SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Just wanted to see if anyone had any first hand experience with either electric assist reels. Want to know the good and bad...... Both are similar in price, but right now i can get the daiwa for 100 bucks cheaper than the kaigen. There is a write up on THT about how much better the kaigen is than the daiwa.
Thanks in advance
I have two tanacom 1000 reels on custom built black hole rods. I have had no problems with the reels. They have also been used to commercial fish as well. If you want more drag, simply upgrade the drag washers. I can get you the drag washer information. I also have a commercial buddy that fishes snapper- grouper complex using daiwa power assist reels. He has used them several years. If the reels sucked he would have trashed them a long time ago. I know nothing about Kaigen.
what are you looking to do with them?
Plan on using them to bottom fish/deep drop for grouper, snapper and tiles. Probably not much deeper than 1000-1200 ft. Not going after swords, but i think brant caught his sword on a daiwa tacacom bull. I think it overheated and shut down a couple times, but thats the nice thing about still being able to hand crank.
It should be fine for that. I would go MP3000 or one of the heavier duty ones if you are planning on doing much swordfishing. Daniel Simmon's 409 was caught on the MP3000. Brant's 150 was on the TB1000 because that's what he had, but he said would go heavier if getting something specifically for swords.
Lots of folks have many more hours on the tanacom so when you research you may find more bad reviews. But the reviews I have seen on the banax is top notch. Theres a guy on tht that sells them and stands behind them very heavily. I hope to add a tanacom.
Yeah waves the MP3000 is bad A, and the LP s1200 is even better. But I am on a budget, and want to stay under a grand.
yeah wolf I have been talking with that guy that sales the kaigen, great guy and very knowledgeable. But it is his product that he is trying to sale..... The kaigen has carbon fiber drag washers, bigger bearings, more heat dissipation/protection, and what looks to be stronger internal components overall. It also has a motor clutch that keeps you from back lashing while dropping.
If they were the exact same price, I think I would go with the kaigen. But i can get a hella deal on the tanacom right now for about 500, and the kaigen is 600.
And matador if i get the tanacom the first thing I am going to do is upgrade to carbon fiber washers. The drag washer info would be great. Thanks
Yeah waves the MP3000 is bad A, and the LP s1200 is even better. But I am on a budget, and want to stay under a grand.
yeah wolf I have been talking with that guy that sales the kaigen, great guy and very knowledgeable. But it is his product that he is trying to sale..... The kaigen has carbon fiber drag washers, bigger bearings, more heat dissipation/protection, and what looks to be stronger internal components overall. It also has a motor clutch that keeps you from back lashing while dropping.
If they were the exact same price, I think I would go with the kaigen. But i can get a hella deal on the tanacom right now for about 500, and the kaigen is 600.
And matador if i get the tanacom the first thing I am going to do is upgrade to carbon fiber washers. The drag washer info would be great. Thanks
That's my reasoning going with the tanacom. Can get too good a deal to pass it up. Didn't know about the drag upgrade so will have to look into that when it's time.
Like everything it all depends how much you use them... We send back for repair to Daiwa at least 6 Tanacoms a year which are mostly used in shallow water. The weakest point is the power cord and throw away one a month! We just started trying the Shimanos and time will tell. But we've already upgraded to the Hooker for swords!
I have two of the banax reels and cant say enough good about them. No issues, easy to operate and even run one on the long line when in the stream.. Catching blackfin on the WWB line is easy now... haha it will bring a 20lb tuna to the boat with ease.
I have four Diawas and use them pretty hard for grouper fishing in shallow water. I like them ok but will second the weak cord issue. The cords tangle up and when you snatch on a fish, pulling on the cord inadvertently, it breaks them. the real still has enough power to stay turned on but not enough to operate.
Mine also overheat on big grouper in anything over 110 feet of water if you have the drag down hard. All in all they are ok but not perfect. Not near as strong as the old electramates but not near as heavy and cumbersome. I can fish them all day and not be whipped which is extra nice! Buy you some extra cords and watch your drag as you get them off the bottom.
Yeah waves the MP3000 is bad A, and the LP s1200 is even better. But I am on a budget, and want to stay under a grand.
yeah wolf I have been talking with that guy that sales the kaigen, great guy and very knowledgeable. But it is his product that he is trying to sale..... The kaigen has carbon fiber drag washers, bigger bearings, more heat dissipation/protection, and what looks to be stronger internal components overall. It also has a motor clutch that keeps you from back lashing while dropping.
If they were the exact same price, I think I would go with the kaigen. But i can get a hella deal on the tanacom right now for about 500, and the kaigen is 600.
And matador if i get the tanacom the first thing I am going to do is upgrade to carbon fiber washers. The drag washer info would be great. Thanks
That's my reasoning going with the tanacom. Can get too good a deal to pass it up. Didn't know about the drag upgrade so will have to look into that when it's time.
Yeah they come from the factory with felt washers.....
I have heard the cords are POS, i think it is the same with both brands.
Thanks for all the feed back, good to hear the daiwas will hold up to the rigors of commercial fishing. Was going to put 80lb braid on them, is that what everyone uses?
Yeah waves the MP3000 is bad A, and the LP s1200 is even better. But I am on a budget, and want to stay under a grand.
yeah wolf I have been talking with that guy that sales the kaigen, great guy and very knowledgeable. But it is his product that he is trying to sale..... The kaigen has carbon fiber drag washers, bigger bearings, more heat dissipation/protection, and what looks to be stronger internal components overall. It also has a motor clutch that keeps you from back lashing while dropping.
If they were the exact same price, I think I would go with the kaigen. But i can get a hella deal on the tanacom right now for about 500, and the kaigen is 600.
And matador if i get the tanacom the first thing I am going to do is upgrade to carbon fiber washers. The drag washer info would be great. Thanks
Don't know anything about these reels, but if you need to upgrade drag washers and the other reel had better heat dissipation/protection...$100 more seems a better deal. Just my .02 :shrug:
You really don't need to upgrade washers. It's more of a preference. The tanacom is at 48 lb drag and the Kaigen is 45 lb but says 20 lb recommended. Not sure about less than half the max being recommended. It is not recommended by the manufacturers to bump up the drag in any of these reels by enhancing the washers.
And like someone else added above, these reels make for a much better day fishing bc you are not wore out. I had to get them bc I need neck surgery and a lot of reeling makes my fingers go numb on one hand. I really don't think a person can can go wrong with any of them. I for one like Shimano reels bar none and looked and their similar reels to the tanacom and I'm just not going to pay the difference but some of those shimanos are bada$$. And the tanacom Bulls are nice too and I preferred the bull but wasn't willing to pay the difference.
Seems to me that an extra $100 for a reel I don't have to buy and put new drag washers in and don't have to buy and replace the power cord is a petty good deal. The cost and time to do this would be worth $100.00 to me just to not have to do it. Just my .02. Good luck with whatever you decide.