SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Most commercial snapper/grouper fishermen in the southeast were put out of work on October 20. The shallow-water grouper, Scamp, and Red Grouper fisheries were shut down with plenty of quota left when the Gag Grouper fishery was closed. This was done to keep gags from being caught accidentally as fishermen targeted other grouper. Now there are not enough legal fish of any value to make a profitable trip.
Here is a simple solution that would allow unfilled quotas to be harvested and provide consumers with access to local seafood for the rest of the year while avoiding excessive Regulatory Discards.
Gag Grouper still have over 20,000 pounds left uncaught in the quota. Opening the gag fishery with a 50 pound commercial trip limit would also open up the shallow-water grouper complex, Scamp, and Red Grouper. The low possession limit for gags would keep fishermen from targeting them while extending the season through the rest of the year. Other closed fisheries with unfilled quota should be reopened with limits low enough to keep them open for the rest of the year. This would reduce Regulatory Discards while filling the quotas and could be implemented quickly.
Please think about how it would feel if you were unnecessarily put out of work during the holiday season. Think about how it would feel not to have money for a turkey on Thanksgiving or gifts for your kids at Christmas. Think about how it would feel to have bills piling up with no way to pay them. Please consider helping local fishermen get back to work providing you with fresh seafood by simply asking the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council to implement the solutions offered in this letter. They will listen IF enough of us ask nicely. safmc@safmc.net 1-866-723-6210
Well Said Chris
While this idea has plenty of merit and would be a big step in the right direction, unfortunately, SAFMC has already said that they will not reopen grouper this year period!
They could easily do this just like they did with yellowtail snapper but they refuse and told me that on advice of their attorney will not even consider it!
In addition they told me they would approve removing the measure to close Reds and Scamps when the gag quota is met at the upcoming December meeting but still will not put it into effect this year.
The only way that commercial grouper/snapper permit holders will be able to effect change is to band together, form a regional fisheries group as allowed by the MSA and then submit a petition to have their own quota managed on a local basis. The MSA allows this and until a lawsuit is brought forth challenging SAFMC, NMFS, and NOAA, no amount of calls or public comment will change anything because they have an agenda and everything else is just lip service!
I encourage everyone to go onto the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council Facebook page and light them up on a daily basis. Just take a look at all of their answers to any question - deflection and obfuscation of the issues!
Needless to say, I am very frustrated and down right angry with the mismanagement of our federal waters!
Sell what bites, worked in the "old day's". Of course that was before CCA, Audobon, Miss Jane, bunny lover's, etc........... I know, there's no fish left in the ocean. Frank
Capt. Cane, Thank you.
QuickFix, A good member of the SAFMC told me the only reason the grouper fishery was reopened at all was because of people sending emails in support of the solution offered. We have power in numbers. Your idea of banding together is what NEEDS to be done. We have a chance through Regulatory Amendment 14 to stand united in support of positive solutions that deal with the reality of lower quotas and work toward long-term goals. We need to work on offering public comments regarding RA14 that a majority of fishermen can support and get everyone we can to submit them before the December SAFMC meeting.
seapower, Your comment is exactly why I support keeping everything open at the same time. Managing quotas with split seasons and sliding possession limits would allow fishermen to target fish with higher limits while still keeping some fish with lower limits. At least you could put a trip together throughout the entire year this way.
Everyone, We need to demand that the SAFMC focus on properly managing existing quotas and collecting accurate data to use in credible stock assessments. The MSA hard deadlines have been met. It is time for the council to fix some of the unintended consequences of actions taken in the rush to meet those deadlines. We need to point out all of the Regulatory Discards they have created and offer positive solutions to limit them. This will help the fish, fishermen, and consumers.
So SAFMC makes a snap decision to open gag for 8 days.Did they even consider the weather for those days?They may have seen it good for Fla. but bad for NC. We get the short end again.The South Atlantic should be split up in two sections.NC SC /Ga Fla. What would it take to change it?Ask for an increase in gag quota when you comment too.One or the other may keep the season at 8 months open.
NC/SC should be split out from GA/FLA and I believe that the MSA allows for this. We must get organized and quickly and present a proposal this December. In addition to splitting the region, NC/SC needs to have quota based on historical landings with allowable yearly increases. I see no scientific reason that NC/SC should not be able to properly manage a fishery with a ten month season of combined species.
