SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Not happy with Shim...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Not happy with Shimano Warranties

16 Posts
14 Users
0 Reactions
41 K Views
ReelSharp
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 544
Topic starter   [#40668]

So I went into the tackle shop today to change out a rod with a lifetime warranty that broke while offshore this weekend. When I had other Shimano rods that broke while fishing, it was brought in and changed out right there for free. Not anymore. Now it has to be shipped back to them at owners expense and wait 3 weeks. No thanks. So I buy a rod with a lifetime warranty and now I am out of a rod and money? I will not buy anymore rods from them and only buy rods with warranties that if it breaks, I get a new one. I am here to fish, not wait for a new rod in the mail. I will start to buy more Star Rods and Fenwicks if that's what it takes to get me fishing asap. Anyways, I just wanted to spread the word if not so many knew. I know this is why many people buy these rods. I spend the extra up front so I do not have to deal with IF I have to exchange. I hope other companies do not follow suit, they will lose my business too. So don't get duped on your next purchase.



   
Quote
Wes Livingston
(@wes)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 968
 

Thanks for the heads up. The return policy definitely played a part in my Shimano purchases.



   
ReplyQuote
Rob Nipper
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 160
 

Had the same problem with a St. Croix a little over 5 years ago.. Broke while casting the 3rd time I used it. Obviously a rare defect or a handling issue before I got it. Tackle shop guys didnt seem to care. Too busy basking in their own knowledge and excellence I can't help to think the tackle shop could have been more helpful if they wanted to. At the time, I chose the rod based off their recommendation. Not mentioning the store on this forum.



   
ReplyQuote
John Gann
(@ab1620)
Honorable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 616
 

Shimano changed the Rod warranty in June I believe. It is BS. Not to mention the reel warranty has been that way for a while now. From now on I will be buying Daiwa.



   
ReplyQuote
Dave Keith
(@wilmingtondk)
Trusted Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 46
 

I went through the same situation and have had issues with Star rods as well.
Thats why I now buy all my rods from Kevin Knox at Anglers Envy. Superior construction to any rods I have bought off the shelf and every rods he makes carries a lifetime warranty..

www.anglersenvy.com



   
ReplyQuote
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 1942
 

Did they change their warranty due to folks taking advantage of a good thing?

Limited Lifetime Warranty Rods
Effective August 1, 2014 the warranty on all Shimano rods is changing to a Limited One Year warranty. Please note that we will honor the limited lifetime warranty on all rods purchased prior to August 1, 2014.
To make a claim on a Shimano rod that was purchased with a limited lifetime warranty, please send your rod postage prepaid to Shimano. To request a warranty claim in Canada, send your rod postage prepaid to Shimano Canada Ltd. / LTÉE. All warranty requests must be accompanied by a valid dated sales receipt and a note describing the difficulty you are experiencing with the rod in as much detail as possible.
Rods sold prior to August 1, 2014 with a limited lifetime warranty are:
ATL, CL "A" Series, CLC/CLS, CNC/CNS, CPC/CPS "A" & "B" Series, CRC/CRS, CSC/CSS, CUC/CUS, CVC/CVS, IGFA, PCF,
SFS, TDR w/2 digit numbered models, TEC/TES, TFC/TFS, TLA, TLC/ TLS/ULC, TLI/TLR/TLT, TMC/TMS, TRC/TRS, TSC/TSS, TVC/TVS, TZC/TZS, ULC, V-RODS, VTS/VTC
THIS LIMITED LIFETIME WARRANTY ONLY COVERS DAMAGE TO THE ROD RESULTING FROM A NON-CONFORMITY IN MATERIAL OR WORKMANSHIP; ANY DAMAGE CAUSED BY MISUSE, ABUSE OR TAMPERING WITH THE ROD BY OTHER THAN NORMAL USE OF THE ROD; OR ANY NON-CONFORMITY OR DAMAGE RESULTING FROM REPAIRS PERFORMED OTHER THAN BY SHIMANO OR AN AUTHORIZED SHIMANO SERVICE PROVIDER IS NOT COVERED.



   
ReplyQuote
William McCann
(@werewolf0711)
Famed Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 3133
 

Shimano did change this. I'm sure there were a plenty taking advantage of it. I see all rod manufacters eventually following suite. Now to be honest I'm sure shimano is making a killing selling their rods at the prices they do compared to what it cost them to make them.

I have moved away from buying store bought when I was introduced to John Ballard with JB Custom rods. He puts in quality in all his work. And he's located her in NC, Dunn to be exact. He carries a lifetime warranty as well but not on stupidity.

