SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I have done years of hook and line commercial fishing (deeper near shore rock cod, salmon and halibut) out of Bodega Bay/San Fransisco Bay CA and and I've done a few trips on a shrimp trawl (for grass shrimp with some fin fish as by catch) and sine boat (for hearing, anchovies and sardines) in the San Fransisco Bay CA and I know each state does things different. I'm amazed at the amount of by-catch that happens here and stuff like that could never happen in CA from all of the tree huggers but is this really par for the course for NC?
So the last few days there has been a marine fisheries meeting talking about Shrimp Trawling and here is something that is quite shocking (or at least to me). It was shown on the https://www.facebook.com/ncfisherymanagementandyou page so I'm posting it here.
The owner of a trawler boat said a few things during public comment.
1. Don't believe anything you hear and only half of what you see
2. The person said there is hardly any bycatch now due to effort being down.
3. They also said Mikey Daniels has developed a bycatch reduction device (BRD) that reduces bycatch by 50%
Here is a video taken by the captain of that persons boat trawling in the Pamlico Sound. So if this is what they call a 50% reduction of bycatch I would hate to see what it looked like before. I know the DMF says 4.5 to 1 by catch ratio but this video looks to be way more.
http://www.youtube.com/v/WLl4GSZLqGU
[/youtube]
It's because the ratio is higher in the Pamlico. Already crunched those numbers. DMF's study provided the raw numbers. Why Daniel's insists on 4.5:1 I don't know.
No one ever accused me of being 100% pro comm as I believe much can be done. It takes time and research. But WoW!! Looks like too many Yankee tree huggers and turtle lovers have moved to NC. Recs should be very afraid of these crazies. Recs hooking their beloved turtles has been mentioned there already. Granted, comms have provided some of their ammo but some is rehashed several times and some is questionable. Where do they come up with "our fish"? Maybe CCA is helping this crowd. Targeting politicians~~ what is next?
https://www.facebook.com/ncfisherymanagementandyou
edit ~~ forgot we cannot say Ya n Kee here... don't know why as it is not a bad word in any way.
Watched the video and looked up the site C/C referenced. All I can say is (like I stated in the site CC fefered to) is be very careful what you help come to be. The folk's that you think are "helping" you gain more fish for your cause, also have the number's (estimate's if you will) of the sea turtle's hooked and killed from recreational fishing in Pamlico Sound last year. They also are pushing the great manatee "cause" up this way too. Yes sir, you do-gooder's are in for a great big helping of their "concern" when THEY get done with the commercial guy. JUst how it work's, can't make this stuff up. When you screw your neighbor, Karma come's a callin'. You have been warned, good luck with it! Frank
This isn't even news. You can scroll the FPT forums and find a ton of discussion on the 4.5:1 topic before the FB page ever existed. I specifically remember debating with Frank. The general public is like a child.... you can hand them a report and basically nothing happens but hand them a picture book (video) and all hell breaks loose. What the FB page has apparently done is found an easy way to appeal to people's senses in a quick hit manner. People can generally handle fish in nets but put flipper in a net and you are screwed.
Said it before, say it again, I 100% support the removal of inshore trawls.
my 2 cents/sense for what it is worth. I purchased a small shrimp trawl several years ago. Dragged through the Core/Pamlico sound as Rec/Comm gear. Every time we pulled it we caught a turtle, shrimp and an azzload of bycatch. Way more than the ratio listed above. Our sounds are nurseries, they should not be trawled, period! The amount of bycatch is sickening.
It takes time and research.
How much time and research, this isn't new. The problem will be dealt with one way or another (rightfully or wrongfully), count on it ... :shrug:
It takes time and research.
How much time and research, this isn't new. The problem will be dealt with one way or another (rightfully or wrongfully), count on it ... :shrug:
Much better dealt with 'rightfully'. Personally, I believe there are too many turtles now but I'm not ready to see turtle lovers hung ~~~~ yet. I think that FB page shows some problems caused by comms and recs adding fuel to the hugger's fires. Comms and recs better wake up. There are always going to be accidental catches in nets AND on hooks. Both sides need to police ourselves and each other without bringing the anti-everything huggers into our lives.
CC, I'm glad to see you coming around to a more centralized point of view. Inshore trawls are gonna disappear very soon. I support that. I think that there are areas that are ok to trawl on the inside, but overall it is a problem. I also think that once those trawls are gone, there will be absolutely no visible increase in fish stocks that could be attributed to those closures. While those couple hundred guys will be out of the water, the waterways and sounds will still have shores lined with neon green lawns and we'll still have coal ash ponds (new to me) leaching their crud into the water system and the water will still be acidifying steadily. When they see that their efforts haven't produced the results that they want, they will turn their eye on the next thing. Who knows what that will be but I have a guess.
I do not know why everybody wants to debate bycatch. It is a proven fact that the bycatch is there in large numbers. No trawler is willing to take anybody out on their boat and show them how much bycath that they have. If it was small, there would be videos all over the internet. They are still trying to make such a video.
The facts are that if you owned a layer chicken house and I went in there and killed a lot of your hens, then you would expect egg production to be down and I would get blamed for it.
Why is it that you do not realize that every fish that you see in the bycatch never had a chance to be a breeder and lay it's eggs. That is why so many fish stocks are down. Trawlers are destroying our breeding stock before it can mature. What part of simple do you not understand.
What part of simple do you not understand.
Yea, it's really simple. Definitely only one reason..... ๐
my 2 cents/sense for what it is worth. I purchased a small shrimp trawl several years ago. Dragged through the Core/Pamlico sound as Rec/Comm gear. Every time we pulled it we caught a turtle, shrimp and an azzload of bycatch. Way more than the ratio listed above. Our sounds are nurseries, they should not be trawled, period! The amount of bycatch is sickening.
An honest answer from someone with no
"Skin in the game",
just a respect for our coastline.
Eric ~ I think I've always had a 'centralized point of view' but was vocal more one sided. Never would have guessed recs were making the rope to hang themselves with. Does anyone need to provide the huggers and turtle lovers ammo to be used against comms as recs will come next. Inshore trawls may go away one day and they should. There are some areas it can work but certainly not in narrow sections of the ICW. If inshore catches would improve it will take a decade +/-. As far as the lawn thing ~~ I have a contract to keep it decent but not like a golf course. Have 3 neighbors that overseed every winter to have green grass all year instead of the brown like most everywhere else. Cutting grass in the winter is dumb and they should have gone to FL when they left NY and NJ and had all the green they want. Too many turtles now. Nothing but a hazard to small boat navigation. Looks like a new crabber has moved in. The ICW is loaded with his pots on both sides. I'll be looking for a new spot for my 5 pots ~~ may dump them in now to claim a spot before I have to travel miles to drop them. I'll not bait them until April.
Eric ~ I think I've always had a 'centralized point Have 3 neighbors that overseed every winter to have green grass all year instead of the brown like most everywhere else. Cutting grass in the winter is dumb and they should have gone to FL when they left NY and NJ and had all the green they want. Too many turtles now. Nothing but a hazard to small boat navigation. Looks like a new crabber has moved in. The ICW is loaded with his pots on both sides. I'll be looking for a new spot for my 5 pots ~~ may dump them in now to claim a spot before I have to travel miles to drop them. I'll not bait them until April.
:wtg:
Inside shrimp trawling has killed the fishery for spot, croaker and weakfish. Southern flounder is being affected. Blue crab is being affected. This is both a recreational issue and a commercial issue.
In 2008, NC shrimpers on the Pamlico Sound killed 2-million pounds of 2" to 8" juvenile weakfish as bycatch, 55-million fish. In 2008, the total east coast weakfish spawning stock biomass was only 4.5-million pounds.
If only 10% of those 55-million juveniles made it to Age-1 spawners, the biomass would increase by over 3-million pounds per year.
You'll hear that "over fishing" is not occurring, that natural mortality is the issue. Specifically, you'll hear the predation theory about stripers and dogfish eating all the juveniles and Age-1 fish, which is preventing a recovery.
The number one predator for NC's Gray Trout, Croaker and Spot is the Pamlico Sound shrimp boat. The video above makes that clear.