SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Me wonders if this is the nugget they are wrestling with:
http://www.ncfisheries.net/recreational/NCCRFL.htm
"The license is required to recreationally take finfish in the state’s Coastal Fishing Waters, which include sounds, coastal rivers and their tributaries, out to three miles in the ocean. Recreational anglers who catch fish in the Exclusive Economic Zone (3 miles – 200 miles offshore) will be required to have this license to land fish in state waters."
So you catch this monster fish and renew your license before....?
Is there a point in time and/or space that the catch would be legal?
What is the definition of "to land fish in state waters"?
I'm buyin a license tonite.........
Tourny rules regarding license. Sounds like this is gonna fall in the laps of NCDMF. Whether or not they consider the area they were fishing to be State or Federal water.
I think its clearly stated that its out to 200 miles though. No money, no record, no nothing.....
HMS Permits
All boats must have one of the following valid permits - HMS Angling (recreational), HMS Charter/Headboat, or Atlantic Tunas General Category Permit (commercial). Permits will be valid from the date of issuance through December 31, 2010. Permits must be on board the vessel when engaged in fishing. The Big Rock Tournament is a registered recreational HMS tournament. For more information - www.nmfspermits.com or (888)-872-8862.
North Carolina Recreational Fishing License: As of 01/01/2009
The North Carolina Division of Marine Fisheries will require a recreational fishing license for anyone participating in fishing aboard a vessel. This includes a license for the captain, the mate and the anglers. These individual licenses can be purchased on a 10-day, annual or lifetime basis.
252-726-7021. http://www.ncfisheries.net/recreational/NCCRFL.htm
I hate to see this kind of problem at the Big Rock. That is a world class event put on by a tireless and devoted staff. I've fished it 10 or 12 times as an angler. Maybe that's why I'm broke now! I sure hope they find a way to get that money into the right hands.
Me wonders if this is the nugget they are wrestling with:
http://www.ncfisheries.net/recreational/NCCRFL.htm
"The license is required to recreationally take finfish in the state’s Coastal Fishing Waters, which include sounds, coastal rivers and their tributaries, out to three miles in the ocean. Recreational anglers who catch fish in the Exclusive Economic Zone (3 miles – 200 miles offshore) will be required to have this license to land fish in state waters."
So you catch this monster fish and renew your license before....?
Is there a point in time and/or space that the catch would be legal?
What is the definition of "to land fish in state waters"?
I have not read the rules of the tourney, but if it states that everyone has to have a license ( which is what other post are saying) then that shouldn't matter. If the tourney rule says you must have it to be eligible then it's pretty clean and simple. Personally I think it's BS that there not going to get what they deserve, but a rule's a rule and you can't give them a pass on this one or someone will want a pass on the next small rule violation. Live and learn.
I see your point, got no dog in the hunt, but will argue with a fence post if nothing better to do... 😆
As posted above, here is what the rules say:
North Carolina Recreational Fishing License: As of 01/01/2009
The North Carolina Division of Marine Fisheries will require a recreational fishing license for anyone participating in fishing aboard a vessel. (note it does NOT say that the Big Rock Tournament requires one.)
When you go and look at what the North Carolina Division of Marine Fisheries "requires", it says "Recreational anglers who catch fish in the Exclusive Economic Zone (3 miles – 200 miles offshore) will be required to have this license to land fish in state waters."
Later....
[
Personally I think it's BS that there not going to get what they deserve, but a rule's a rule and you can't give them a pass on this one or someone will want a pass on the next small rule violation. Live and learn.
Fishfinder this is not an attack on you, however I have seen this type statement made a few times now and I fail to understand! I feel its my responsbility when entering a tournament to know 100% of the rules, I owe that much to the guys fishing with me and chipping in on the expense. My wife could understand within a few moments of reading the rules where they were WRONG. She simply pointed this out to me. RULE No. 9.
9. FEDERAL AND STATE REGULATIONS - (Marlin and Gamefish) As of 12/16/08
Blue Marlin-99" LJFL (lower jaw fork length) and 1 per vessel per trip*
Billfish Release Methods-Under these regulations, anglers are allowed to remove the hook from a billfish using a hook-removal device. However, fish below the minimum size cannot be removed from the water, consistent with previous regulations.
Yellowfin Tuna- 27" curved fork length, 3 per person per day. Permit required. www.nmfspermits.com.
Wahoo-2 per person per day
Dolphin- 10 per person per day
*Size limits apply throughout Atlantic Ocean and adjacent waters to U.S. citizens and U. S. flagged vessels.
