SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

NCDMF for hire logb...
 
Notifications
Clear all

NCDMF for hire logbook!!

111 Posts
29 Users
0 Reactions
116.7 K Views
JOHNNY CARPENTER
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1169
 

WOOOOOOEEEEE!!!! Sure will be nice when warm weather comes. You fellas are getting pretty rough on each other.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

When Dave checks this thread out there's going to be trouble.



   
ReplyQuote
Fernie Brown
(@)
Prominent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 784
 

He may be out of locks.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

I think everyone wants the best data available and a log book could be a step in the right direction especially from the for hire fleet although I don't see how boats like the Continental Shelf could possibly keep track of 100 fares on board and their releases.

BUT....

It is what happens WITH that data that needs to change FIRST.

When SAFMC and DMF use ridiculous assumptions in their computer modeling, it produces ridiculous results so it does not matter what goes in because what comes out is crap

Garbage IN... Garbage OUT

When they use unrealistic release survival rates, this new data will be used to shut down healthy fisheries (again).

When they assume that 90% (or whatever their number is) of all released fish die, those will be used to shorten seasons AGAIN

They need to fix the back end before messing with the front end

I think catch and consume regardless of size is the only possible answer. It is well known the more diverse the size and age structure, the healthier the fish stocks are. Forcing everyone to catch only the bigger fish, focuses all effort on specific year classes and the overall population becomes full of holes. The effects of those holes in the population structure become more apparent in the natural boom and bust cycles of the fish.
Take your limit regardless of size and take it home.

~

Good in theory but impossible to stop people from culling dead fish for the biggest ones to take home

He is greedy by nature. Do you really believe he would bring in small fish that both counted against the quota and he was paid less for less weight? Lots of comm BS in this thread.



   
ReplyQuote
Sea Cern
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 172
 

Does anyone have any doubt that the process is broken? How can anyone have any faith in FRA-97, with the Governor, with the Director, with Nancy Fish the MFC liaison who hand-picks MFC Advisory Committee members, with Sammy Corbett-MFC Chairman who appoints AC members or with Jennie Hauser- the MFC legal counsel when a member of the NCMFC FinFish Advisory Committee makes these kind of posts in a public forum. All credibility is lost for everyone involved and the total process.

#LouisDaniel #JennieHauser #PatMCCroy #NacyFish #SammyCorbett #NCMFC #NCDMF #NCDENR #DonaldVanderVaart



   
ReplyQuote
Wayne Batten
(@cwayne)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 811
 

I know Dave is at the Expo. Soon as he sees this one now it is history. What started off as a good subject surely got detailed a couple of pages ago. Seem like some people only want to talk about their feelings no matter what others think.



   
ReplyQuote
Capt Ryan Jordan
(@pin)
Honorable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 466
 

I am not a for hire captain but I did sleep at a holiday inn express last night...No seriously, I know lots of the charter guys. One of them is my oyster partner every day so I am maybe a little more tuned into that industry than the common man though not completely well versed. But, I do consider them to be commercial fishermen just like me for the simple reason that they make profit from the public resource just like me. I know that they prefer the recreational label and it's easy to understand why as who'd want all the hassle that being a comm fisherman brings with it. I think we're still a little ways off from having any kind of real data on recreational anglers simply because the technology doesn't exist that would make it completely easy for every rec angler to report in a timely manner. But the for hire fleet is perfectly capable of keeping up with their numbers and for one simple reason. I hear my partner everyday talking to the tuna fleet and the bottom fishing captains who are his good friends and everyday I hear a second hand run down on every strike they got, every bite, every landed fish and yes....every throwback too. It is dishonest to say that every fisherman doesn't know how many fish he caught today. He sure knows how many when he's reporting it to his fishing buddies. The argument that it's too much to remember just don't fly with me. Flip over to the fishing reportsd page and read a couple of the long winded reports posted by fishermen here on this site. They detail every strike and missed fish as well. But when the man's looking over your shoulder, it suddenly becomes a burden to do so. I totally understand that and I sympathize with them. The head boat argument is the only one that I understand as the captain has his hands full protecting the crew and putting them on fish. Further burden on his mind is not a good idea, but his crew has a good idea what the over all catch was. They tag each stringer already for each fisherman, not a huge stretch to count the 10-12 fish on each stringer and keep a tally. It's a long ride in after all. No one wants big brother looking over their shoulders, it's basic human psychology. Not saying I told you so or we told you so, but it's no new idea that the regulators would eventually turn their eye towards the private sector. The future is here I guess. I can offer this advice to those who are fighting it, Your arguments against only serve to paint you in a negative light to the ones you fight against, They are masters of taking your perfectly sensable arguments and making you sound like a japanese whaler at the end of the day. It's an uphill struggle and the enemy has deep pockets and seemingly unending patience.

There is no way that I can count every fish on an offshore bottom fishing trip. NO WAY. When I have 6 guys in the back it is all my mate can do to keep up with what is going in the box, let alone undersize, trash, and over limit fish(all throw backs). I understand that discard numbers are important, but if they are guestimates, I can fill it out without even leaving the dock every day. I think we all want better data and getting it with flawed numbers is putting us in the same boat we are in now.



   
ReplyQuote
Bob
 Bob
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 331
 

Sounds like recreational bycatch may be a bigger issue than most thought. If captains are saying there is so much bycatch that it's impossible to keep up with, significant change may be in order. With estimated discard mortality rates as they are, it's beginning to appear that dead discard numbers might be found to be at shocking levels by some of the conservation groups. ๐Ÿ™„
I sure hope the shoe is not moving to the other foot.



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

What does someone's sexual orientation have to do with fishery management?

It doesn't.
Buddyscratch is just gay. :wall:

In before the lock! :lmao:

:lmao:

A blowfish ?



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

I think everyone wants the best data available and a log book could be a step in the right direction especially from the for hire fleet although I don't see how boats like the Continental Shelf could possibly keep track of 100 fares on board and their releases.

BUT....

It is what happens WITH that data that needs to change FIRST.

When SAFMC and DMF use ridiculous assumptions in their computer modeling, it produces ridiculous results so it does not matter what goes in because what comes out is crap

Garbage IN... Garbage OUT

When they use unrealistic release survival rates, this new data will be used to shut down healthy fisheries (again).

When they assume that 90% (or whatever their number is) of all released fish die, those will be used to shorten seasons AGAIN

They need to fix the back end before messing with the front end

I think catch and consume regardless of size is the only possible answer. It is well known the more diverse the size and age structure, the healthier the fish stocks are. Forcing everyone to catch only the bigger fish, focuses all effort on specific year classes and the overall population becomes full of holes. The effects of those holes in the population structure become more apparent in the natural boom and bust cycles of the fish.
Take your limit regardless of size and take it home.

~

Good in theory but impossible to stop people from culling dead fish for the biggest ones to take home

He is greedy by nature. Do you really believe he would bring in small fish that both counted against the quota and he was paid less for less weight? Lots of comm BS in this thread.

Contrary to your misguided belief, markets, restaurants and consumers want pan size fish, not something they have to chop up in a half dozen pieces to have a single serving that fits on a dinner plate.

~



   
ReplyQuote
Wells Barker
(@juice)
Eminent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 30
 

No need to waste time arguing the merits or lack of merits of an electronic fore-hire reporting logbook system in N.C..Any opposition at the Feb.18 NCDMF meeting appears to be a waste of time. Whether you're for the for-hire monitoring or not, the fact that it's already a done deal before the meeting is upsetting. According to NOAA, it's a done deal in N.C. Check out www.safmc.net/sites/default/files/meetings/pdf/Council/12-2014/Data/A2c_ET_ImplementationPlan.pdf page 10. You'll see in this "Plan" that electronic reporting,electronic monitoring, and vessel monitoring systems are on their way to implementation in the South Atlantic.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Sounds like recreational bycatch may be a bigger issue than most thought. If captains are saying there is so much bycatch that it's impossible to keep up with, significant change may be in order. With estimated discard mortality rates as they are, it's beginning to appear that dead discard numbers might be found to be at shocking levels by some of the conservation groups. ๐Ÿ™„
I sure hope the shoe is not moving to the other foot.

:lmao: Thanks!! After all the BS that was enough to bring a smile to everyone!!! :lmao: MFC would love this to get moving as it takes heat off their mess. How many charters to equal 1 gill net of 24 hours? How many years of charters to equal 1 day of trawlers bycatch?



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Contrary to your misguided belief, markets, restaurants and consumers want pan size fish, not something they have to chop up in a half dozen pieces to have a single serving that fits on a dinner plate.

~

So Ken,
I guess you want all comm quotas to be in pounds not numbers of individual fish then? May as well take it from the ocean as the nets will kill it anyway?
If the markets prefer small fish the fish farms are the future!



   
ReplyQuote
David Plowden
(@mealonreels)
Prominent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 652
 

How many charters to equal 1 gill net of 24 hours? How many years of charters to equal 1 day of trawlers bycatch? Wouldn't that answer come from the for hire logs filled out honestly?



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

How many charters to equal 1 gill net of 24 hours? How many years of charters to equal 1 day of trawlers bycatch? Wouldn't that answer come from the for hire logs filled out honestly?

Comms are not required to report bycatch. They do not re[port that kept for themselves, to give to family/friends/, donate to organizations for fish fries. Much more comm bycatch. The dead bycatch from one trawler probably cover 1000 recs catch and bycatch. As the MFC is run by comms one must really wonder what their plan is.... but they are not to be trusted.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 5 / 8
Share: