SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

SAFMC ignores fishe...
 
Notifications
Clear all

SAFMC ignores fishermen once again. Are Catch Shares on the table?

50 Posts
15 Users
0 Reactions
85.1 K Views
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

I believe there is a section in the suit that specifically addresses the cessation of rec. fishing until an ITP is granted (I'm not taking a side, just want the facts straight). Pretty sure I read that and I can go find it if necessary. Maybe that is why recs. can't get behind the current commercial fight against Catch Shares, or maybe they are oblivious to what is happening, or don't care bc it appears to be someone else's problem.

You are correct. There is a part of the lawsuit that shuts rec fishing down. Comms see 800,000 recs and want them to contribute and pay for the observers comms are required to have as they cannot be trusted to be honest. No rec is in favor of catch shares and such retardation would effect recs at some point. Sadly, catch shares will effect the entire coast and sadly the lawsuit will effect recs along the entire coast also just so the greed continues.



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

I believe there is a section in the suit that specifically addresses the cessation of rec. fishing until an ITP is granted (I'm not taking a side, just want the facts straight). Pretty sure I read that and I can go find it if necessary. Maybe that is why recs. can't get behind the current commercial fight against Catch Shares, or maybe they are oblivious to what is happening, or don't care bc it appears to be someone else's problem.

You are correct. There is a part of the lawsuit that shuts rec fishing down. Comms see 800,000 recs and want them to contribute and pay for the observers comms are required to have as they cannot be trusted to be honest. No rec is in favor of catch shares and such retardation would effect recs at some point. Sadly, catch shares will effect the entire coast and sadly the lawsuit will effect recs along the entire coast also just so the greed continues.

Do you not think that recs break the laws? You throw all the comms into one bucket of law breakers and then all recs as opposing catch shares. CCA was at one time a huge proponent of catch shares. Their letter stating such is on this site somewhere. They thought they could buy the shares and use them to increase their membership level, but then when they found out they would be open to bidding, they backed away. Might not have been CCA in NC but it was CCA somewhere. I'll see if I can find that letter and repost it.

I'd like to see someone do the research that shows how many tickets were written to recs and comms over a period of time in NC. This notion that all comms "cannot be trusted" is pure bovine fecal matter. I'd be willing to make a wager that more recs break the laws than comms or should I say more recs are ticketed for breaking the laws than comms but purely a guess at this point



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

Might not have been CCA in NC but it was CCA somewhere.

CCANC was included. As I remember CCA as an organization in its entirety was a proponent of Catch Shares until they discovered Catch Shares would prove problematic for the organization. I bashed CCA severals times on FPT for getting their hands caught in the Catch Share cookie jar.



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

CCA Positon Paper suggesting that red snapper catch shares for recs could be sold in bundles:

http://www.gulfcouncil.org/Beta/GMFMCWeb/downloads/BB%202009-08/B%20-%206%20Is%20There%20a%20Better%20Way%20to%20Manage%20US%20Shared%20Commercial%20&%20Recreational%20Fisheries.pdf

And from an RFA release where CCA Jeff Angers is quoted:
"By comparison, CCC's Jeff Angers, head fisheries lobbyist for ASA, CCA, IGFA, TBF and NMMA told Congressional leaders that his groups would support a program where state-established entities could purchase quota on behalf of their citizens. "States have a long history of fishery management and, on the whole, a trusted relationship with recreational anglers," Angers told the Congressional committee, adding "providing them with the ability to purchase quota on behalf of their angling public will help to maintain public access to a public resource, while promoting sound fisheries conservation."

Found this too, look at who was working together on sector separation and inter sector trading of catch shares..

http://www.nmma.org/lib/docs/nmma/gr/policy/Fish_Collaborative_Letter_on_Reallocation_in_the_Catch_Shares_Policy.pdf



   
ReplyQuote
Joe Hifko
(@roughandready)
Famed Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 2882
Topic starter  

I went Blue fin tuna fishing with a friend who needed my gps today & Am going
to Tag & Release Gag Groupers for NCDMF Wednesday.
SAFMC is taking public comments Thursday, I'm going to try and make it.
Wednesday is a Q & A with Hartig & Crabtree ( Would be a good time to ask them why we are being ignored)

link



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Do you not think that recs break the laws? You throw all the comms into one bucket of law breakers and then all recs as opposing catch shares.

I'd like to see someone do the research that shows how many tickets were written to recs and comms over a period of time in NC. This notion that all comms "cannot be trusted" is pure bovine fecal matter. I'd be willing to make a wager that more recs break the laws than comms or should I say more recs are ticketed for breaking the laws than comms but purely a guess at this point

NO~~~ I do not throw all comms in the same bucket and have said here many times the problems are with a minority. A silent minority for sure. I'll bet you are correct that more recs are ticketed than comms as there are 1250 times more of them. I'd also bet those were honest mistakes more so than on the comm side where it is just a cost of doing business for some. Good luck with numbers as I have asked several times and places how many, if any recs and comms have lost their license for more than a year in the last decade. No one seems to have that information. I still trust CCANC and NOAA much more than NCFA, NCWU, NCMFC, and NCDMF. You feel otherwise and it is understood.



   
ReplyQuote
eric broome
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1299
 

I trust CCANC too.....I trust them to continue the same crap they always have. You continued the same thought process even while denying it. You bet that most of rec tickets were honest mistakes while comm tickets were just cost of doing business. You're completely out of it IMO. I've known plenty of rec fishermen who make double trips when the bite is hot. If we were being honest, I'd say a majority of recs and comms have been guilty of this and it's not an honest mistake. Same with small fish. People are dishonest. It's a human trait. It doesn't discriminate based on which card you carry. Please don't go thru the trouble to tell me how honest you are and how youv'e never done the tings I mentioned. It may be true but it's changes nothing about the statement itself. You'd be blown away how many people are out there fishing without a license at all. You're the only one still crying about the damn lawsuit. Hands up everyone, who thinks that the silly turtle lawsuit is gonna put even one single rec fisherman off the water? Give it a break man. I think your background in finance has given you a bad view of people. I can guarantee you that your statement about comms seeing the 800k rec license fees and salivating over it is absurd. 99% of them don't even know what you are talking about or even what VMS even means. They've never heard of it.



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

I still trust CCANC and NOAA much more than NCFA, NCWU, NCMFC, and NCDMF. You feel otherwise and it is understood.

I don't trust any of them. I was a member of CCA a long time ago and have been to NOAA Fisheries meetings and was lied to by both.

I have dealt with NCDMF but that was in getting the fishing license exemption process created for MAD so it was not relevant to this conversation but they always were fair and another time I got pulled over by a NCDMF Officer for violating a no wake zone that did not exist. That caused a lot of discomfort for an overzeolous fish cop after the fact, but again off topic but these are my only dealings with NCDMF.

I met the NCFA head lobbiest in Washington (can't remember his name but it was not Jerry Shill) and he was the biggest skeezbag I encountered next to the endless list of Senators and Representatives.... all liars when it came to what they told me vs. what they actually did except for Walter Jones and Richard Burr. They kept their word.

Never once had any interaction with NCWU and know nothing about them

So, you tried to lump me in as trusting the commercial lobby and you failed. I trust no one that is a lobbyist, is part of the lobbying group that flat out lies to its members (CCA, NCFA, NCWU probably too) and the very least goes to NOAA Fisheries who are packed with the biggest bunch of lying SOBs to ever come across my path.

Who do I trust? The fishermen on the water every day like Capt John, Capt Dave, Capt Hifko, Capt Gould. These guys see real world evidence on the health of our fisheries. They know the devastating impacts that Catch Shares would have on fishermen, fishing communities and the total lack of a biological benefit that would exist if they became reality.

I don't need some lab rat dumping numbers into a computer using failed methodologies to determine fish stocks when they dont get off their ass and go out on boats with knowlegable captains and gather data.

When I attended the BSB dog and pony BS show in Raleigh, the liar in chief Greg Waugh claimed NOAA Fisheries did not have enough money to get out on the water to do correct sampling of the stock.

I offered to find them 100 FREE boats across the entire SAFMC management territory, volunteers that would take them out fishing and I was turned down. They are not interested in science, they are interested in adopting the agenda of the people that donate millions upon millions of dollars.

NOAA fisheries has the best scientists that money can buy! Just ask PEW, EDF, Oceana and the rest of the radical left wing environmentalist groups or new SAFMC council member Chris Conklin how that $250 K check from PEW found its way to his snapper grouper business to support catch shares.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

NOAA fisheries has the best scientists that money can buy! Just ask PEW, EDF, Oceana and the rest of the radical left wing environmentalist groups or new SAFMC council member Chris Conklin how that $250 K check from PEW found its way to his snapper grouper business to support catch shares.

Also, there is an abundance of folks at NOAA and many other federal agencies involved in the Catch Shares game that previously worked for PEW, EDF, and Oceana; especially PEW and EDF.



   
ReplyQuote
SuperGrouper
(@supergrouper)
Trusted Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 62
 

http://fisherynation.com/press-releases
Keeps getting better what a bunch of crap.



   
ReplyQuote
eric broome
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1299
 

Funny how the word conspiracy taints the discussion. I'll throw it out anyway, there's a conspiracy being perpetrated against east coast fishermen. If you fail to see how the seperation of our "stake holders" (love the language) into two smaller, easier to control groups is all connected, or if your personal feelings just can't help but get in the way, then you are helping them in a big way. Any day now the sport fish talk will start up again because right now everyone's focused on NOAA and PEW. They'll float the gamefish status stories and pretty soon all that opposition will melt into a fight....diluting the message about their failures.



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

Funny how the word conspiracy taints the discussion. I'll throw it out anyway, there's a conspiracy being perpetrated against east coast fishermen. If you fail to see how the seperation of our "stake holders" (love the language) into two smaller, easier to control groups is all connected, or if your personal feelings just can't help but get in the way, then you are helping them in a big way. Any day now the sport fish talk will start up again because right now everyone's focused on NOAA and PEW. They'll float the gamefish status stories and pretty soon all that opposition will melt into a fight....diluting the message about their failures.

Doubtful anyone but comms mention a gamefish bill again. They are the only ones that mentioned it recently. I was not in favor of a bill until the lawsuit was filed. Those that pushed for that bill found who controls the legislature. So instead, keep watching for gear restrictions, like the billboards and more things coming. Instead of restrictions on gill nets they will now look for removal.



   
ReplyQuote
Randy Hoffman
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 192
 

Funny how the word conspiracy taints the discussion. I'll throw it out anyway, there's a conspiracy being perpetrated against east coast fishermen. If you fail to see how the seperation of our "stake holders" (love the language) into two smaller, easier to control groups is all connected, or if your personal feelings just can't help but get in the way, then you are helping them in a big way. Any day now the sport fish talk will start up again because right now everyone's focused on NOAA and PEW. They'll float the gamefish status stories and pretty soon all that opposition will melt into a fight....diluting the message about their failures.

I have always thought this, but I would call it more of a multi-pronged strategy more so than a conspiracy. Regardless of what it's called, it is an effective way to weaken the opposition which is obviously all of us out here on the water.



   
ReplyQuote
eric broome
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1299
 

Doubtful anyone but comms mention a gamefish bill again. They are the only ones that mentioned it recently. I was not in favor of a bill until the lawsuit was filed. Those that pushed for that bill found who controls the legislature. So instead, keep watching for gear restrictions, like the billboards and more things coming. Instead of restrictions on gill nets they will now look for removal.

You are still stuck in this mentality that commercial guys are steering the ship. You also seem very very tuned into what's coming next. Think about this, how many times have comm fishermen been attacked by the hobby sector both legislative and just plain old sh!t talk? It still floors me that you (in particular) are so angry about them pushing back for once....and in such a harmless way too. You may have anger control issues because you take things way to personally. If I took all the crap slung at me on this site and others personally I'd be a wreck. Try to have thicker skin man. That thought creeping in your head that says "those damn comms are trying to put me off the water with their lawsuit..." Thats paranoia man. If I allowed myself to succumb to it, I'd be in another profession. I'd be wondering why the DMF has left all brunswick county water closed to oysters thru the holiday and for a solid two weeks over one night of rain..... :duh:



   
ReplyQuote
John Rakoci
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 2331
 

So wrong Eric. If any paranoia it is you and others like Ken thinking the end of the world is coming with change. You can wine and cry and that may delay it, but change is coming. You can make silly comments to the messenger, but it is still coming. All those tears are in vain as the change will not be all that earth shattering or 'heritage' shattering either. I'm not angry they showed childishness and filed the lawsuit as it showed their true intentions. Without that there would be no programs by CCANC and others.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 3 / 4
Share: