SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
My current engine breaks all the time, has piss poor fuel efficiency, and barely pushes my heavy hull. Now my fisher price outdrive has bad bellows, bad gimbal bearing, and bad u joint. Enough. Not pouring any more money into this pit. Time to get new engine/outdrive. I need help choosing an engine/outdrive and choosing a rock solid mechanic to do the work.
I currently have a POS Volvo Penta (5L, 270 hp) with XDP outdrive. My boat is heavy for 24' (5900# hull weight, probably pushes 10000# when stream bound) and definitely needs more ponies than what she has now! Boat cruises at 25mph and tops out at 30mph currently. Fuel economy piss poor- 1.3mpg at cruise. I'd like to cruise about 35mph and top out about 45 mph, and get 2 mpg at cruise. Thinking of 6.1 L Mercursier 383 Stroker (350 hp, 390 ft # torque) and Bravo outdrive. Thoughts? Don't think I would have the engine compartment room for a long block 7.4L or 8.1L. I would do diesel if someone knows of a cheap source. The reman Cummins I've found are about 20k, vs 8-10K for a brand new gasser. So looking like gasser...
I also need a good, reputable, and EXPERIENCED mechanic that can handle the scope of the job. Don't want someone who has never done this before, pushing his limits, etc. Boat is in Hampstead and I would prefer someone local, but I'm willing to drive 1-2 hours if needed. For those recommending someone, please let me know if they have specifically done a repower for you or just routine maintenance and repairs.
Thanks in advance for all the help.
Chum, I don't know anything about inboards BUT I plan on fishing every day of June that the weather is good! I'd love to have you aboard so I can learn some of your knowledge....
Sounds like you REALLLLY need a yanmar or other diesel. That would be the way I would put my money. I know it's more upfront but think in the long run you will be more happy and save money. I see it all the time in diesel vs gas engines in vehicles hauling. That much weight puts too much strain on the engine. If your definitely going gas I don't think your going to get any better economy. You'll end up in a bigger engine that sucks just as much if not more gas. I don't have any experience in the marine so this may not be completely correct but I don't see it much different than a vehicle. Good luck with the search and I'm sure it will come out good. Keep everyone posted
Chum,
Sorry to hear it... I know you were hoping for another year or two out of it!
I'd imagine you'll have a tough time getting close to 2 mpg with a gasser...Boat is probably too heavy. I can't offer any advice as I am not at all mechanically inclined..but I am completely happy with my diesels, although currently no where 2 mpg as I hoped, also lost some speed, trying to fiquredthe that out.
Good luck with whatever you decide, and of course your welcome on my boat anytime too!
I'd love to go diesel and have all that torque. I've looked at the Yanmar and Cummins a good bit. The Yanmars put out about 600 ft # torque and the Cummins about 800# ft# torque. That is 50-100% more than the stroker at comparable hp and negligible changes in engine weight (yanmar about the same, cummins about 300# more). I just hate the price tag associated with diesel up front...
I truly believe you'd be so much happier I know the price tag is tough. I just got out of a gas pulling my boat and went diesel and I can't imagine driving anything else. That's nothing compared to boats though. Grouper has a tough time bc he has two beasts to feed. But your boat is pushing the limits of too much for a gasser and be efficient. Hopefully someone can get you a mechanic you can talk with bc I don't know anyone. But they may be able to help better persuade you.
Near shore trip 1/2 day was 2.65 MPG
Offshore running 70+ miles was 1.4. But my 2400 rpm speed has dropped to 24-25 knots... I was getting 28.5 fully loaded and 30+ light in Venice.
Bottom paint/swim platform dragging/ cooler/ice... Gotta fiquredthe that out.
Boat is probably 16k plus loaded. The efficiency difference is speed loss?
Can you ditch the outdrive and go straight inboard? Maybe have a prop pocket added?
I can get ya the name/number of the diesel mechanic that fixed an impeller for me if ya want?? He might be able to tell ya if it's possible.
I'm thinking outdrive is easier. That way I don't have to glass over the big hole in my transom. Also easier for getting in/out of my new slip (shallow at low tide, bump bottom)
Chum,
I would go with a 5.7 Vortec Motor.
Both Bambam and myself have repowered our 24 Albemarles with 5.7 vortec motors. Your boat is probably not as heavy as our 24 Albemarle express. We average 180-215 miles for a days fishing and average 2.5-2.8 mpg for a days trip fully loaded with 4 people with a 60 mile run to the stream and 60 mile ran back.
The key is running the correct pitch prop. I run a stainless c-5 prop and bambam runs an aluminum b-6 prop.
At 3200 rpm I am going 27mph, at 3400 30 mph with a top end of 41 mph at 4400 rpm. Bambam's props are pitched a little higher and probably does 3-4 mph more at the same speed.
I have repowered 2 Albemarle 24 express boats with 5.7 vortec motors and they both perform exactly the same. COULD NOT ASK FOR A BETTER MOTOR.
The 5.7 vortec motor will have a lot more power than the crappy 5.0 motor.
ATP engines in Florida sells a Factory Mercury 5.7 vortec reman motor for around $2100, complete with factory GM oil pan, valve covers, timing cover and harmonic balancer. If your motor has an ecm you will just have to get a new program for the 5.7 motor.
ATP also sells new factory GM 5.7 vortec motors for a couple thousand more. I would get the mercruiser reman and use the savings for other new parts.
You should be able to find a shop to do the swap for around $1000.
At the time you repower you should use new manifolds and risers, a new water pump and a new raw water pump. Install a new starter and alternator, new bilge pumps, new belts and hoses and you will have many trouble free years ahead
Our outdrives have the 1;95 to 1 gearing. Just make sure your drive has the 1;95 to 1 gearing, get the correct pitch props and drop in that 5.7 vortec motor from ATP and you will be happy. No need to break the bank on diesels and other motors when the 5.7 vortec will work well.
If your drive is geared correctly, reseal the drive, change the u-joints, new gimbel bearing and seals, new bellows and you will be on your way.
Chum, I hate to say it but I don't believe 80 additional hp will get you a 10 mph increase in cruise speed. I do believe it will get you to 30 mph with better economy though.
I think you know I repowered my last boat, a 23' w/a. I went from a old, tired 1994 5.7 rated at 235hp but I'm sure was down to around 215-220hp. I went to a vortec 5.7 (carb'd) with 300hp. That 80hp gained me 6mph at cruise (24mph to 30mph). Economy increased from 2.25mpg to 3.4mpg and I was able to go from 15" of pitch to 18".
Now, I'm speaking of best cruise speed/economy. I guess if I ran the new engine at the same speed as the old one I might have gotten the 10mph increase.
Old- 3400/24mph/2.25mpg/15" pitch
new- 3000/30mph/3.4mpg/18" pitch
I just did a prop slip calc and running my new engine at the same speed (3400) would have gotten me a 9mph increase. I was most economical at 3000 and I don't remember what my burn was at 3400.
I know CHUM's boat is a BEAST!!!!!! I think it is bigger than the Albemarle Bambam has...?
Diesel IS the way to go for Power..Efficiency.. Longevity. A under powered motor will be loaded up through the entire power band and will fail prematurely. Not saying a big gas V8 wouldn't work...but BIG V8 and fuel economy don't go hand in hand.
**GrouperSandwich... Check your fuel filters. A clogged filter will cause your slow degradation of speed and economy.
What's that smell? Oh its everyone except gsrol and baytro talking out of their asses about things they know nothing about.
Let me save you some time here I have already done the research for you....
Option 1 (best option imo)
Its simple, go with the 5.7 vortec and one size higher pitch props and fix the normal minor issues you describe on the outdrive. Gimble should be replaced anytime the motor is out anyway. Your probably out 5-7k depending on what mechanic you decide to trust your life to....I prefer to do this stuff myself and can do it for around 2k total with new bolt ons and fixes to your small outdrive issues.
Option 2 (i hate this but see it done quite a bit)
Add a bracket, mount a Yamaha 350 4s, move fuel tank forward to balance boat.
Option 3
Take werewolfs advice. Spend a minimum of 50k on a yanmar repower package with no idea how it will perform since there has probably never been an osprey with this power package in it. Be a pioneer.
Option 4
Take Scotts advice. That ain't even possible so I ain't even going to insert my joke here.....
Option 5
Take weekendhookers advice. While your boat sits broken in the driveway and you mull over werewolfs diesel suggestion, to make yourself feel better about the coin your about to drop on your boat compare its size to the size of a reputable hull like the albe 24 that has been produced unchanged by one of the best builders in the business for over 30 years (and before albemarle was produced by formula and blackfin).
Option 6
Remove motor and drive, drain fuel tank. Sink boat in the ocean. Give me coordinates to wreck. Go buy a nice albe 24 for around 15 - 20k.
Well you have some decisions to make, have fun, and good luck.
Oh and my boat weights 6000# before its gassed and loaded and still gets 2.5-3 mpg with a carbed 5.7. I cruise at 34 on calm seas and top out around 45. We ain't talking 22' lightweight seahunts here. These are heavy boats with steep deadrises made for offshore fishing and if you can burn under 80 gallons on a 14 hour stream trip your doing pretty good.
Why can't bambam quit beatin' around the bush and just tell us what he really thinks. :lmao: :lmao:
I agree with most of his comments. Diesels are great but cost prohibitive. The difference in price will buy a lot of gas. Some boats require diesel for their torque. Chum's boat is a beast but not to the point that diesel is required. The correct gasser will provide good results.
Bracketed outboard, PLEASE, I'm sick of hearing this too. Outboards are not the solve all, end all, to all boat problems.
The only part we (bambam & I) differ is I would go with the larger small block (6.2, 383, whatever with 350hp) and accept the much better results even though they might be slightly less than Chum is hoping for.
As far as rebuilding the plastic drive vs. replacing, I can't speak (type) intelligently about that. If I had been having problem after problem with it and didn't trust it then I would certainly lean towards replacing it with a Bravo 3.
I don't know what those plastic volvos are rated for. Will they handle 350hp reliably? I know my Bravo 1 has only been getting only maintenance since 2003 with no breakdowns. It's rated for up to 400hp and I'm pretty sure Bravo 3's are rated the same.
disclaimer: the beginning of this post contains sarcasm and fun poking at a fellow member. There is no malicious intent. I have recently learned that a higher percentage of the population (than I previously thought) has some symptoms of Aspergers Syndrome and are very literal.
Lighten up Francis :lmao:
I know I can have fun with these guys. Just keeping it light. If I go fishing with one of them and don't return, call the coast guard..........
I think the 6.2 would be a nice choice, however I have no experience with it so I can't make an educated comment on its performance in a boat like chums.