SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I HOPE HE IS STILL OUT THERE TRYING TO FIRE HER UP...
I heard dat !
Maybe he can use the prop spooled mono as
sum kind of a "rope start"....like a lawn mower.
(btw, what a jackass the perp is)
Everyone is so critical of everything on the web site! I can't believe it!!
For whatever it's worth, the title of this post should be "What An Idiot" as opposed to "What A Idiot".
"I have read the book, took the course and passed with flying colors probably before you were born. I know the rules sir and I was engaged in fishing, when I saw him coming and it didn't look like he was going to turn, we slowed to a crawl waiting for him to pass in front of us and he still went to the stern. We did EVERYTHING by the rules."
In responce.... Was there any attempt to comunicate via vhf? Was there any sort of sound signals snet from any side? Did you start tracking this vessel in a timely manner to deduce his course and speed and to whether the approaching vessel was within the 22 1/2 degree arch which decimates from "burdened" to overtaking. That is the true question. Was there any awareness of the "prudential rule" on either side? I do not think so. The rules of the road are rigid and unbendable in their intent and requirements of the prosecution of these laws.
It looks to me that there was a serious lack of situationlal awareness on both sides which in effect places "blame" on both sides of the fence. This situation could have easily been averted by th "burdened?" vessel siginaling her intentions by either presenting her stern or bow in order to prevent the sitiuation that resulted. This manuver would have changed the entire encounter.
BTW. As far as my experience is concerned. I have none. I am currently on my 9th issue of a federal merchant mariners crediental and claim no further expertise or experience on the subject at hand.
That being said, it is general operating procedure on my vessel to start tracking larger vessels (100 meters or more) at a minimum range of 10 n/m and smaller vessels at a range when they are 1st detected until I am sure they are out of any close quarters situations. This means a lot of times I go out of my way to avoid situations whether I have the right of way or not. Other times this is not possible and I do press the issue if I am in the right. I do not mean to "offend" anyone on this post, but, feel it is my duty to present my views on the presentaions of this incident.
If anyone on this post feels it is necessary to contact me about this, my contact info is hltg1@yahoo.com or at my office @ 252-726-5479. I will be glad to talk about this anytime. 🙂
Like it or not, Carolinaprincess is right.
There is also an unwritten "courtious" rule, I wish more would follow.
I don't fish AR's or in crouds for this very reason.
It's a big ocean out there.
I hope he doesn't fish the river channel in the US open this year.
We lost a nice fish in the open a few years ago due to lack of courteousness from someone in a large boston whaler, we hailed and waved to no avail. He was absolutely clue less.
"I was pulling one of South Chatham Tackle's high speed lures" ....
Not for nothing, but some people may not be aware of high speed lures. Too bad he didn't cross in front of you so he wouldn't have had to make that apparent course correction. It would also be nice if there was a corresponding flag that let others know not to cross your stern (during high speed trolling).
WE were trolling at about 12 knots, and we started waving at him when it was apparent he wasn't paying attention. He was at least a half mile from us when we started waving at him, three of us waving hats and I slowed to idle giving him plenty of time to cross in frt of us and he altered his course to go behind us and like I said earlier, he crossed less than 50 ft behind our boat. Anyway its done and over and in my opinion he is still a idiot.
you will never win the argument, it's just how it is around here, someone always has the answer, the final word, almost as if to prove you wrong is the goal...... I dont care what reg, rule of the road or what credentials you throw around ....it was wrong and not a good move..I have seen it many times by so called pros, 'great captains' bla bla...
Any 'good Capt' will identify a spread and a boat trolling, then procede to deviate course out of respect and common courtesy, at least thats how I was taught....
I'm with you, it was completely not warranted.
Peace.
Once again,the uptight know it alls are at it again.this is two fishing vessels in a common sense situation.pass within 50 ft. of my stern in this bigass ocean?dumbass...'WAKE UP"!this falls simply in the common sense rule.plain ole not paying attention I would think.Anyhow break out your merchant mariners handbooks.etc..But you still just can't fix stoopid!
you will never win the argument, it's just how it is around here, someone always has the answer, the final word, almost as if to prove you wrong is the goal...... I dont care what reg, rule of the road or what credentials you throw around ....it was wrong and not a good move..I have seen it many times by so called pros, 'great captains' bla bla...
Any 'good Capt' will identify a spread and a boat trolling, then procede to deviate course out of respect and common courtesy, at least thats how I was taught....
I'm with you, it was completely not warranted.
Peace.
Amen
I will have to disagree here. There are MANY people on the water that are not fishing or involve in any type of fishing. They simply do not think that way. He was moving at 12 knots....the other vessal very well could of thought he gave him plenty of room.
Hell I damn near got tee-boned by a sail boat last week....it happens.
I think CP's role here was to simple explain the rules as written and I commend him for it.
To say it was wrong and not a good move is short sighted. Do I agree with it? No not really but I do not agree with how both vessels reacted because they did not conform to the rules of the road.
Love them or hate them...the rules are the rules and every Captain should make an effort to understand them.
Dave
Not for nuthin' , but if memory serves correctly, this is how it goes. In the absence of any communication (5 blasts is probably appropriate here) the stand on vessel has an obligation to hold course and speed unless there is an imminent risk of collision.
I will have to disagree here. There are MANY people on the water that are not fishing or involve in any type of fishing. They simply do not think that way. He was moving at 12 knots....the other vessal very well could of thought he gave him plenty of room.
Dave, do you call less than 50 ft plenty of room in a wide open ocean ?? You seem to miss the point, I WAS FISHING, he was running up on plane. You mean to tell me when a boat is trolling at the BIg Roack for example, its ok for a boat to pass less than 50 ft from the stern ?? We were not at the Big Rk but in essence thats exactly what happened. Man you guys kill me, you turn a incident that I did everyhing I could short of pulling in the lines to avoid this guy and he almost runs over us and its my fault. Some of you beat all.
"When two power-driven vessels are crossing, the vessel which has the other on the starboard side must give way and avoid crossing ahead of her"
You were the "Burderned" vessal. It was your role to get out of HIS way. Not the other way around.
Fishing or not fishing it does not matter.
I am not the one making a big deal out of it. We are simply trying to enlighten everyone as to what the rules say about this situation. Nothing more or less.
Dave
Hey, I'm on your side, that guy had no business cutting behind you either close or far.