SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Need some clarification on dual batteries. My understanding is cranking battery for obviously starting engine and deep cycle best for electronics, I.e. Bottom fishing with motor off and instruments on. I didn't much pay attention to what I had when I bought my boat but now see its two crank batteries. I was in need of a new battery in a fix the other day and purchased a deep cycle.
So, OK to have one of each? Two deep cycles if I replace the other one?
Also have read differing opinions on running switch on 1, 2, or both. My dealer told me to run on both. Thoughts and thanks for advise.
Most batteries in a dual setup are cranking
The starting battery should be #1 and the battery switch should stay on #1.The house battery(electronics& accessories) is #2 and is kept charged with a voltage sensing relay.This way nothing is drawing off the starting battery and it stays charged.It's not good to run battery switch on both.Both batteries could be discharged and not start engine.Also if one battery has a dead cell it would pull the other battery down with it.With a VSR the batteries are isolated.
Only way you should ever run the switch in "BOTH" is with identical batteries, purchased at the same time and used identically.
Don't ask how I've learned this, over and over.
Ok, so do you start on battery 1, and then switch to "2" at some point? Or just leave on "1" all day?
Thanks
I always use the "BOTH" setting.
Check out this video link below. Does anyone have any experience with the Blue Sea Battery System?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=B4830QsybbM
I always use the "BOTH" setting.
Not good practice. If your charging system had ever failed and you weren't watching your gauge, when your motor quit both batteries would have been dead and you would have been adrift with no radio. If you had kill just one, at least you would have had the other battery to hail for assistance and get you some distance toward port or at least to where you could safely drop anchor.
After today I will be getting a dual battery system.
Only have a single battery system and today my engine would not start - 5 hrs of 2 livewells, fishfinder and stereo did me in. Luckily the radio island boat ramp was down current and down wind of me. Riptide to the rescue - it got me to the dock so I could borrow a jump start box. Got it refired and motored back to Airport boat ramp. Short term and as a back up I will be getting a jump start pack - long term, dual batteries!
intubaited: So you would recommend using one or the other. For a while I was using odd/even to match the day of the month.
I do see your point, but don't like getting a power down on the GPS when I start the engine. Just a nuscense, but better than calling TowBoat.
Battery switch stays on #1(starting battery)...House battery(electronics&accessories)is #2 and charged with voltage sensing relay.This relay simply connects between #1 & #2 post on battery switch.This way there is no voltage drop on gps/fishfinder when starting engine and nothing drawing voltage from starting battery
I am running the setup above, Starting(1) + house(2), but start on the starting battery (1) and switch to (2) after a few minutes and the battery has recharged. Is there a problem with this?
From how I'm taking your post I should be installing a VSR like this? And run it on (1) always.. what are the benefits of this compared? Just not having to switch the perko switch?
http://www.westmarine.com/buy/marinco--digital-voltage-sensing-relay-dvsr-12-24v--14152185
intubaited: So you would recommend using one or the other. For a while I was using odd/even to match the day of the month.
I do see your point, but don't like getting a power down on the GPS when I start the engine. Just a nuscense, but better than calling TowBoat.
Sorry for this lengthy response, but you'll get a bunch of opinions on "the best" way to manage multiple batteries and I don't have that. I have one step above a single battery which is dual batteries on a switch and system that works for me. I run both deep cycle starting batteries and generally always have them both fully charged before I leave the dock. I'll use one for starting and running and the other for when the motor is off. If I don't cut the motor off, the second one may not get used at all.
Just about the only variation to that would be if I pull up anchor to make a decent run and want to put some charge back in the one I was anchored on. I have a single outboard and they really don't significantly charge a battery underway so I wouldn't run with anything else drawing power that wasn't absolutely necessary. I have been known to run on "both" in that situation to charge the one I was drawing off of while it also borrows juice from the starting battery. I hope that all makes sense.
Anger M ..Your way would work fine.For me,there is a lot of starting and stopping so to much switching and remembering to switch.Yes,that vsr would work.
Here is a good read , it s called solving the battery switch dilemma. http://www.boattest.com/Resources/view_news.aspx?NewsID=3084