SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
According to the SAFMC proposal bulletin released in April, ARS 'may' open on the 2nd Friday in July. Has anyone heard anything more definite?
I heard that there still was no decision. Not happening in July but still on table. Maybe later this year.
Public comments could keep it closed. Those who support the closure submitted their comments. Let NOAA know if you want to see a Red Snapper season. Silence supports keeping it closed.
I think it has a lot to do with the catch share fishery in the gulf.Open up the East coast and then they have a little market competition.They have enough bribe money to keep it closed
Public comments could keep it closed. Those who support the closure submitted their comments. Let NOAA know if you want to see a Red Snapper season. Silence supports keeping it closed.
The comment period is closed; however, upon looking through the data, there is overwhelming support for opening the season. I picked a random selection of 300 out of 2477 comments and found only 2 that opposed the ammendment. Seems that the public comment aspect is extremely well represented on the support side.
https://www.regulations.gov/docket?D=NOAA-NMFS-2017-0148
Public comments could keep it closed. Those who support the closure submitted their comments. Let NOAA know if you want to see a Red Snapper season. Silence supports keeping it closed.
The comment period is closed; however, upon looking through the data, there is overwhelming support for opening the season. I picked a random selection of 300 out of 2477 comments and found only 2 that opposed the ammendment. Seems that the public comment aspect is extremely well represented on the support side.
https://www.regulations.gov/docket?D=NOAA-NMFS-2017-0148
The official comment period is over but the decision has not been made. It is not too late for the thousands of fishermen who did not submit public comments during the official comment period to contact NOAA. Anyone planning to fish for Red Snapper should have submitted an official public comment supporting the opening.
The official comment period is over but the decision has not been made. It is not too late for the thousands of fishermen who did not submit public comments during the official comment period to contact NOAA. Anyone planning to fish for Red Snapper should have submitted an official public comment supporting the opening.
Hey Chris, is my random pull of 300 responses accurate or not to the entire pool of data? Appears to be overwhelmingly lopsided in favor of opening a season. That seems to be a pretty clear response. If it's about "how many" replies they receive, then the scope of the inquiry is misleading. Hopeful you can help me understand better. How am I missing it??
Thank God somebody was able to get a bunch of fishermen to copy and paste this comment.
"As a recreational angler and conservationist, I support Amendment 43 to the Fishery Management Plan for the Snapper-Grouper Fishery of the South Atlantic Region that would allow a limited opening of the red snapper fishery in South Atlantic federal waters.
I support opening a South Atlantic red snapper season in 2018, through Amendment 43, that balances season length with sustainability. The South Atlantic red snapper stock has increased in abundance over the last several years at an even faster rate than predicted by the rebuilding plan. Abundance surveys and angler reports point to a quickly rebuilding fishery. Opening a conservative season as proposed will not only provide access and opportunity for anglers, but will also provide much needed data for a more accurate assessment of the red snapper stock.
In conclusion, I support Snapper Grouper Amendment 43 and urge swift final approval by the Secretary of Commerce.
Thank you for your consideration."
I checked with SAFMC and this was their response:
recreational red snapper season
>
6:50 PM (21 hours ago)
to kim.iverson
Hello
In reading the April 13th bulletin regarding and ARS open season it states that the season may open on the 2nd Friday in July. PLEASE tell me this is going to happen. I'd love to tell my boss I'm going to be sick Friday.
Best regards,
Kim Iverson via safmc.onmicrosoft.com
7:15 AM (9 hours ago)
to me
Good morning Wes,
Unfortunately the red snapper season isn’t opening this Friday. If Amendment 43 is approved by the Secretary of Commerce and there is an opening, it will likely occur in August.
I’m afraid you will have to come up with another excuse. However, your email was the best inquiry I’ve received to date!
Please feel free to call me on my cell if you have any questions. 843/2x4-7xx8.
Kim
Kim Iverson
Public Information Officer
Bummer on the season dates. LOL at your email.
I checked with SAFMC and this was their response:
recreational red snapper season
>
6:50 PM (21 hours ago)to kim.iverson
Hello
In reading the April 13th bulletin regarding and ARS open season it states that the season may open on the 2nd Friday in July. PLEASE tell me this is going to happen. I'd love to tell my boss I'm going to be sick Friday.Best regards,
Kim Iverson via safmc.onmicrosoft.com
7:15 AM (9 hours ago)to me
Good morning Wes,
Unfortunately the red snapper season isn’t opening this Friday. If Amendment 43 is approved by the Secretary of Commerce and there is an opening, it will likely occur in August.
I’m afraid you will have to come up with another excuse. However, your email was the best inquiry I’ve received to date!
Please feel free to call me on my cell if you have any questions. 843/2x4-7xx8.Kim
Kim Iverson
Public Information Officer
Her number keeps ringing busy. Please repost. Thx...
Looks like an August season.
Three weekends consisting of Friday, Saturday and Sunday
1 fish per person
No minimum size
Did you see which weekends Squid?
The official comment period is over but the decision has not been made. It is not too late for the thousands of fishermen who did not submit public comments during the official comment period to contact NOAA. Anyone planning to fish for Red Snapper should have submitted an official public comment supporting the opening.
Hey Chris, is my random pull of 300 responses accurate or not to the entire pool of data? Appears to be overwhelmingly lopsided in favor of opening a season. That seems to be a pretty clear response. If it's about "how many" replies they receive, then the scope of the inquiry is misleading. Hopeful you can help me understand better. How am I missing it??
There would not have been many comments supporting the opening if somebody had not convinced a bunch of fishermen to copy and paste a comment. Some of the catch share charities could have easily gotten just as many people to sign a petition opposing the opening. One of the attached documents in the public comments could be such a petition. It is mostly about numbers. Although asking for or supporting something reasonable certainly helps.
It is understandable why fishermen don't comment on every issue. This is obviously an issue that is important to many fishermen. Why rely on other people to submit enough public comments when it is SOOOOOOOOOOO easy to simply say you support Amendment 43?
If you plan on fishing for Red Snapper, please officially report your catch and release any extra snapper suffering from barotrauma with a descending device.
Did you see which weekends Squid?
They did not specify, just a target of August based on Secy of Commerce needed approval
42,510 fish for the SE Atlantic is the quota