SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I agree looks like one we caught of big pine key last year. If they stay our reefs are going to suffer. The guys in Florida use a cut off 130 rig and when hooked leave it in the holder and let them wear down. The mouth gets sore and they will not eat for a day or 2 😯
I agree looks like one we caught of big pine key last year. If they stay our reefs are going to suffer. The guys in Florida use a cut off 130 rig and when hooked leave it in the holder and let them wear down. The mouth gets sore and they will not eat for a day or 2 😯
I dive a lot in FL and agree -- these fish can suck a ledge or wreck dry of fish. Easiest way to tell it is a Goliath (other than the size) is the tail, which is rounded. Was that the case? I have yet to see a Goliath up here, fishing or diving.
Wow, it sure looks like one from here--looks way too light in color to be a Warsaw and the dorsal spines resemble a Goliath too
After looking at a few additional pics the tail does appear to be rounded. Also we caught the fish in 70' of water and it is my understanding that warsaw are typically in 250+ feet and are also much darker in color.
..Also we caught the fish in 70' of water and it is my understanding that warsaw are typically in 250+ feet...
True. =) We had quite a few goliath on shallow water areas (esp nearshore wrecks) of Destin. fwiw, Warsaw also have a tall 2nd spine out of its 10.
Anyway, that's great to see that out of NC!
Sure looks like one. NCDMF has had commercial guys reporting catches for years, we have some in our waters.
ok first off great catch
Next thing is it good to have them here in NC or not. I have heard of tons problems with them in Fla.!!!!!!
But man it would be great to have them to inshore fish for just for the fight!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I think the problems with them in Florida is that there is an antiquated ban from keeping them. They were largely over fished in the past but their stocks seem to be improving greatly..... yet the ban remains.
I hope we don't see this same junk with the ARS!
They are really cool fish, I have seen specimens that easily went 400 pounds. I am wondering whether they have always been here, or have they pushed up north because of the growing population down south due to their fishing ban. These fish are at the top of the food chain, no predators. They suck up other fish and lobsters pretty quickly to get to the size that they do.
Can we keep them off NC? That is alotagroupa meat.
They are big vaccuum cleaners. I hope this one is lost or following some finger of warm water. I've dove wrecks in the keys that were almost devoid of fish, except goliaths. They need to do some sort of capture lottery or sell tags or something down there. I lived there back in 1998 and it was bad then, I can't imagine it's any better now.
When I was fishing at Marathon FL last winter, we caught these grouper in 40 and 50 feet of water. They were everywhere! Our guide was trying to get away from them; he kept saying another "endangered" fish and laughing. The first few were fun on spinning gear, but they got old in a hurry. Looks like FL needs to open a limit on these big fish.
Thanks for the post and picture, nice catch.
Jew Fish are seen by divers in NC mostly in or around ship wrecks. I believe fisherman don't catch more of them because they will run back into the wreck and break the line. A spearfisherman shot a 90 some pound Jewfish at masonboro jetty and took his catch to Motts to sell not realizing it was a federally protected species. He recieved a hefty fine I believe.
I have seen them while diving in various parts of Florida where there were other fish all around them on the reef. Maybe they just didn't get a chance to eat them all yet.
They are so big I can't imagine they are very quick chasing smaller reef complex species. However, as big as they are I bet they require a lot of food to maintain their size...
