SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

marine patrol
 
Notifications
Clear all

marine patrol

83 Posts
41 Users
0 Reactions
130.5 K Views
Randy Harris
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 344
 

You can show someone permits and license all day but until you show some type of ID with a photo you going to get the once over,everyone should carry a photo ID even if you never get checked.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

What is a young person to do????

.

So if someone is 15 and doesn't have an ID yet, what are they to do?

Regarding the story above about the officer who said the young person had to have an ID, last time I checked burden of proof is on the officer. You don't have to prove you are under 16, he has to prove you are over it. Even if he wrote you a ticket it would be thrown out in court.

Again its not the LEO proving your age as it the court would require the individual to produce ID, birth certificate....burden of proof on individual and even if thrown out officer did their job as they could not 100% identify in field so they sent to court to sort out.

And this is NOT how the law is supposed to work. Burden of Proof is on the State. They SHOULD have to have proof you are over 16 to write a citation. It obviously doesn't work that way, but that doesn't make it right.



   
ReplyQuote
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 1598
 

Really, and how are they supposed prove or disprove your age when you have no valid ID and never provided a DNA sample or been fingerprinted. Maybe everyone should have a microchip implanted in them at birth, then you don't have to be bothered with carrying a valid means of ID.



   
ReplyQuote
Randy
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 450
 

Really, and how are they supposed prove or disprove your age when you have no valid ID and never provided a DNA sample or been fingerprinted. Maybe everyone should have a microchip implanted in them at birth, then you don't have to be bothered with carrying a valid means of ID.

Surely you jest.The folks who magically know how many grouper,seabass and snapper there are in the ocean as well as how old they are when they breed in order to set limits and close seasons on all fishermen should be able to tell the age of a teenage boy.
No chip for me. The last people I saw with markings tatooed on them didn't fare too well.



   
ReplyQuote
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 1598
 

Yes it was sarcasm.



   
ReplyQuote
Barry Turano
(@barryturano)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 2720
 

Just out of curiosity. How does a teenager say 14-15-16 get on to an airplane? I doubt they are driving at that age. Keeping aside those who have a passport. You are required to show a photo id to get to the boarding area. Just wondering.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

Mentioned earlier in the thread: "Did you know that every legal resident of NC that has a ssn can get a state ID from the NC DMV..all ages. my son has had one since he was 10 and it makes traveling through airports so easy."

That is what I used to travel prior to having a driver's license.



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

No chip for me. The last people I saw with markings tatooed on them didn't fare too well.

I'd be willing to bet the day of the chip is coming.



   
ReplyQuote
scott Evans
(@mzbhavn)
Eminent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 36
 

No chip for me. The last people I saw with markings tatooed on them didn't fare too well.

I'd be willing to bet the day of the chip is coming.

Its buried in the "American Job Act" and part of "Obama care" havent you heard 🙄 but dont worry its paid for by are ever so small government



   
ReplyQuote
scott Evans
(@mzbhavn)
Eminent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 36
 

"And this is NOT how the law is supposed to work. Burden of Proof is on the State. They SHOULD have to have proof you are over 16 to write a citation. It obviously doesn't work that way, but that doesn't make it right."

It just depends on how you want to look at it. If they can't positively ID you and the offense is a misdemeanor or felony then they should arrest you so that they can confirm they aren't being provided false information. So ask yourself how long you want to be detained or in custody until they can demonstrate the burden of proof of who you really are before releasing you. The laws and policies also apply to minors, they just dont get jailed with adults.

There is alot of misperception of LEO requirements and a person rights and frankly it can be scary of how much power they have.....ok I will admit I do miss the gun, badge and handcuffs, but I dont miss dealing with the general public and the people that think LEO are like the cop TV shows. Nor do I miss wondering if the next call would be my last as you never knew what you were walking into.

Thank you to all our dedicated LEO's and military personnel that protect my freedoms.



   
ReplyQuote
Randy Harris
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 344
 

Still in the field no ID no go,you should have a ID with a photo to prove who you are,you have to have a photo ID to do everything else why not fishing or to show your age and who you are,its a safe thing to do in the long run,is it so big a problem to do that ?



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Gorges
(@captaingorges)
Noble Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 1581
 

We aren't talking for positive ID after an offense, just plain carrying ID. If you aren't breaking a law why does it matter who you are? I have only once been asked for ID by somebody on the water and he then detained me for over 30 minutes for sobriety tests then golly gee wiz I blew a .00... I am a professional captain and stay legal 100% of the time but will never give one more inch than required by written law, not law as interpreted by somebody who is jacked on the fact they have a gun, badge, and handcuffs.



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

We aren't talking for positive ID after an offense, just plain carrying ID. If you aren't breaking a law why does it matter who you are? I have only once been asked for ID by somebody on the water and he then detained me for over 30 minutes for sobriety tests then golly gee wiz I blew a .00... I am a professional captain and stay legal 100% of the time but will never give one more inch than required by written law, not law as interpreted by somebody who is jacked on the fact they have a gun, badge, and handcuffs.

I bet if you were female in a bikini, he would have just let you go. Just sayin ... Best advice is to let them do their job - have papers in order and be polite. Makes me wonder if their funding or job performance is tied in with the amount of tickets they write.



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

So if ID is so important how does ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS produce one? And don't tell me they don't fish, do they just get a free pass?, and if so, I'm heading to a tanning booth.



   
ReplyQuote
scott Evans
(@mzbhavn)
Eminent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 36
 

We aren't talking for positive ID after an offense, just plain carrying ID. If you aren't breaking a law why does it matter who you are? I have only once been asked for ID by somebody on the water and he then detained me for over 30 minutes for sobriety tests then golly gee wiz I blew a .00... I am a professional captain and stay legal 100% of the time but will never give one more inch than required by written law, not law as interpreted by somebody who is jacked on the fact they have a gun, badge, and handcuffs.

I bet if you were female in a bikini, he would have just let you go. Just sayin ... Best advice is to let them do their job - have papers in order and be polite. Makes me wonder if their funding or job performance is tied in with the amount of tickets they write.

Isnt every job measured by some sort of performance? we were always told if not writing reports you better be writing tickets or be doing trackable community tasks. Funding was never mentioned or came back to the department so I would say that is just silly talk. Finally, like any other job you are going to have those that are better or worse in handling each and every situation they come across, but few professions actually have to wonder if this encounter will be their last. SO give them a break, let em do ther job and it will go that much quicker and easier. IF you arent happy take care of it through their chain of command.

If you are charter fishing captain you are not only measured by how safe you can handle a boat but also by how many fish you get. The problem with dealing with a LEO is that most people don't think they need to give that inch because they feel they aren't doing wrong, things go down hill and then 1 of million laws are starting to be broken and the only place to sort it out is in court which is as big of a waste of time as your washington politicians. Thats when it all goes down hill, get stopped on land you will show an ID as well. No excuse to be a prick but possibly your the last encounter of a long day of trying to be professional while dealing with people that think there are other fish in the sea that you should be going after. Generally LEO are so scrutinized that it make it tough living in that fish bowl, they are judged and second guessed about everything and they dont have time to walk around with big heads or ego's as when you need help you need those around you and they may not be law enforcement.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 5 / 6
Share: