SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Mud minnows for spa...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Mud minnows for spanish?

34 Posts
12 Users
0 Reactions
42.2 K Views
John Gann
(@ab1620)
Honorable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 616
 

Where do you fish out of? Out of MHC there are plenty of creeks that are slam full of peanut pogies in the summer. It's rare if I throw more than once. Finger mullet swim the best and are the toughest but also take a little longer to catch. Especially early in the summer. I like to carry both that way I can throw some overboard if they aren't awake and biting yet.



   
ReplyQuote
Kevin
(@kp1226)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 156
Topic starter  

Where do you fish out of? Out of MHC there are plenty of creeks that are slam full of peanut pogies in the summer. It's rare if I throw more than once. Finger mullet swim the best and are the toughest but also take a little longer to catch. Especially early in the summer. I like to carry both that way I can throw some overboard if they aren't awake and biting yet.

I fish out of Southport.



   
ReplyQuote
Micheal McCoy
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 665
 

Want bigger Spanish? Troll a daisy chain behind a bird with a decent flashy stinger lure. You’ll get fewer strikes but better quality fish.

Yep! I use BWC daisies. Haven’t used the bird, but the daisy by itself slightly out-fished my spoons last year. Best part is that a bluefish has never hit mine.

Oh They will and they will mess your rig up.



   
ReplyQuote
Bilzo
(@bilzo)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 2620
 

fishing out of hatteras we haven't had bluefish hit the daisy chains when targeting spanish. But we do get a fat albert every now and then.



   
ReplyQuote
David Tedder
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 11 years ago
Posts: 55
 

I've caught quite a few citation size spanish on small and medium size pogies trolling for kings. Our baits were from 4 to 6 inches long. They will hit frozen cigar minnows too. Small live mullets will catch them too. All the citations I've caught were in 40 to 60 ft water.. Gottca plugs and spoons are great close in,, peanut pogies or finger mullet will catch some large than average size fish closer inshore



   
ReplyQuote
John Gann
(@ab1620)
Honorable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 616
 

To everyone saying pull a daisy chain, clarkspoon etc, it's clearly obvious he's wanting to live bait for big ones. And I can promise you a peanut pogie or a finger mullet will out fish any of that any day of the week on 4+ pound Spanish. Sure you may catch one every now and then on them but a size 8 gold treble with a 3-4 inch piece of 30 lb 7 strand with the smallest spro swivel you can find will out fish that any day. Trust me, many of days I've watched numerous boats do circles around me on the reefs with planers and birds throwing their arms up wondering how I'm catching them one after another.



   
ReplyQuote
John
 John
(@piratejuan)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 299
 

fishing out of hatteras we haven't had bluefish hit the daisy chains when targeting spanish. But we do get a fat albert every now and then.

Yeah alberts and bonitos have hit mine, but bluefish don't seem to like the surface stuff around here.



   
ReplyQuote
Kevin
(@kp1226)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 156
Topic starter  

To everyone saying pull a daisy chain, clarkspoon etc, it's clearly obvious he's wanting to live bait for big ones. And I can promise you a peanut pogie or a finger mullet will out fish any of that any day of the week on 4+ pound Spanish. Sure you may catch one every now and then on them but a size 8 gold treble with a 3-4 inch piece of 30 lb 7 strand with the smallest spro swivel you can find will out fish that any day. Trust me, many of days I've watched numerous boats do circles around me on the reefs with planers and birds throwing their arms up wondering how I'm catching them one after another.

Based on what you are saying in your example of the reefs, with the live pogies, do you fish the same areas as you would the spoons and planers? Like the tidelines for instance or is it better to fish the reef areas or rocks like you would kings?

Meat fishing with planers and spoons is fun but im ready to step it up and "sportfish" a little with the spanish. Rather have 4-5 really nice spanish and fight them on light tackle than to limit out on 14-15" with spoons.



   
ReplyQuote
Bilzo
(@bilzo)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 2620
 

To everyone saying pull a daisy chain, clarkspoon etc, it's clearly obvious he's wanting to live bait for big ones. And I can promise you a peanut pogie or a finger mullet will out fish any of that any day of the week on 4+ pound Spanish. Sure you may catch one every now and then on them but a size 8 gold treble with a 3-4 inch piece of 30 lb 7 strand with the smallest spro swivel you can find will out fish that any day. Trust me, many of days I've watched numerous boats do circles around me on the reefs with planers and birds throwing their arms up wondering how I'm catching them one after another.

Good point. But live baiting big Spanish with mud minnows is clearly not the best approach, and I think we've all convinced him of that.

How much harassment do you get from Blues and other creatures when you're live baiting? (disclaimer - it's only harassment if its a trash fish).



   
ReplyQuote
John
 John
(@piratejuan)
Reputable Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 299
 

To everyone saying pull a daisy chain, clarkspoon etc, it's clearly obvious he's wanting to live bait for big ones. And I can promise you a peanut pogie or a finger mullet will out fish any of that any day of the week on 4+ pound Spanish. Sure you may catch one every now and then on them but a size 8 gold treble with a 3-4 inch piece of 30 lb 7 strand with the smallest spro swivel you can find will out fish that any day. Trust me, many of days I've watched numerous boats do circles around me on the reefs with planers and birds throwing their arms up wondering how I'm catching them one after another.

Good point. But live baiting big Spanish with mud minnows is clearly not the best approach, and I think we've all convinced him of that.

How much harassment do you get from Blues and other creatures when you're live baiting? (disclaimer - it's only harassment if its a trash fish).

Or the tax man



   
ReplyQuote
Capt.Barbosa
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 784
 

To everyone saying pull a daisy chain, clarkspoon etc, it's clearly obvious he's wanting to live bait for big ones. And I can promise you a peanut pogie or a finger mullet will out fish any of that any day of the week on 4+ pound Spanish. Sure you may catch one every now and then on them but a size 8 gold treble with a 3-4 inch piece of 30 lb 7 strand with the smallest spro swivel you can find will out fish that any day. Trust me, many of days I've watched numerous boats do circles around me on the reefs with planers and birds throwing their arms up wondering how I'm catching them one after another.

best advice so far. You can either slow troll with smallish pogies or anchor on bottom structure and light line. The great thing about anchoring is you can fish for flounder, etc, etc, and also be fishing for spanish, king and cobia with a light line. If your current is right you can free line without balloon or kite, if not you can use balloons and run multiple lines. Some guys I take out want to do both (flounder fish and king fish), so I will anchor on good flounder spots let them pound the bottom and will usually catch some nice Spaniards or kings too.



   
ReplyQuote
John Gann
(@ab1620)
Honorable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 616
 

To everyone saying pull a daisy chain, clarkspoon etc, it's clearly obvious he's wanting to live bait for big ones. And I can promise you a peanut pogie or a finger mullet will out fish any of that any day of the week on 4+ pound Spanish. Sure you may catch one every now and then on them but a size 8 gold treble with a 3-4 inch piece of 30 lb 7 strand with the smallest spro swivel you can find will out fish that any day. Trust me, many of days I've watched numerous boats do circles around me on the reefs with planers and birds throwing their arms up wondering how I'm catching them one after another.

Based on what you are saying in your example of the reefs, with the live pogies, do you fish the same areas as you would the spoons and planers? Like the tidelines for instance or is it better to fish the reef areas or rocks like you would kings?

Meat fishing with planers and spoons is fun but im ready to step it up and "sportfish" a little with the spanish. Rather have 4-5 really nice spanish and fight them on light tackle than to limit out on 14-15" with spoons.

I have. I have stopped where I have seen them busting/jumping on tidelines and done ok. I have also done pretty well around bait balls on the beach but the tried and true method is on the nearshore wrecks right at first light. They will bite through the day if not many boats show up but at the nearshore wrecks out of MHC that's not gonna happen. Spanish are a little different than Kings in that they like to hold right on top of the structure. You can catch them around the wrecks and on the smaller structure but I have typically had the banner days right on top of the main structure. I don't like to anchor. I typically do one of two things: slow troll like I do for Kings or pull up on top of the structure and throw a couple lines out. I don't like to anchor because I don't want to lose an anchor and I also don't want to take up the whole wreck. Everyone can fish it if it's done that way. If you have a livewell full of baits, pull on top of the wreck and throw a net full overboard and have each person throw a line out and hang on.

As far as the trash fish go, that's always a possibility but it seems to depend on the day. The bigger sharks leave you alone due to the smaller baits but the smaller ones will mess with you. The blue fish are there some days and non existent others. Seems the hotter it gets they head inshore. One Pain in the butt is the Needle fish or Carteret County Marlin as some call them. If they are around you might as well move to a different wreck.

One more thing on the tackle. Use your trout rods instead of your typical trolling rods (TLDs, etc). The light tip seems to help with the bite on the tiny trebles. Just make sure you put 10 feet or so of a fluoro leader on. Oh and leave the trailer off. You will miss bites but at least you are getting bites. I'd say 90% of days they WILL NOT bite a rig with a trailer.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

Spanish are, in my experience, much more leader shy than kings



   
ReplyQuote
Kevin
(@kp1226)
Estimable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 156
Topic starter  

Thanks everyone.



   
ReplyQuote
John Gann
(@ab1620)
Honorable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 616
 

Spanish are, in my experience, much more leader shy than kings

Correct. I've seen one come charging in on a finger mullet and come to a screeching halt inches from the bait. Look at it.....then swim away. The short light 7 strand is the best way to go.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 3
Share: