SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
How am I banging the eco-charity/SAFMC drum?
Circle hooks work well for fish like grouper. They suck for fish like triggers.
Have you asked the council to reduce the 40% discard mortality rate for gags after circle hooks were required? If so, do you think it might help if hundreds of us asked and pointed out the advances in technology that many fishermen are using to greatly reduce discard mortality rates?
I've asked them to do a study about this 40%
discard rate or show me how they came up with it.
I've also volunteered to tag Gag grouper several times.
And all these guys had excuses.(About the tags)
I asked Chip Collier for tags a while back.
Asked Brian Pearson for tags last year.
Asked Tom Burgess for tags 3 or 4 years ago.
And asked the Noaa research guy Scott
Van Sant for tags this year also. All these guys missed the bus.
If any of them would have given me 1000 tags, 1000 gags would have tags in them now.
Do you think it might help if hundreds of us asked the council to look at discard mortality rates while pointing out that many fishermen are using decent assist devices to greatly increase the survival rates of released illegal fish suffering from barotrauma?
Please do not confuse my understanding of how the fishery management process works and willingness to have discussions or offer solutions with supporting the IUCN/NOAA/eco-charity agenda.
Chris, Here is part of the problem.
The Data that has been collected in years past gets outdated
or doesn't apply to the current fishing pressure.
When we make improvements to our fishing practices,
like circle hooks, they are very reluctant to give us any credit for it.
The scientific group/person that is reporting these findings of
discards of undersized fish is reporting it on worse case scenario
that favors the resource and ignores reasonable scientific logic.
I'll give you a for instance. This 30,000lbs removed from the gag quota to keep reds and scamps open. I'd bet they figured that with out recreational retention or re adjusting the discards from the original quota discard. Also they have the data to make us use circle hooks because it decreases discard mortality, but they haven't adjusted the discard mortality rate based on the use of circle hooks. That defies reasonable, rational science.
We need someone that understands what they are doing, can
point out their mistakes and get the fishermen a fair shake.
We need to hold these/this so called scientific group/person accountable for their actions and might need to find some experts that can convert this data into fair un bias terms.
RoughandReady, the man you speak of IS John Carmichael. I will set a lunch meeting with John during the December SAFMC meeting if you would like to talk with him. As for that 27,218 pounds of commercial gag quota that was taken away for Post Season Discard Mortality, would you support using that for a 50 pound by-catch allowance after the primary quota is filled? The gag quota will likely be filled by the end of this month if the entire fishery is not closed any day now because data is not being collected and could result in overfishing.
Honestly I wouldn't support any decisions on the gag groupers until the stock assessment is done. And I think it was very un- ethical to push that 27,218 before it was done. I saw were that was mentioned on Facebook along with the other stuff.
Feel free to ask Selby Lewis or David Plowden how they feel
about the gag size limit it will give you more input.
Ask them what they think about this so called 40% that die when they return them to the ocean. I also have more verbal information about that, but can't post it yet, till I verify it.
RoughandReady, that 27,218 pounds has nothing to do with size limits. The council already allocated 81,000 pounds of quota to real and perceived dead discards of undersized fish. I told you I AGREE the discard mortality rate is less than 40%. John Carmichael does the SAFMC stock assessments. He is the man we need to talk with about getting that 40% mortality rate reduced based on the use of circle hooks, decent assist devices, and the reality that most undersized fish are caught in less than 15 fathoms. Would you and the other fishermen you have been talking about me to be willing to have a meeting to discuss these issues? I would like to be able to share my side of the story with them. I want them to know that I am willing to go along with the 24" size limit on gags if fishermen will agree to use decent assist devices on illegal fish suffering from barotrauma. The fact is that it would be better for the fish while providing better data for stock assessments if we just kept what we caught until the possession limit was met and counted everything landed against the considerably higher quotas. This would leave more big breeders to replenish the stock with strong spawn. Size limits and quotas work against each other. It is far better to pick one or the other. That being said, let me repeat that I can live with the 24" size limit on gags IF fishermen will do what it takes to reduce the 40% discard mortality rate that is currently being used to waste tons of seafood.
Doing stock assessments from behind a desk miles from the coast~~~ little to no input from those on the water~~~ surely the numbers are right on!
They haven't done a stock assessment since 2006, The new data has been collected and ready for there findings.
And from what I've seen and been told it should show an increase for us. As far as the dead discards go that problem with
40% being used, Carmicheal needs to re-evaluate that %
and get it to a reasonable level. If he feels 40% is reasonable
I think a meeting with him should happen with a panel of gag grouper fishermen to discuss this issue.
Chris I have talked to several "Gag Grouper" fishermen
both commercial & recreational and nobody that I have talked to
can possible believe that 40% of the throw backs die.
With the growth of the stock since the early 90's
It is utterly impossible! If brought down to a reasonable %
this could have a positive impact on both recreational & commercial gag fishermen alike.
I have been commercial gag fishing out of Beaufort,N.C. for many years. I have expressed to the Council thru written comments that the 40% death rate of throw back gags is WAY TOO HIGH. I also relayed to them an actual real life experience regarding a gag survival. A few years back I was fishing a rock in 85-90 ft. of water in August. I caught a severely deformed grouper. His tail was attached at the end of his body but right after his anus. Even though he had plenty of weight he was too short to legally keep so I released him. A few weeks later I caught the exact same grouper at the exact same rock again. I released him again. The next year I caught him again at a rock 1.5 miles from the original catch site. He had grown to a harvestable length so I kept him. If you believe the 40% death rate crock, the chances of his survival should have been extremely low. From my experience with the fishery management process over the years, what the fisherman experiences on the water, and relays to the "powers that be", is ignored in the collection of "best available science" used in their decision making process.
Does anyone believe the bureaucrat behind a desk that could not identify a gag knows less than the guy on the water? Time for the military to take over and go back to the Constitution and have new elections. without liberal candidates for 20 years.
Doing stock assessments from behind a desk miles from the coast~~~ little to no input from those on the water~~~ surely the numbers are right on!
That's my whole point, especially for deep water groundfish. Fisheries scientists have models though....... which are completely worthless because so much is lacking that we could write a book. I can appreciate the mortality argument and agree that 40% in a shallow water fishery is absurdly high. But what is more ridiculous is we were already getting screwed on the total weight alotted which is then compounded by bogus mortality numbers. See, people on the water can tell anyone that the fish are there but desk jockies can't really tell you anything about the presence or absence of fish, only what they are fed or believe to be true. When Joe offers to more than one fisheries person to tag groupers and he has no takers it simply let's me know that fisheries people don't really want to know because once you really know it is harder to blindly push agendas and arbitrarily screw fisherman.
I never said or believed that the discard mortality rate for shallow water gags has ever been 40%. Gags caught in deeper water and suffering from barotrauma may have a 40% mortality rate if they are not released using assist decent devices. Fortunately, very few undersized gags are caught in deeper water. I did not set the 40% mortality rate and am actively trying to get it reduced.
I will set up a meeting with John to discuss discard mortality and some other issues during the SAFMC meeting this December in Wilmington. Let me know if you are interested in attending.
Is anyone interested in reducing regulatory discards of Gag Grouper by using most of the 27,218 pounds gag quota that is being allocated to post closure discard mortality for a 50 pound bycatch allowance after the primary quota is filled? This year's season is likely to be over before the end of this month. This common sense solution would limit waste while collecting better data for more accurate stock assessments.
Chris that's your problem, your buying into there plan &
your not looking at the overall picture which is a healthy
Ecosystem. The only way to do that is to take everything into consideration and not take SAFMC's, EDF/Pew management
plan as the gospel. Some species are caught together on a higher frequency then others and some are not. Size limits
work much better in shallow water then deeper water &
that problem needs to be addressed, But In no way should
it hurt the progress we have made in the last 20+ years on our shallow water reefs. And new research is needed to get a more realistic poundage on dead discards. They forced us to use circle hooks to help with dead discards and had this so called science to back it up, But why haven't they changed the dead discard amount? You know why? Its not there job to be fair to fishermen,
But its becoming the fishermen's job to make sure they don't take advantage of us. It would be nice to see you on the fishermen's side instead of banging their drum.
"We the people are the rightful masters of both Congress and the courts, not to overthrow the Constitution but to overthrow the men who pervert the Constitution."
– Abraham Lincoln