SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Well since the stupid limit change didn't work can we go back to 2 per person limit? I have a feeling this will be luke trout. We will never get back to the old limits.
I just want to know how they got that number. Not saying it's wrong or right. Just can't believe that number
This document will give you a very good idea about the methodology used to determine the cobia harvest numbers and management process. It is lengthy, but worth your time because other assessments are the same or similar.
http://sedarweb.org/docs/sar/S28_SAR_SACobia_WithAddendumFinal_5.16.2013.pdf
Chris do you know how they came up with the 245% overage?
Matador's link explains that.
NC WILL enforce the closure in state waters.
The SAFMC is playing with numbers to achieve desired results. You will never see the bag limit go back to two fish without some kind of better reporting system for recreational landings. Speculation and uncertainty are why recs continue seeing reduce bag limits and closures. Watch for more of the cobia TAC being allocated to projected dead discards due to the reduced bag limit and extended closure. You will need to watch closely as it will be done discreetly. Fishermen need to start working together if we want to keep our freedom to fish and eat them.
The SAFMC is playing with numbers to achieve desired results.
That is the take home lesson for sure. Has been for years.
There are no numbers to support this closure, as there is no requirement to report the catch of a Cobia for recreational fisherman. If a fishery can't support a two fish limit in my opinion there should not be any commercial harvest, just another spoonful of S#@t we are being forced to eat
I for one, have little faith nor understand all the so called numbers
that are thrown around by agencies and fishermen alike ! But what I do
know is that the cobia are waaaay down in the areas I usually fish , so
if there are less fish to be had , then the burden to help rebuild the
stock should fall on all parties equally !! When the catch limit xxxx is met
or exceded , the season is over for all and the limits adjusted so that all share in pain , allowing some to continue catching only extends the pain
for other fishermen.. :hail:
I would have preferred to see a madatory slot size limit all year with a one fish limit like the red drum, than a complete closue.
Looks like NMFS's divide and conquer strategy is working well.
A simple reporting ap for the smartphones almost every fishermen has would be a great way to get better landings data for the rec sector.
Chris do you know how they came up with the 245% overage?
Matador's link explains that.
NC WILL enforce the closure in state waters.
The SAFMC is playing with numbers to achieve desired results. You will never see the bag limit go back to two fish without some kind of better reporting system for recreational landings. Speculation and uncertainty are why recs continue seeing reduce bag limits and closures. Watch for more of the cobia TAC being allocated to projected dead discards due to the reduced bag limit and extended closure. You will need to watch closely as it will be done discreetly. Fishermen need to start working together if we want to keep our freedom to fish and eat them.
I agree. I have sent in a lot of comments lately to SAFMC/NOAA during commenting periods. I've noticed that I'm usually one of a few hundred rec fishermen to comment (where are the thousands of comments??). Since nobody seems to care about bottom dwellers, maybe the cobia actions will entice some public involvement from the rec sector.
I remember when they slashed the blueline tilefish ACL and basically closed down the fishery, I was one of ~60 public comments. Their tilefish data was even more suspect than the cobia numbers.
Looks like NMFS's divide and conquer strategy is working well.
A simple reporting ap for the smartphones almost every fishermen has would be a great way to get better landings data for the rec sector.
Agree Chris. I think we need better reporting for commercials and recs alike. Real time electronic ticket reporting or be able to call in your catch much like deer hunting. Would be extremely useful and I don't think many people would mind one bit.
I'd be ok with that if it was for all involved, not just recs.......
Would you be ok with shutting down recreational fisheries when commercial limits have been met as well ?
No, but the commercial argument is recreational fisherman are greedy and want all the fish to themselves.
Looks like NMFS's divide and conquer strategy is working well.
A simple reporting ap for the smartphones almost every fishermen has would be a great way to get better landings data for the rec sector.
Agree Chris. I think we need better reporting for commercials and recs alike. Real time electronic ticket reporting or be able to call in your catch much like deer hunting. Would be extremely useful and I don't think many people would mind one bit.
That would be great in theory. However, I'm sure there are a lot of deer that never get reported. Does anyone know of a hunter that has had his freezer checked to validate the kill and see if that is all that is in possession? I've been stopped and checked by marine fisheries once. They counted the fish for infractions, but did not record anything. One member here has told me he has been checked at Carolina Beach ramp several times, but person asked how many fish and type, but never asked to see the catch for verification. We will never have accurate numbers without enforcement/verification of current reporting methods, whatever the species.
It would be simple to give a Cobia tag and put a limit per year (say 20) and per day (say 2), when your tag is full you can't keep any more Cobia. That would provide real catch numbers and a fair chance to every one to enjoy Cobia.
It would be simple to give a Cobia tag and put a limit per year (say 20) and per day (say 2), when your tag is full you can't keep any more Cobia. That would provide real catch numbers and a fair chance to every one to enjoy Cobia.
Slippery slope into recreational catch shares
I won't lie, I can understand the frustration with the numbers and how they come to their decisions but the quota was busted by Recs and we have a responsibility to bare that overage as the rules dictate. Don't like the rules, find a way to get them amended and changed. Don't take something away from others because they stayed within their allotted quota.