SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Finetooth?
BULL shark. a man eater Juan!
Dusky maybe?
Looks like a spinner shark to me.
They are very common in that area
A Sandbar maybe?
Spinners have black tips like blacktip Sharks. Anal fin in spinners has a black tip while blacktip anal fins do not.
I would guess sandbar or finetooth based on the proportionally tall dorsal fin, color and rear find but tell tale sign is presence of an inter dorsal ridge. Color is a little light for a typical sandbar, but that can vary. Looks too stocky for a dusky(dorsal also isn't right for a dusky) so my guess is sandbar if it had a dorsal ridge and finetooth (more likely based on body shape/conformation) if it did not.
It's a Blacktip, most common shark around the surf zone. You can tell by the "Z" shaped white on the sides and lack of any other distinguishing marks. Dorsal is too big to be a spinner, it's too small to be a Dusky or Sandbar, not triangular enough, nor the shark stocky enough, to be a Bull. Could be a finetooth very hard to tell the difference but they usually don't get very big. Blacktip's name comes from the underside of the pectoral fins, which you can't see. Also can't see the anal fin, if it had a black tip then it's a spinner. I have a couple hundred blacktips tagged on the books with NOAA back from my landbased shark fishing days.
That is absolutely NOT a blacktip. That is laughable. Wrong color, wrong proportions, wrong tail shape. Not even close.
Not a fine tooth either. Way too stocky. Wrong dorsal shape.
Not a Sandbar. The dorsal on a sandy is about twice that tall.
Not a spinner. They have short fins, black tips and are not that stocky. Also wrong coloration.
Not a bull shark. The pectoral fins on a bull are longer. Bulls are more grey instead of grey-bronze. Dorsal is more triangular and the trailing edge is straight.
It is a Dusky. (Also known as a black whaler or "bronze whaler" depending on where you are from.) Easiest way to tell is the trailing edge of the pectoral fins are even with or slightly behind the trailing edge of the dorsal, but the dorsal trailing edge curves inward instead of straight like a bull sharks. Body size and shape is similar to a bull. Coloration can vary in a Dusky from a blue-grey to a bronze-grey. Slow growing shark. They get pretty big. 12ft or so. That one is probably 12 to 15 years old. Not supposed to be a threat to humans, but the Aussies will tell you otherwise.
Tim
Tim
Good documentation and well edified I'm today
It is a Dusky. (Also known as a black whaler or "bronze whaler" depending on where you are from.) Easiest way to tell is the trailing edge of the pectoral fins are even with or slightly behind the trailing edge of the dorsal, but the dorsal trailing edge curves inward instead of straight like a bull sharks. Body size and shape is similar to a bull. Coloration can vary in a Dusky from a blue-grey to a bronze-grey. Slow growing shark. They get pretty big. 12ft or so. That one is probably 12 to 15 years old. Not supposed to be a threat to humans, but the Aussies will tell you otherwise.
Tim
Great stuff but one last question: how are they on the grill?
It is a Dusky. (Also known as a black whaler or "bronze whaler" depending on where you are from.) Easiest way to tell is the trailing edge of the pectoral fins are even with or slightly behind the trailing edge of the dorsal, but the dorsal trailing edge curves inward instead of straight like a bull sharks. Body size and shape is similar to a bull. Coloration can vary in a Dusky from a blue-grey to a bronze-grey. Slow growing shark. They get pretty big. 12ft or so. That one is probably 12 to 15 years old. Not supposed to be a threat to humans, but the Aussies will tell you otherwise.
Tim
Great stuff but one last question: how are they on the grill?
Never been that hungry. LOL
Dusky
I used to work on a long line boat out of Wrightsville in the 80's. We caught right many of those but they were much bigger which threw me at first. But I am pretty sure that it is a Dusky. Out of all the sharks on the line, Duskys were very docile and easy to handle. I would say that the ones we caught averaged over 500 pounds.
Nice catch.... I hope you released it. They taste like what ever you put on it. In other words they have very little taste at all.


