SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

flounder closure la...
 
Notifications
Clear all

flounder closure lawsuit

56 Posts
22 Users
0 Reactions
143.8 K Views
Cliff Pack
(@recess)
Eminent Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 36
 

You are so right about us needing to solve our own problems Matador. You also have some good suggestions for funding hatcheries. We could tap into existing taxes such as the Dingell-Johnson tackle tax and Saltonstal-Kennedy tax on imported seafood. We should also have more say in how our license fees are used. A 1% restocking fee on all seafood sales in NC could fund a wide variety of stocking efforts.



   
ReplyQuote
john
 john
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 214
 

Recognizing Dingell Johnston is a sportfish restoration tax and Saltonstall Kennedy taxes imported seafood, and a tax on seafood sales would be coming from consumers what is the commercial industry going to pony up to help pay for the stocking as they would be financially benefitting from it?



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

Recognizing Dingell Johnston is a sportfish restoration tax and Saltonstall Kennedy taxes imported seafood, and a tax on seafood sales would be coming from consumers what is the commercial industry going to pony up to help pay for the stocking as they would be financially benefitting from it?

You could tax their poundage but one way or the other the consumer pays directly or indirectly.



   
ReplyQuote
Drew Maultsby
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 806
 

There is no hatchery in the world that can compete financially, or productivity wise, with a healthy stock of mature flounder in a clean environment. Competing with that model, instead of protecting and nourishing it, is pissing into the wind. Saying that hatcheries will supplement, rather than compete, is nonsense because the shares of effort and dollars for both all come out of the same pie.



   
ReplyQuote
George Golinski
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1371
 

I am not in favor of using hatcheries to grow flounder numbers beyond what a healthy population can provide via normal reproduction. If you do that you'll risk moving the issue to another species rather than solving the problem. Those additional flounder will eat something, be it juvenile grouper, sea bass, trout or crabs. IMHO hatcheries work well to re-establish species that have declined in numbers, but are a potential hazard to other species if overused.



   
ReplyQuote
john
 john
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 214
 

So what you are saying is that the consumer and folks that buy lots of tackle, trolling motors, etc would be subsidizing (welfaring)the commercial fisherman by paying for the fish they would harvest. Why not just pay them not to catch them and let the population rebuild



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

There is no hatchery in the world that can compete financially, or productivity wise, with a healthy stock of mature flounder in a clean environment. Competing with that model, instead of protecting and nourishing it, is pissing into the wind. Saying that hatcheries will supplement, rather than compete, is nonsense because the shares of effort and dollars for both all come out of the same pie.

What do you propose then? Shutting it down until it rebuilds? Nobody wants to take that bullet rec. or commercial. That's the whole problem, no one wants to pay and no one wants to sacrifice. So if that's the way it is going to be then someone has to pay to help bridge the gap.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

So what you are saying is that the consumer and folks that buy lots of tackle, trolling motors, etc would be subsidizing (welfaring)the commercial fisherman by paying for the fish they would harvest. Why not just pay them not to catch them and let the population rebuild

Not exactly, everyone would have to pony up. And keep in my the flounder stock is basically split down the middle. What if those deep pockets on the commercial side garnered more of the rec. poundage? And as for your last sentence, don't rule that out because I have heard that mentioned more than once as an alternative but where does the money come from? And that can also be a slippery slope because their are some that want gamefish status and I haven't seen that as being very successful.

I'm just tossing out ideas to keep the fishery going. But the recs. usually take the hit. That's why I got the commercial license.



   
ReplyQuote
Bobby
(@marker39)
Estimable Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 102
 

Split down the middle?

http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/mf/12-southern-flounder-ssr-2015



   
ReplyQuote
john
 john
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 214
 

Folks did that to rebuild striped bass years ago coastwide. NC tried hard to say our stripers didn't go to ocean to keep from being subjected to same rules.



   
ReplyQuote
john
 john
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 214
 

Maybe the commercial fisherman that harvests a flounder needs to purchase a stamp. That would go for anyone wanting to keep one using commercial gear whether targeting with gigging, large mesh or pound nets or bycatch in small mesh, crabpot, etc.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

Split down the middle?

http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/mf/12-southern-flounder-ssr-2015

My mistake. I was looking at the 2005-14 data against 2015 data. And I was looking at Summer not Southern.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

It is good to see some critical thinking and serious discussion about this important topic. Here are my replys to some of the questions and comments.

"Recognizing Dingell Johnston is a sportfish restoration tax and Saltonstall Kennedy taxes imported seafood, and a tax on seafood sales would be coming from consumers what is the commercial industry going to pony up to help pay for the stocking as they would be financially benefitting from it?"

Commercial fishing license fees could help fund hatcheries. A 1% restocking fee on all seafood sales could be applied to every sale starting at the dock so everyone ponies up.

"You could tax their poundage but one way or the other the consumer pays directly or indirectly."

It is true that most business costs are ultimately passed on to the consumer. Consumers are the largest user group of our state's seafood but are left out of most management discussions. A 1% restocking fee would give them more of a voice as they pony up keep stocks healthy.

"There is no hatchery in the world that can compete financially, or productivity wise, with a healthy stock of mature flounder in a clean environment. Competing with that model, instead of protecting and nourishing it, is pissing into the wind. Saying that hatcheries will supplement, rather than compete, is nonsense because the shares of effort and dollars for both all come out of the same pie."

This might be true in a perfect world, but we must deal with the reality that our environment is far from pristine. I held the purest point of view for a long time until I learned more about stocking. We should work to enhance habitat so it can support at least as much marine life as it did centuries ago. Stocking doesn't have to cost so much if we only raised juveniles to just past the plankton stage. The mortality rate would be higher than if we raised them to fingerlings, but those that survive would be stronger.

"I am not in favor of using hatcheries to grow flounder numbers beyond what a healthy population can provide via normal reproduction. If you do that you'll risk moving the issue to another species rather than solving the problem. Those additional flounder will eat something, be it juvenile grouper, sea bass, trout or crabs. IMHO hatcheries work well to re-establish species that have declined in numbers, but are a potential hazard to other species if overused."

Fishery biologists should establish caps on how many of each species can be stocked without overpopulating any of them. Keep in mind that higher production should also result in higher landings.

"So what you are saying is that the consumer and folks that buy lots of tackle, trolling motors, etc would be subsidizing (welfaring)the commercial fisherman by paying for the fish they would harvest. Why not just pay them not to catch them and let the population rebuild"

This is why I say the recreational and commercial sectors should be given the option of funding half of potential Hatchery Supported Quotas. Most fishermen would rather work than be paid not to. Hatcheries and habitat enhancement are proven solutions that can benefit everyone and the environment when used wisely. Shouldn't we focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting the public's freedom to access them?



   
ReplyQuote
David
(@tanktom)
Honorable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 525
 

So ... is flounder closing this weekend or not? Thanks and tight lines!



   
ReplyQuote
Capt.Barbosa
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 784
 

Remove the blasted nets, take gigging away from recs, only allow commercial gigging. Keep the rec limits the same only hook and line.

Best idea i have ever heard................!!!!!!!!!! Don't get me wrong I love gigging, but some rec giggers just abuse the resource.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 3 / 4
Share: