SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I have a 2011 Silverado Z71 crewcab 4x4 5.3L with the towing package, it pulls my 23WA Neptune just fine. I put it and out at Tripps in Shallotte Pnt or at OIB in 2wd I always put it in tow/haul when I tow anything. I pulled a car carrier with a crysler Journey on it to the mechanic for a friend today and it did fine. My last truck was an 08 Sierra Z71 crew cab 4x4 never had any problem with it towing either. Most of my trips are 10 mi or less tho. The longest haul I made with it was with the 08 from Shallotte pnt to Leland and back and had no problem going with the flow of traffic on Hwy 17. Not sure of the weight of the boat but it is pretty heavy for a 23. the extra weight of the cabin, 140 gal. gas, 225 opti on an armstrong bracket, 2 batteries and gear its probably between 5000 and 6000 lbs. Since you have a lot longer haul than I, you might should consider the Duramax or Powerstroke, One of my buddies has the Ford with a programmer on it and gets 21+ mpg out on Hwy normal driving.
It's not what you can tow it's what you can stop. That being said I think you will be fine with a 5.3 Sierra.
I have a Ford Excursion with diesel....DONE! But any of the newer diesels would be a good choice too.
I would look at 3/4 ton whatever your choice Chevy Ford or Dodge. The 3/4 ton trucks have better brakes and are designed to pull more than 1/2 ton trucks. Their frames are bigger engines are bigger they are all in all a better choice for what you are going to be doing. I was in the same situation when I was looking for a truck. I was looking at 1/2 ton trucks and was checking fuel mileage and comparing brakes ect... The 1/2 ton was pushing the limit. I wound up getting a 3/4 ton Duramax with the Allison transmission. I have been very pleased with it. Fuel mileage is about 21-22 not pulling any thing and pulling my boat 245 C Hawk is which is a very heavy boat is around 17-18 mpg :wtg:
I'm a long time Ford truck owner. My 1999 F250 SD has 190,000 miles on a 7.3 liter International turbodiesel. It's rated for 13,800 lbs tow weight and has a massive disc brake system for stopping it. It's kind of like me: wide, loud, cantankerous and prone to emitting noxious gasses. But it's one of the best trucks ever made IMHO. With that said, I think the best diesel engine for pickups is a 6 cylinder made by Cummins. It's absolutely bulletproof. Unfortunately it only comes in a Dodge pick up, of which I am not a fan.
I'm a long time Ford truck owner. My 1999 F250 SD has 190,000 miles on a 7.3 liter International turbodiesel. It's rated for 13,800 lbs tow weight and has a massive disc brake system for stopping it. It's kind of like me: wide, loud, cantankerous and prone to emitting noxious gasses. But it's one of the best trucks ever made IMHO. With that said, I think the best diesel engine for pickups is a 6 cylinder made by Cummins. It's absolutely bulletproof. Unfortunately it only comes in a Dodge pick up, of which I am not a fan.
I've got an 02 7.3.Bullet proof,Love that engine!
I got a Ford Expidition with a 5.3 Gas motor that has no idea my 6,000# boat is behind it. Not the best gas mileage, but it is strong. No way I'd buy a diesel unless I got over 10,000 pounds. Good Luck
Great info guys.. I really appreciate the advice.
It's not what you can tow it's what you can stop. That being said I think you will be fine with a 5.3 Sierra.
Good point
if you going to buy a stock deisel for towing purposes. Go to the local dodge dealship and buy a Cummins... Ive had 3 so far and loved everyone one of them. The stock torque off the 6.7 will pull anything you need it to and still get a nice fuel mileage. And for your headaches i wouldnt wory about them ou wont smell a thing driving one of the new deisels
Hey Guys this might not be an apple to apple comparison but I have a 2010 Toyota Tundra we pull a 32ft camper with. The camper weighs 7500lbs and I have yet to have a problem. Hope this helps.
I have a Ford Excursion with diesel....DONE! But any of the newer diesels would be a good choice too.
I'm with you ..have had excursions since they were first made.... I'll drive the one I have now till the wheels fall off ... If if wasn't for an excursion I'd be pushing up daisies, T boned a van years back with my cruse control set on 85....
I really want a 14 f series but I love my space in the X
I didn't buy diesel because it is not good on the turbo to just drive to the supermarket and shut it down. I bought a Dodge 2500 5.7 Hemi and it towed my 12 - 14 k 34' Yellowfin just fine. I sold the lift kept Yellowfin 2 years ago and am now selling the truck. If interested, here's a link. I am probably going to sell it at dealer trade value. It is an awesome tow vehicle. Good luck either way.
http://www.thehulltruth.com/trucks-trailers-sale-wanted/553738-2009-dodge-2500-slt-big-horn.html
I apprecite all the advice. After considering that the truck will be used aa a family vehicle too, kds to school, work, vacations etc. and that i keep that boat on a lift and will only tow it maybe 3-4 times per year, i got a 2012 sierra with hd towing, tranny coolee, and engine oil cooler. As always great advice.