See below from the MSA:
(4) REGIONAL FISHERY ASSOCIATIONS.—
(A) IN GENERAL.—To be eligible to participate in a limited access privilege program
to harvest fish, a regional fishery association shall—
(i) be located within the management area of the relevant Council;
(ii) meet criteria developed by the relevant Council, approved by the Secretary,
and published in the Federal Register;
(iii) be a voluntary association with established by-laws and operating procedures;
(iv) consist of participants in the fishery who hold quota share that are designated
for use in the specific region or subregion covered by the regional fishery association,
including commercial or recreational fishing, processing, fishery-dependent support
businesses, or fishing communities;
(v) not be eligible to receive an initial allocation of a limited access privilege but
may acquire such privileges after the initial allocation, and may hold the annual fishing
privileges of any limited access privileges it holds or the annual fishing privileges that
is [sic]17 members contribute; and
(vi) develop and submit a regional fishery association plan to the Council and the
Secretary for approval based on criteria developed by the Council that have been
approved by the Secretary and published in the Federal Register.
(B) FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH PLAN.—The Secretary shall deny or revoke
limited access privileges granted under this section to any person participating in a
regional fishery association who fails to comply with the requirements of the regional
fishery association plan.
17 So in original.
16 U.S.C. 1853a
MSA § 303A
83
(C) PARTICIPATION CRITERIA.—In developing participation criteria for eligible
regional fishery associations under this paragraph, a Council shall consider—
(i) traditional fishing or processing practices in, and dependence on, the fishery;
(ii) the cultural and social framework relevant to the fishery;
(iii) economic barriers to access to fishery;
(iv) the existence and severity of projected economic and social impacts associated
with implementation of limited access privilege programs on harvesters, captains,
crew, processors, and other businesses substantially dependent upon the fishery in the
region or subregion;
(v) the administrative and fiduciary soundness of the association; and
(vi) the expected effectiveness, operational transparency, and equitability of the
fishery association plan.
(5) ALLOCATION.—In developing a limited access privilege program to harvest fish a
Council or the Secretary shall—
(A) establish procedures to ensure fair and equitable initial allocations, including
consideration of—
(i) current and historical harvests;
(ii) employment in the harvesting and processing sectors;
(iii) investments in, and dependence upon, the fishery; and
(iv) the current and historical participation of fishing communities;
(B) consider the basic cultural and social framework of the fishery, especially
through—
(i) the development of policies to promote the sustained participation of small
owner-operated fishing vessels and fishing communities that depend on the fisheries,
including regional or port-specific landing or delivery requirements; and
(ii) procedures to address concerns over excessive geographic or other
consolidation in the harvesting or processing sectors of the fishery;
(C) include measures to assist, when necessary and appropriate, entry-level and small
vessel owner-operators, captains, crew, and fishing communities through set-asides of
harvesting allocations, including providing privileges, which may include set-asides or
allocations of harvesting privileges, or economic assistance in the purchase of limited
access privileges;
(D) ensure that limited access privilege holders do not acquire an excessive share of
the total limited access privileges in the program by—
(i) establishing a maximum share, expressed as a percentage of the total limited
access privileges, that a limited access privilege holder is permitted to hold, acquire, or
use; and
(ii) establishing any other limitations or measures necessary to prevent an
inequitable concentration of limited access privileges; and
16 U.S.C. 1853a
MSA § 303A
84
(E) authorize limited access privileges to harvest fish to be held, acquired, used by, or
issued under the system to persons who substantially participate in the fishery, including
in a specific sector of such fishery, as specified by the Council.
(6) PROGRAM INITIATION.—
(A) LIMITATION.—Except as provided in subparagraph (D), a Council may initiate a
fishery management plan or amendment to establish a limited access privilege program to
harvest fish on its own initiative or if the Secretary has certified an appropriate petition.
(B) PETITION.—A group of fishermen constituting more than 50 percent of the
permit holders, or holding more than 50 percent of the allocation, in the fishery for which
a limited access privilege program to harvest fish is sought, may submit a petition to the
Secretary requesting that the relevant Council or Councils with authority over the fishery
be authorized to initiate the development of the program. Any such petition shall clearly
state the fishery to which the limited access privilege program would apply. For
multispecies permits in the Gulf of Mexico, only those participants who have
substantially fished the species proposed to be included in the limited access program
shall be eligible to sign a petition for such a program and shall serve as the basis for
determining the percentage described in the first sentence of this subparagraph.
(C) CERTIFICATION BY SECRETARY.—Upon the receipt of any such petition, the
Secretary shall review all of the signatures on the petition and, if the Secretary determines
that the signatures on the petition represent more than 50 percent of the permit holders, or
holders of more than 50 percent of the allocation in the fishery, as described by
subparagraph (B), the Secretary shall certify the petition to the appropriate Council or
Councils.
(
Limited Access Priviledges = Catch Shares.This program should be avoided at all costs.Except for the "fat cats" in the Gulf that got all the shares,everyone else(the majority) got the shaft.Ask the fishermen that have to rent quota from the "fat cats" in order to fish.Not saying a split in the quota between N.C.,S.C. & Ga.,Fl.might be an option to look into but not with LAP/Catch Shares involved.
Limited Access Priviledges = Catch Shares.This program should be avoided at all costs.Except for the "fat cats" in the Gulf that got all the shares,everyone else(the majority) got the shaft.Ask the fishermen that have to rent quota from the "fat cats" in order to fish.Not saying a split in the quota between N.C.,S.C. & Ga.,Fl.might be an option to look into but not with LAP/Catch Shares involved.
LAP does not equal catch shares. The federal grouper snapper fishery is already a limited access fishery. The idea is to give NC/SC its own regional fishery independent of GA/FLA managed at the local level, not via catch shares! hope this clarifies my thoughts. Thanks
SAFMC just needs more free red snapper samples.
The 8 day extension gets them that....
If they had enough samples to make a decision about Red Snapper.
This would never be opened, like Tim said, they refused to reopen for the fishermen.
They don't care about North Carolina or the fishermen. :protest:
From what I read on the SAFMC site, the primary method being used to implement LAP is ITQ which I believe are "catch shares".The current system operates on limited access to permits but does not operate under a limited access "priivilege" where an individual or group gets a guaranteed access to a share of the quota.I have no problem with considering some "new" management scheme where N.C./S.C break off from the SAFMC's rule but the radical environmental groups that have such a hold on what's going on will never allow that but it would be interesting to see what the Council would say.I'd just be careful about requesting or labeling it as LAP.
The best chance we had to disrupt the " best in the world scientist" (ding dongs) just pasted Nov 6th
Until you get Jane and Roy from behind the wheel of the Agenda Wagon, nothing will change. Their mind has already been made, and you can't climb to the top of the ivory tower (where they live)... We are not worthy , or smart enough. They are INTENTIONALLY trying to put us all out of business.
Meals. dead on.
Seapower. time to get back to basics
Roughandready. Bingo!
Chris, I respect your efforts... I feel your pain on a state level with southern flounder. Hang in there. A squeaky wheel gets some grease
Does anybody know how many gag each state caught last year?How many fished each state ,each month?It,s probably on public record but don,t know where.Thanks
Does anybody know how many gag each state caught last year?How many fished each state ,each month?It,s probably on public record but don,t know where.Thanks
Below are numbers from NC - October was incomplete - I will update this as soon as I get a chance to get the numbers.
You are right this is public record and NC readily makes the data available, however, SAFMC refused my request to release their data on a state by state basis! I will try to compile the other states and post what I find.
NC should easily sustain a state quota of 300,000+ per year with proper management!
YEAR Month AFSNAME POUNDS DEALERS TRIPS
2012 5 Grouper, Gag 37,422 26 189
2012 6 Grouper, Gag 59,823 30 225
2012 7 Grouper, Gag 26,703 24 162
2012 8 Grouper, Gag 19,242 24 143
2012 9 Grouper, Gag 12,224 15 81
2012 10 Grouper, Gag *** 1 1
We have more power than Roy or Jane if we can get a 2/3 majority of permit holders to agree on something. We also have power in numbers through the consumers of seafood who are left out of almost all management discussions. We need to come up with a Public Comment for the December meeting offering solutions that have broad support from fishermen and show up at the meeting. We also need to call out the eco-charities that aggressively or passively support management measures that generate tons of Regulatory Discards while compromising the safety of fishermen at sea and deny consumers a dependable supply of safe American seafood.