HMS Permits
All boats must have one of the following valid permits - HMS Angling (recreational), HMS Charter/Headboat, or Atlantic Tunas General Category Permit (commercial). Permits will be valid from the date of issuance through December 31, 2010. Permits must be on board the vessel when engaged in fishing. The Big Rock Tournament is a registered recreational HMS tournament. For more information - www.nmfspermits.com or (888)-872-8862.
SIMPLE AS IT GETs!!!!
North Carolina Recreational Fishing License: As of 01/01/2009
The North Carolina Division of Marine Fisheries will require a recreational fishing license for anyone participating in fishing aboard a vessel. This includes a license for the captain, the mate and the anglers. These individual licenses can be purchased on a 10-day, annual or lifetime basis.
252-726-7021. http://www.ncfisheries.net/recreational/NCCRFL.htm
Participant is responsible for knowing all state and federal regulations or any recent changes that may occur.
So what I'm hearing here is, if one was the 2nd place boat and did everthing legally and made sure he covered all his bases and laws, should also feel its BS and let the man whom did not obide by all rules have 1st!?!? The state waters verses fed waters is irrelevant here. The breaking of this one rule is all it will take to DQ this guy and it will be official today!
Congratulations to the Carnivore crew, Brandon, Garland, Brad Sewell, Ben Beasley and a few more whom leased this boat and Captain Ed. Another 2nd year win for these Swansboro natives. Yes these same guys leased the Sea Creature last year to take home $750,000.00. By time these guys get this win which is 100% thiers, they will have a 2 year win of appx $1.9 Million......... Go Bogue Boys!!
Everyone that has ever fished a tournament knows its their responsibility to know the rules and obide by them or suffer the consequences of the ENTIRE team being DQ'ed. In most cases they don't DQ people in tournaments they DQ boats. Everyone knows all this going in, its all in black and white. The whole reason for rules are to level the playing field for all whom sign their name acknoledging they understand the rules. I to hate it for the others on the boat but, someone dropped the ball and it wasn't the Big Rock Committe.
Again congratulations team Carnavore for winning fair and square!
The mate has been fined and identified.
http://www.jdnews.com/news/news-79639-fishing-alexandria.html
From the article linked above:
“I can tell you we cited Peter Martin Wann for not holding a coastal recreational fishing at the time his boat landed the 883-pound blue marlin,†Fish said. “He did buy a license later that afternoon.â€
Now that doesn't see quite right. Did they jump the gun?
Regs say "Recreational anglers who catch fish in the Exclusive Economic Zone (3 miles – 200 miles offshore) will be required to have this license to land fish in state waters."
So how can N.C. Division of Marine Fisheries write him up for what happened outside of 3 miles??
Because they are coming back into NC Coastal Waters???(meant as a way of asking a question)
Because they are coming back into NC Coastal Waters???(meant as a way of asking a question)
So if he bought the license 5 miles out, is that legal, in the eyes of Fisheries???
Would not think so, as you have to have to have the license when you leave the dock.
What would of happened if and I know it would not happen, but what if, they had been checked on the way out of the inlet. I would think the individual would be fined then. All persons on the boat would have to have the CRFL since there is fishing gear on board. From what I have read, the boat did not have a blanket license to cover everyone.
lol dont slam me as sometimes i think to much......
Would not think so, as you have to have to have the license when you leave the dock.
What would of happened if and I know it would not happen, but what if, they had been checked on the way out of the inlet. I would think the individual would be fined then. All persons on the boat would have to have the CRFL since there is fishing gear on board. From what I have read, the boat did not have a blanket license to cover everyone.
lol dont slam me as sometimes i think to much......
Blanket license (for hire boats) was not in play here, the block license (for rec boats 23' and over) could have been - but I am just guessing there - but it appears from the regs that these are "issued" to individuals for use and must be returned once expired (since only good for 10 days once "issued"), so that "seems" to work.
I have been stopped before with rods on the boat and once I proved no fish onboard was not checked for fishing license. Only ever checked for fishing license while fishing or if had fish on board when stopped. So maybe only my experience, but not sure.
Just seems interesting that the press release indicated "We have been in contact with the Division of Marine Fisheries as well as the NC Attorney General's Office." That would APPEAR to imply the committee is trying to gain a clear understanding of the law from both parties - maybe???
Speculation is fun and keeps the days (and nights) interesting.....
Tight lines.....
more speculation I read this afternoon, they caught the fish in federal waters, mate owned up to not having a license (or captain did - whatever you believe), they called in and bought a license for him before entering state waters.
so what is the definition of 'land' in the rules in this case. Before they 'landed' back into state waters he was legal.
He was probably legal in the eyes of the law. But tourney rules say you need a license to participate? So regardless of the technicalities they broke tourney rules. But that's a heck of a fish to kick out on such a rule...
Fish is DQ'd - on the BR web site.