Examples: high sticking a trout rod that has an extra limber tip and it breaks, owners fault. Overpowering a blank with too much drag designed for that blank, owners fault.

Those types of things people think it's the rods fault for not holding up and I'm sure all rod companies are getting tired of the rods being returned due to these instances.



   
ReplyQuote
Jim
 Jim
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 960
 

I too love and bought 6-7 travela and compre rods over time. I was willing to pay the extra money because of the warranty. I hope they change their policy back after their sales drop off. They are still excellent rods.



   
ReplyQuote
James
(@ncstatefisher)
Reputable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 238
 

too many people abusing the system i can't say that i blame them.. people breaking their rods on purpose after getting cosmetic wear and tear for a while. hell the only ones that break on a regular basis are trevalas and terez jiggers and thats 99% user error, I don't have a problem with it



   
ReplyQuote
Rob Nipper
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 160
 

Had the same problem with a St. Croix a little over 5 years ago.. Broke while casting the 3rd time I used it. Obviously a rare defect or a handling issue before I got it. Tackle shop guys didnt seem to care. Too busy basking in their own knowledge and excellence I can't help to think the tackle shop could have been more helpful if they wanted to. At the time, I chose the rod based off their recommendation. Not mentioning the store on this forum.



   
ReplyQuote
DAVID DICK
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 154
 

I went through the same situation and have had issues with Star rods as well.
Thats why I now buy all my rods from Kevin Knox at Anglers Envy. Superior construction to any rods I have bought off the shelf and every rods he makes carries a lifetime warranty..

www.anglersenvy.com

Kevin is top notch!



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Fenwick and others. Last year I broke a 9' Fenwick rod on the 5th cast. Put it in the corner and saw I had 3 others that were in the same shape. One was of a brand I do not recall ~~ they asked to email photos of the break and a copy of the receipt for farther instructions. Instructions came as "send mailing address" and a new rod arrived ~ no charge. Penn was easy ~ send us the rod and your contact info. An email was received asking to call and I called. The rod returned was no longer made and to pick anything like it or lesser to be shipped to me at no charge. Easy! Next were 2 owned by Pure Fishing and instructions were sent by Ugly Stick and Fenwick. Sent both back and within 14 days the Ugly Stick replacement was delivered. Another week went by and an email was sent on the Fenwick asking about the status. In a minute the info was on their computer and was told the warranty was approved but they required $9.95 for S&H. Fenwick was the most expensive to purchase and only one that required a payment. I have sent a reel back to Penn and it too was no longer made. Quickly replaced with the new replacement model. Reel went from one liked to one made in China that I gave to a neighbor boy. No complaint as they did what they were supposed to.
Every time anything has been sent for warranty the results have been good. I never take anything back to a tackle shop as they must hold until their rep comes and still may have to wait. paying return shipping is usually minimal. The 9' Fenwick was inexpensive as they only wanted both of the break ~~ about 6". I might return more than most as I keep at a minimum 7 trolling rods, 8 medium spinning, 8 medium heavy spinning, 2 for bait rigs, and a few spares ready to go. I take many children and newbies that do not own equipment and breakage may be a little higher based on that and I fish all year.



   
ReplyQuote
NCSUEngineer
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 64
 

I went through the same situation and have had issues with Star rods as well.
Thats why I now buy all my rods from Kevin Knox at Anglers Envy. Superior construction to any rods I have bought off the shelf and every rods he makes carries a lifetime warranty..

www.anglersenvy.com

Kevin is top notch!

x3 for Kevin Knox of AE, he is a top notch guy and rod builder. I have a AE Sniper Planer rod 80W class which is very well constructed and a proven fish catcher. I plan to have an additional six 50W class trolling rods and a spiral wrapped conventional jigging rod for a Shimano Trinidad 16A reel by Summer 2015 as I know these rods will end up being proven fish catchers as well that will last a lifetime.

I have also had warranty success as well with broken Star Aerial rods of which I own two as well as the Star Plasma I have mated up to my Shimano Stella SW10000PG has a lifetime warranty as well, for now...



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

A commercial fisherman told me the Black Hole Cape Cod Special Custom is a beast for grouper. I have yet to try one but can't wait; especially since I will now be out of the Shimano market.



   
ReplyQuote
ReelSharp
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 544
Topic starter  

What are Angler Envy prices ranging?



   
ReplyQuote
Page 1 / 2
Share: