SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Shrimp By Catch and...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Shrimp By Catch and Aquaculture

26 Posts
15 Users
0 Reactions
34.7 K Views
Tim Barefoot
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 942
Topic starter   [#34998]

Not to hijack an existing thread....
If we take a historical look @ aquculture, one of the major issues with aquaculture is the cost of feed...processed protien pellets.
What if, just what if we worked WITH some folks (in the form of NO INTREREST loans and GRANTS) that are willing to build huge cold storage facilities for freezing tons of feed.
I know of several facilities that could produce fingerling flounder (year round) at a reasonable price for these shrimpers/gill netters (part of the year), AND open water or closed loop fish ranchers.
Beef is grown at a 6:1 feed to growth rate
Pork is grown at a 5:1 feed to growth rate
Fish are typically grown at a 1.5 or 2:1 growth rate.
If you fed your fish a million pounds of food, they grow 750,000 pounds, @3 dollars/pound... according to my math, that is is a pretty good ROI for FREE food (minus the cost of storage) just sayin'....

With that being said, how could we make the best of 20 million ponds of FREE food? Correct me where I am wrong, but don't flounder eat small spots, croakers and grey trout???? (what you see in the tailbags)
Being that it is completely natural feed, couldn't you say that these are ORGANICLY grown aqua cultured flounder (or other fish...drum etc...)?
If you were growing fish instead of netting fish, you don't HAVE TO SELL in October, November and December when the price of flounder drops to nothing... hang on to your fish until Feb., March and April when the price is HIGH.
I AM NOT AN EXPERT on this topic, but I know some, and would refer to them to answer some of the pointed questions.
I know folks think of the salmon industry when we start talking about large scale aquaculture, however this field has made huge advances in just the last few years. Yes, they made some mistakes in the salmon industry, but we have learned some valuble lessons of what NOT to do.

I would like to hear from some proactive minded commercials, and yes there are some.



   
Quote
Frank Brown
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 79
 

Yes I would like to hear from some commercial fishermen too. I am on the shrimp A/C and have been talking to a lot of commercial fishermen about considering aquaculture and of roughly 100 commercial fishermen, only one said he would even consider it, and that was on here. All the trips I have made to commercial docks have been failures. I see aquaculture as the future for commercial fishermen, and that includes raising shrimp. There seems to be a bias against raising what you can get for free.
In my way of thinking, with the right setup, recreational fishing license fees could be used to contract with commercial aquaculture to raise fingerlings to put in sounds and ocean. With that type contract, a commercial could go to Sea Grant or a bank and get good loan options to finance the operation, which would be expensive in the beginning, but so is buying a commercial trawl. The major problem today is that of the flounder that Brunswick high school put in the water each year, the commercial guys are allowed to net them at 14 inches, while the recreational guys only get a chance at 15 inches. So why should one group pay for another to be given preferance.
We need to change our thinking on all fishery issues,period, and aquaculture is the only thing that will save the small commercial fishermen.
Just my opinion!
Frank



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

big difference in walking down to a building full of fish tanks in back of the house versus jumping aboard a boat and watching the sun come up or set while fishing nets not knowing whether you made a good trip or did not make enough to pay the fuel bill. Most commercial fishermen consider themselves watermen and raising fish in a tank doesn't lend itself to them even if the money potential is greater.



   
ReplyQuote
seawolftoo
(@)
Eminent Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 45
 

From my personal reading I am under the impression that unless subsidized heavily , aquaculture operations in the US have mostly gone broke and given foreign competition its tough to make it happen and make the economics work.

I'm aware of one in this county and several more in adjacent counties that went broke

Clams seem to do ok however and timing and contracts are everything

Most pf the shrimp grown by aquaculture are freshwater prawn and not equivalent to wild caught shrimp



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Smith
(@wildcard)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 1573
 

AND we could use "by-catch" for feed. Problem solved! Frank



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

AND we could use "by-catch" for feed. Problem solved! Frank

I don't know what shrimp prefer to eat but byproduct from fish houses ground into a meal and fortified sounds like something that some critters would eat. Blue crabs love bycatch. I read a study paper by a UNC grad student where she talked specifically about the blue crab population thriving on bycatch.

Anyway, I support efforts in shrimp/fish hatchery science.



   
ReplyQuote
Jim
 Jim
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 960
 

What if A tax write off we're give to shrimpers and fish houses for baskets of by-catch instead of dumping? People will follow the money.



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Brown
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 79
 

Why is every post on here trying to increase bycatch rewards. Yes people will follow the money and if you start paying for bycatch there will be plenty and it already is one of our major problems in the water. I guess I am just of a different mind set. AS for being a waterman, it sounds great but everyone needs to plant what they harvest as the freebies are like food stamps, they are running out. Status Quo will lead to demise of fishery stocks and commercial fishermen. Alittle self examination is in order.



   
ReplyQuote
Scalez
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 67
 

NEWS FLASH :

Some by catch is sold. NC law limits it to 500#/day Dec thru Mar, 1000#Apr thru Nov. Dealers charge @ $0.74/ # as crab bait in flats. It's somewhat confusing since elsewhere the NC law says 5000#/day/vessel ???

Two thoughts: 1) shrimpers have $ incentive for by catch, 2) trip limits are there to prevent abuse but force waste



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Smith
(@wildcard)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 1573
 

Why is every post on here trying to increase bycatch rewards. Yes people will follow the money and if you start paying for bycatch there will be plenty and it already is one of our major problems in the water. I guess I am just of a different mind set. AS for being a waterman, it sounds great but everyone needs to plant what they harvest as the freebies are like food stamps, they are running out. Status Quo will lead to demise of fishery stocks and commercial fishermen. Alittle self examination is in order.

Crabbers are running out of bait sources,so their costs are going up. The anti-trawler crowd makes it sound like "as long as there are trawlers around, there's gonna be wasted by-catch". I hope the trawlers don't go anywhere, so I was proposing a use of the by catch. After all, poiund nets and haul nets used to supply bait for our crabbers (remember the most valuable fishery we have). Don't have pogy boats any more, so was just offering a solution. Protien is protien, food is food. By the way, all the talk about not putting anything back in will lead to our demise; when you fill up your car/truck with gas or diesel, what are you putting back? I understand that is a finite supply, that doesn't reproduce, like fish do. I also remeber very long lines back in the late 70's when we were running out the first time. I believe MR Barefoot hit the nail squarely on the head, when he made the arguement that the world has gone viral. I will add to his answer, that along with that alot of oflks now have way to much time on their hands. Yes the sky is falling, cause I saw it on the inter-net. Frank



   
ReplyQuote
Jim
 Jim
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 960
 

My preference is zero by-catch. But that is not realistic. I think the goal here is to tune the whole system with common sense to get the best optimum results for both recs and comm. I suggest comms get on board and only get a minimum for bycatch inconvience.

Is anyone totally happy with where we are now with our fishery? At what point will we know? BSB everywhere, but totally screwed up seasons, spots flounder croaker almost absent. We now have limits on fish we never had before that are needed.

I just want fish populations back up for all to enjoy.



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Brown
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 79
 

AMEN!!!! :hail: :hail: :hail:



   
ReplyQuote
Glen Montgomery
(@)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 284
 

Think a huge part of the problem is that most commercials see proposals to reduce bycatch as nothing more than an attempt by groups such as the CCA to abolish commercial fishing gear other than hook and line. And they have very good reason to believe this I might add.



   
ReplyQuote
Lyle
 Lyle
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 146
 

NEWS FLASH :

Some by catch is sold. NC law limits it to 500#/day Dec thru Mar, 1000#Apr thru Nov. Dealers charge @ $0.74/ # as crab bait in flats. It's somewhat confusing since elsewhere the NC law says 5000#/day/vessel ???

Two thoughts: 1) shrimpers have $ incentive for by catch, 2) trip limits are there to prevent abuse but force waste

NEWS FLASH:

Not everything you read on NCWATERMAN.COM is the truth or fact.

The person that came up with those figures assumed that a flat of crab bait was 25 pounds. It's not, it's 50-60 pounds.

He also assumed that crabbers pay the same price for it that they do for fatback. They don't, they pay about half of what fatbacks cost if they pay anything for it at all. Frozen in flats, it's about $8-$10 for 50 pounds. Unfrozen, it's about $10 for 100 pounds. Fatbacks are double those prices.

So to the shrimp boat may get 10 cent but probably closer to 5 cent per pound depending on if they sell it to a crabber or if they sell it to a dealer. That guy did a lot of assuming without having any first hand knowledge of anything

I'm not sure how many of them even bring bycatch in. Around here none do because it's not worth the effort to them to have to ice down.

If you'll read my previous post on the subject of shrimp bycatch, you will realize I'm all for reducing it. What I'm not for, is making up lies about selling bycatch or the price of it in an effort to gain more support. To be honest, I don't think we should allow it to even be brought to the dock.

Facts, proven FACTS, let's stick to them and not repeat hearsay from Chuckle's website :wtg:



   
ReplyQuote
Scalez
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 67
 

Fishy - I've got no agenda to deceive people to support reduced by catch. I've never bought crab bait so I have no idea what it costs other than what I read. Thanks for giving us the real numbers. I have never seen a shrimper sell by catch and the small payout is probably the reason. Not worth the trouble !

The point of my post was simply to note that by catch IS sometimes sold and used. Further investigation tells us that 5000#/day/vessel is the law for "unmarketable" smalls.

15A NCAC 03M .0102 UNMARKETABLE FINFISH

(a) It is unlawful to land finfish if in violation of minimum size or possession limits established by rule or proclamation.

(b) It is unlawful to land finfish taken in connection with commercial fishing operations which are unmarketable as individual finfish by reason of size, except a quantity not exceeding 5,000 pounds per vessel per day may be sold to a dealer that is licensed under G.S. 113-169.3 (f) (6), (7) and (8).



   
ReplyQuote
Page 1 / 2
Share: