SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

North Carolina's Su...
 
Notifications
Clear all

North Carolina's Surprising Decision To Ignore The Economic Value Of Gamefish

134 Posts
22 Users
0 Reactions
110.5 K Views
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

The comm fishing industry has a lot of highly paid people to lobby so there was no reason to believe the bill would pass. Doubtful if passed there would have been any benefit. There are only 2 ways to cut bycatch waste- either cut total landing weight which no one finds acceptable or eliminate nets in favor of hook & line. Neither of those are going to happen.

:wtg:



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

FishFactory and CoastalCarolina, there is a third way to cut by-catch waste. Use by-catch for food or feed for other food. Seafood is a renewable source of food that should not be wasted. We should make the most efficient use of what can be sustainably harvested. We should be working toward near full retention commercial fisheries with reasonable quotas that are properly managed with appropriate possession limits and by-catch allowances.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

FishFactory and CoastalCarolina, there is a third way to cut by-catch waste. Use by-catch for food or feed for other food. Seafood is a renewable source of food that should not be wasted. We should make the most efficient use of what can be sustainably harvested. We should be working toward near full retention commercial fisheries with reasonable quotas that are properly managed with appropriate possession limits and by-catch allowances.

That would be like putting the fox in the hen house and locking the door. Sure, let them be paid for what they waste. Hook and line would limit the dead. If the comms do not realize it is coming and get involved they may like what the state or feds force on them. More and more are moving to NC from liberal states. If recs and comms do not get the waste factor figured out the liberals will in a manner no one is happy with.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

Chris McCaffity , you could prove beyond any reasonable doubt porgies chit gold nuggets and it wouldn't make any difference, some people are just plain think headed.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

As long as the fox has a limit on how many chickens he could eat, there would always be more. He could eat much more if he only ate half of the chicks and an older hen occasionally while leaving most of the breeders to keep replenishing his food supply. The remaining chicks would grow faster and bigger with less competition. He would need to invite friends over to keep the hen house from being overpopulated and prevent disease from spreading or keep his growing stock from starving as they competed for a limited food supply. Have you ever noticed that in the wild this is the way predators eat? Biologists call it a balance of nature. Government has upset that balance and created waste with Regulatory Discards by reversing God's plan for sustainable stocks. The hen house would be empty as the fox starved to death if he ate nothing but the breeding stock?



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

The common accepted policy of increasing a size limit and the population will improve is simply the wrong answer.

Say a 12" adult fish produces 10,000 eggs
13" fish will produce more maybe 50,000 eggs
14" fish may produce 250,000 eggs
15" fish may produce 1,000,000 eggs

Move the size limit from 14" to 15" and take the 15" fish out of the spawning pool, and it will take 4 - 14" fish to replace the productivity of 1 - 15" fish in the spawning pool.

So, were do those 4 -14" fish come from, they for sure just don't magically appear?

In the shell game you have lost the productivity of all the 15" fish now targeted that we depended upon to produce.

Increasing size limits is the classic shell game with no winners, everyone including the fish looses.

The way we manage red drum is a perfect example of successful fisheries management were the larger spawning fish are protected.

~



   
ReplyQuote
mike gore
(@capt-mpgore)
Eminent Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 34
 

Most people don’t realize that half of the three species in HB-983 that are landed by commercial fishermen and currently enjoyed by consumers would be allocated to dead discards of by-catch. Nobody would benefit from that wasted seafood. We need to limit waste, not pass laws creating more of it.

TimC, you asked BuddyRoe in another thread about high-grading of 12" trout before the size limit was increased to 14". I don't know why he didn’t mention that the 75 fish limit wasn’t in place until after the 2" arbitrary length increase. I told the finfish committee that recommended a 75 fish limit the limit had to be in pounds or recreational fishermen would accuse every Speckled Trout strike-netter of high-grading.

Size limits have been increased over the years to reduce the number of fish taken. The proper way to manage a stock is with quotas and possession limits. As long as appropriate quotas are not exceeded, there will be plenty of fish for everyone. Dr. Conover did a study showing how removing nothing but big breeders from a stock left runts and weak fish to spawn resulting in a greatly reduced average size of fish in that stock. Removing the small fish increased the average size of fish in that stock. I disagree with his idea of requiring fishermen to target small fish while discarding all large ones. The key is to not overharvest the stock period. As long as we have appropriate quotas in place, it should not matter what size the fish are. We should not plan ahead to waste tons of perfectly edible fish because some think it will make it easier for them to catch bigger fish. Big breeders yield many strong spawn that grow up to be big breeders. Runts yield a few more runts.



   
ReplyQuote
QuickFix
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 245
 

If everyone is burned out on the 983 arguments, don't feel obligated to respond to my comments, I'm not begging for more discussion.

I really didn't feel like I had a dog in the fight, but I did read the bill and listen to all of the public opinion expressed in Raleigh.

I just couldn't make the leap from taking the ability of comms to sell their by-catch, to where that would create some economic boom for the recreational fishing industry.

I'm not saying that it isn't possible, but I never heard any evidence to support that case. Did I just miss that evidence? (evidence, not just opinions from fishermen in other states)

I agree - the economics of this bill are total fabrication and deception! This was not about economics nor about fisheries management for the health of the stocks!

Absurd to think that people will flock to NC to live here for the fishing! Here is a little data for you to refute and ponder:

2011 Striped Bass = 350% increase

Striped bass jumped from the No. 4 slot in 2010 to No. 2 last year. Anglers caught 2 million pounds of striped bass in 2011, up 350 percent from 2010.

A full landings report can be found on the division website at http://portal.ncdenr.org/c/document_...&groupId=38337.

Cheryl Gilgo

Public Affairs Assistant IV

Division of Marine Fisheries

252-808-8137

So without gamefish status recreational striped bass landings jumped 350% How could that be possible?

Anyone with any links to the windfall created by such a turn of events? How many jobs did this create? How many people from other states came to throw some cash around and what was the increase in revenue to the tackle shop owners, restaurants, hotels, gas stations and most importantly the tax coffers of NC?

I sure hope those in Raleigh intrusted to look after the best interest of all of us spend the windfall wisely

How many packed up all there belongings and moved to NC for the striped bass fishing and could you list what counties had the largest increase in new residents from out of state? Certainly they would be at the coast somewhere!\

And what about the trout windfall from 2012? - The number of spotted seatrout landed in 2012 was 131 percent higher than in 2011! Where did all of the money and jobs go that should have been directly attributable to such an event?

Additionally, the number of red drum releases hit 1.5 million in 2012, three times higher than the highest ever seen in North Carolina. Again, follow the cash windfall! Trouble is it does not exist! Just ask all of the charter guys and tackle shop owners and motels and etc.

Certainly someone can post irrefutable hard economic data directly attributed to the increase in recreational landings of these species! After all that was the whole premise behind this bill!

So post up!

Still waiting! - where is the data on the economic value of Gamefish?



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Still waiting! - where is the data on the economic value of Gamefish?

You will wait forever on an answer based on fact on that question. Just as long as waiting on stopping nets and going to hook and line to show comms really care about the resource.



   
ReplyQuote
George Golinski
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1371
 

I don't believe this bill had all that much support among the recreational sector either. I for one did not support it because these are viable fisheries and I believe they should remain open to everyone. Should the time come when additional cuts are required to maintain the health of the species or the ecosystem, then they should be instituted equally across all sectors.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth Seigler
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 1001
 

I don't believe this bill had all that much support among the recreational sector either. I for one did not support it because these are viable fisheries and I believe they should remain open to everyone. Should the time come when additional cuts are required to maintain the health of the species or the ecosystem, then they should be instituted equally across all sectors.

Capt. Dave you have got to get a LIKE button.



   
ReplyQuote
john Smith
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1776
 

FishFactory and CoastalCarolina, there is a third way to cut by-catch waste. Use by-catch for food or feed for other food. Seafood is a renewable source of food that should not be wasted. We should make the most efficient use of what can be sustainably harvested. We should be working toward near full retention commercial fisheries with reasonable quotas that are properly managed with appropriate possession limits and by-catch allowances.

There is no so-called "by catch",
hook and line.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=Q_qqqE8GiCA

Video posted by ECS....best I can tell, netter doesn't give a damn
about crabs or fish "by-catch" mixed with his handful of shrimp.

Won't even bother to toss suffocating fish overboard...this has been the
mentality since at least the 70's



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
 

The common accepted policy of increasing a size limit and the population will improve is simply the wrong answer.

Say a 12" adult fish produces 10,000 eggs
13" fish will produce more maybe 50,000 eggs
14" fish may produce 250,000 eggs
15" fish may produce 1,000,000 eggs

Move the size limit from 14" to 15" and take the 15" fish out of the spawning pool, and it will take 4 - 14" fish to replace the productivity of 1 - 15" fish in the spawning pool.

So, were do those 4 -14" fish come from, they for sure just don't magically appear?

In the shell game you have lost the productivity of all the 15" fish now targeted that we depended upon to produce.

Increasing size limits is the classic shell game with no winners, everyone including the fish looses.

The way we manage red drum is a perfect example of successful fisheries management were the larger spawning fish are protected.

~

Or allow small fish to grow by using size specific gear(gillnets) to harvest a limited amount of larger fish. No one in their right mind would suggest killing ALL of the larger fish.

What species of fish brings a higher $$$$ per pound for smaller fish?

If large flounders average 2.5 pound(probably higher than that at times) are $4 per pound. Mediums average 1.5 pounds and $3 per pound, here's what it looks like economically for 100 pounds

40 large fish = $400
66 medium fish = $300

Which looks like a wiser use of the resource? Keep in mind that with mesh size restrictions, there are VERY FEW small flounder discarded in the flounder gillnet fishery.

The same can be applied to every fishery that targets finfish with gillnets because they for the most part are size specific.



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
 

FishFactory and CoastalCarolina, there is a third way to cut by-catch waste. Use by-catch for food or feed for other food. Seafood is a renewable source of food that should not be wasted. We should make the most efficient use of what can be sustainably harvested. We should be working toward near full retention commercial fisheries with reasonable quotas that are properly managed with appropriate possession limits and by-catch allowances.

There is no so-called "by catch",
hook and line. Gigging is the ONLY fishing method(rec or comm) with no bycatch.



   
ReplyQuote
QuickFix
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 245
 

FishFactory and CoastalCarolina, there is a third way to cut by-catch waste. Use by-catch for food or feed for other food. Seafood is a renewable source of food that should not be wasted. We should make the most efficient use of what can be sustainably harvested. We should be working toward near full retention commercial fisheries with reasonable quotas that are properly managed with appropriate possession limits and by-catch allowances.

There is no so-called "by catch",
hook and line. Gigging is the ONLY fishing method(rec or comm) with no bycatch.

well actually you can harvest with spears and by hand(com & rec) with no bycatch, as long as you have good eyesight and the appropriate skill set! :hail:



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 9
Share: