus on finding solutions that reduce Regulatory Discards rather than trying to calculate this unnecessary waste. Our goal should be to limit discards while promoting release techniques that give illegal fish the best chance of survival.

Electronic Reporting could be a good thing that most people would support. Any reporting website should include a forum where stakeholders can log in with our license/permit number and a password to have discussions and hold votes on how our fisheries will be managed. We should be allowed to pick who represents us on management council’s and decide how each sector’s TACs will be managed with a 2/3 majority vote from participating stakeholders.

There is a growing distrust for the entire fishery management system that will be exacerbated by pushing for any kind of electronic spy devices that are blatant violations of our civil and constitutional rights. Please consider working with willing fishermen to collect better data while reserving any expensive and intrusive Electronic Monitoring as punishment for poachers. We need to work together as liaisons rather than being adversaries.

Imagine if all the time, effort, and expense being put into pushing Orwellian agendas were put into improving our fisheries with hatcheries and habitat enhancement. We could feed more people, create more recreational opportunity, and generate more revenue while passing on a healthier resource to future generations. These sustainable solutions would be the perfect union of aquaculture and wild-caught seafood that lives free and self-sufficient until harvested.

I respectfully ask each individual reading this to think about if you would personally make a loved one install some spy device on their private property or how you would feel if forced to do so. Please treat us as you would like to be treated.

Thank you for your thoughtful consideration of these comments. I am always happy to answer any questions and/or discuss any fishery issues. freefish7@hotmail.com



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

We need to focus on finding solutions that reduce Regulatory Discards rather than trying to calculate this unnecessary waste.

Translation:

"We need to allow comms to sell everything they can dredge,
hook or trawl net out of the public's waters"

🙄



   
ReplyQuote
eric broome
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1299
 

We need to focus on finding solutions that reduce Regulatory Discards rather than trying to calculate this unnecessary waste.

Translation:

"We need to allow comms to sell everything they can dredge,
hook or trawl net out of the public's waters"

🙄

Are you so idealistic that you feel there could be zero by-catch in NC fisheries? Chris is only advocating for doing away with wastefullness. I applaud his efforts. He puts up with a lot from the peanut gallery but never changes his course. That's admirable. Besides, he's a hook and line fisherman, why throw all the trawl crap at his door? As you age (further) that hate and vitriol is gonna eat you up man. Like a tapeworm. The other guys are missing you at hardees this morning.... :lmao:



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

Chris is only advocating for doing away with wastefullness

Sounds like advocating another revenue stream to me.

"Regulatory By-catch explained"

The quota system works like this: a trawler goes out to with a quota to catch five tons of cod and five tons of haddock. After a while they have caught their five tons of cod but only three tons of haddock. The trawler will not return port without reaching its full quota of haddock and so keeps on fishing. They eventually catch the two tons of haddock they are entitled to but in the process of doing so also catch an extra ton of cod. All of this extra cod over the five-ton quota will have to be thrown back into the sea dead. The term discard therefore refers to fish that commercial fishing vessels have caught and thrown back over the side of the boat dead because they cannot legally take it back to port to sell. The discards issue is just one of the horrible, wasteful practices commercial fisheries take part in. Bycatch is another. When trawling for cod or haddock in a mixed fishery (which all the seas around the UK are) other fish are inevitably caught. These other species are referred to as bycatch. Good quality bycatch – like monkfish or halibut – will be kept and sold. But bycatch made up of small species, undersize fish or species with no commercial value will simply be thrown overboard back into the sea. Fish which are thrown back into the sea as bycatch or due to a vessel being over quota do not live. By the time they have been dragged up from the seabed they are usually already dead, and fish which still have some life left in them will not live as their swim bladder will be ruptured meaning they will not survive.

There is also the issue of high-grading. This is the practice of commercial fishermen throwing low-value fish they have caught back into the sea to make more room in the hold of the ship for the higher value fish. For example a ton of whiting will be thrown back overboard as a discard to make room for a ton of haddock, as the haddock will gain much more at market. Theoretically, there is a ban on high-grading taking place by fishermen from EU nations, but no procedures exist to determine whether this is being followed.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 4 / 6
Share: