SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Ruffin McNiell fire...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Ruffin McNiell fired?! Why?

49 Posts
24 Users
0 Reactions
132.1 K Views
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

Anyone give any thought to what went on behind the scenes when Ruff didn't sign his contract extension a few months ago?

Looks like they low balled him on his assistants and reneged on a promise in his previous contract.

http://www.underdogdynasty.com/2015/12/7/9869114/ruffin-mcneill-was-offered-a-contract-extension-by-ecu-but-turned-it

Yeah but what that article don't tell you is that was for bonus money. FWIW, The lowest paid asst coach made $110,000. YES I agree - Ruff got a raw deal but I will still continue to support the Pirates. Unlike many who apparently signed a petition to boycott unless Ruff was hired back.

Which is on the low end for assistant coaches in FBS, and contrary to his last contract. The names I'm hearing they are considering for the job like Chizik and Shane Beamer are freaking awful. If you don't have a better coach already lined up it is really stupid to fire your successful coach.



   
ReplyQuote
brian apple
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 352
Topic starter  

Anyone give any thought to what went on behind the scenes when Ruff didn't sign his contract extension a few months ago?

Looks like they low balled him on his assistants and reneged on a promise in his previous contract.

http://www.underdogdynasty.com/2015/12/7/9869114/ruffin-mcneill-was-offered-a-contract-extension-by-ecu-but-turned-it

Yeah but what that article don't tell you is that was for bonus money. FWIW, The lowest paid asst coach made $110,000. YES I agree - Ruff got a raw deal but I will still continue to support the Pirates. Unlike many who apparently signed a petition to boycott unless Ruff was hired back.

Which is on the low end for assistant coaches in FBS, and contrary to his last contract. The names I'm hearing they are considering for the job like Chizik and Shane Beamer are freaking awful. If you don't have a better coach already lined up it is really stupid to fire your successful coach.

Chizik awful? He is four years removed from a National Championship as HC. One of the best DC's period in college football. I think that would be a great hire.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

Anyone give any thought to what went on behind the scenes when Ruff didn't sign his contract extension a few months ago?

Looks like they low balled him on his assistants and reneged on a promise in his previous contract.

http://www.underdogdynasty.com/2015/12/7/9869114/ruffin-mcneill-was-offered-a-contract-extension-by-ecu-but-turned-it

Yeah but what that article don't tell you is that was for bonus money. FWIW, The lowest paid asst coach made $110,000. YES I agree - Ruff got a raw deal but I will still continue to support the Pirates. Unlike many who apparently signed a petition to boycott unless Ruff was hired back.

Which is on the low end for assistant coaches in FBS, and contrary to his last contract. The names I'm hearing they are considering for the job like Chizik and Shane Beamer are freaking awful. If you don't have a better coach already lined up it is really stupid to fire your successful coach.

Chizik awful? He is four years removed from a National Championship as HC. One of the best DC's period in college football. I think that would be a great hire.

Hahahahahahahahahaha. That was Cam and Malzahn's championship. Chizik has sucked every other year as a HC, that's why he got fired so shortly after winning a MNC. One of the best DCs in CFB? Please. UNC had nowhere to go but up.

The other name I heard was Everett Withers, which, damn, that's the worst yet.



   
ReplyQuote
brian apple
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 352
Topic starter  

Hahahahahahahahahaha. That was Cam and Malzahn's championship. Chizik has sucked every other year as a HC, that's why he got fired so shortly after winning a MNC. One of the best DCs in CFB? Please. UNC had nowhere to go but up.

The other name I heard was Everett Withers, which, damn, that's the worst yet.

Chizik was 2004 Broyles award winner. The OTHER 1500 assistant coaches in college football voted him the best assistant in the country, not me.

He also won a national Championship as DC for Texas.

I can pull up the stats starting at every school he has been the DC from the time at UCF to UNC before and after he left. Its all there in black and white. He is one of the best DC's in college football.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

Hahahahahahahahahaha. That was Cam and Malzahn's championship. Chizik has sucked every other year as a HC, that's why he got fired so shortly after winning a MNC. One of the best DCs in CFB? Please. UNC had nowhere to go but up.

The other name I heard was Everett Withers, which, damn, that's the worst yet.

Chizik was 2004 Broyles award winner. The OTHER 1500 assistant coaches in college football voted him the best assistant in the country, not me.

He also won a national Championship as DC for Texas.

I can pull up the stats starting at every school he has been the DC from the time at UCF to UNC before and after he left. Its all there in black and white. He is one of the best DC's in college football.

Okay. Those awards are pretty useless, I still don't put him at the same level as Chavis, Venables, Durkin (just got a HC job) and Pruitt so I guess it depends on how many guys you want on your list of "best". Still doesn't make him not suck as a HC. He's 38-38 and if you disregard 2014 (which is credible to do because of Cam and Malzahn) its even worse. Some guys are better off as assistants. If ECU hires any of those guys it will be a downgrade.



   
ReplyQuote
brian apple
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 352
Topic starter  

Hahahahahahahahahaha. That was Cam and Malzahn's championship. Chizik has sucked every other year as a HC, that's why he got fired so shortly after winning a MNC. One of the best DCs in CFB? Please. UNC had nowhere to go but up.

The other name I heard was Everett Withers, which, damn, that's the worst yet.

Chizik was 2004 Broyles award winner. The OTHER 1500 assistant coaches in college football voted him the best assistant in the country, not me.

He also won a national Championship as DC for Texas.

I can pull up the stats starting at every school he has been the DC from the time at UCF to UNC before and after he left. Its all there in black and white. He is one of the best DC's in college football.

Okay. Those awards are pretty useless, I still don't put him at the same level as Chavis, Venables, Durkin (just got a HC job) and Pruitt so I guess it depends on how many guys you want on your list of "best". Still doesn't make him not suck as a HC. He's 38-38 and if you disregard 2014 (which is credible to do because of Cam and Malzahn) its even worse. Some guys are better off as assistants. If ECU hires any of those guys it will be a downgrade.

Just consider this though,.....who was the last HC hired at ANY North Carolina school that had a National Champioship ring as HC BEFORE they were hired here.....?



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

I mean nobody gives him much credit for the MNC though, it is not much different than hiring a GA who has one.

Rings don't mean jack.



   
ReplyQuote
brian apple
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 352
Topic starter  

I mean nobody gives him much credit for the MNC though, it is not much different than hiring a GA who has one.

Rings don't mean jack.

Hmmm......



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

I'm serious. Chips mean very little when evaluating a coach. Overall record and consistent success is a much better indicator.

Anybody think Chizik is a better coach than Art Briles or Mark Dantonio or Jim Harbough? None of those guys have chips but are leaps and bounds better coaches.



   
ReplyQuote
brian apple
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 352
Topic starter  

I'm serious. Chips mean very little when evaluating a coach. Overall record and consistent success is a much better indicator.

Anybody think Chizik is a better coach than Art Briles or Mark Dantonio or Jim Harbough? None of those guys have chips but are leaps and bounds better coaches.

Look, I get SOME of where you are going with this.

But none of those three coaches is interviewing for the ECU job, ECU isn't getting ANY of those guys right now. For that matter they'd be lucky if the coaches agent even took the time to call back and politely say he is not interested. Nick Saban and Urban Meyer ain't comin either.

Look I'm still disappointed they fired Ruff. He was a great fit for a School without many great fits. But Gene Chizik is not a bad a hire. ECU could do much worse than that.

But who do you think they should hire? I mean a coach they can get, and don't say Riley because he clearly has no interest by all reports so far.

Who?



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

I think they should have never fired Ruffin. All coaches I have seen mentioned so far would be a downgrade. The only way to have a chance at an upgrade would be to take a chance at an O Coordinator. Sonny Cumbie, Rhett Lashlee, somebody like that.

You keep trying to say Chizik is a good HC. He is demonstrably not. He is a bad HC. Apparently it is down to either Everett Withers or Brady Hoke now anyway so it is a moot point.



   
ReplyQuote
Motivator
(@motivator)
Estimable Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 132
 

No dog in the fight, just sharing information from ESPN:

GREENVILLE, N.C. -- East Carolina hired Duke offensive coordinator Scottie Montgomery as its head coach, athletic director Jeff Compher announced Sunday night.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

Yeah I saw that.

Duke fans are not upset about him leaving and it apparently came about as a result of Cutcliffe recommending him, if that tells you anything. Hey fellow in state FBS program, have I got the guy for you!



   
ReplyQuote
Ed
 Ed
(@aftergolf)
Famed Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 2170
 

Heard Ruff was hired at UVA as Assistant Head Coach.



   
ReplyQuote
Jamie Blue
(@)
Famed Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 3660
 

Heard Ruff was hired at UVA as Assistant Head Coach.

Yup. Good for him. UVa gonna be a problem in the next years.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 3 / 4
Share: