SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Someone please explain something to me! I anchored up and fished on my first ship wreck for first time this past weekend. I had the family out who just wanted to fight some fish. I got anchored up over the Raritian and the fish finder lite up! Everyone had a blast catching and reeling in big barracuda and big false albacore. My question is why could i not get a single amberjack to hit. I could see them below the boat when I would reel a fish up. I through everything at them from top water lures, live and dead pogies and dead cigar minnows. I tried jigging too and nothing. what do i need to do. Everyone says they cant keep them off their lines out there. I caught everything but them all day.
Not that I target amberjacks but I have seen them finicky before. What worked best was a single hook on a live pogie with no artificial lure. Just the hook and pogie freelined behind the boat. Wouldn't hit anything else.
I tried that the most. I kept a few flat lines up top out the back on a plain hook rig and I even dropped a live pogie to the bottom. every time it would come up being a bonito or barracuda. I could was about to try to just gaff one when reeling in another fish because they were coming up so close to the boat lol
Make sure that you have someone videoing that.
Did you try chumming them up with some cut bait? .....ICM
What were you jigging with, and what were you topwater fishing with? I've never seen them that I couldn't catch with a knife jig or big saltwater popper. Just have to get them fired up. Create a commotion at the surface.
Sometimes I think they just won't bite. I know my friends that charter and does this pretty regularly throw several non hooked pogies over to get them fired up then go with the hooks.
The best advice I can give you is get on the boat of someone Kingfishing. Especially one that is tournament fishing. I can guarantee you if there's one around you will catch him.
I was was jigging Wilmington speed jigs and yo-zuri poppers. I through dead cigar minnows everywhere and about 50 live pogies out. I didnt throw any cut bait. And believe it or not it was the one time I forgot my dang go pro! I was a bit pissed. I wasnt sure what else to try. The ONLY thing I didnt try was to use a sabiki rig and try to catch some live cigars. They were hitting everywhere on the surface around us. I had plenty of activity around the boat. You guys think I should have cut up one of the many false albys I caught? Once the kings hit the Horseshoe area Ill probably make a stop there again to try to get them suckers going.
Without being there I can't say for sure, but IME, the more commotion you can kick up the more likely your chances of firing them up. Work that popper hard and violently so it really kicks up a fuss, and same goes for the jig.
My favorite is to take the hooks off a popper and play with them that way.
They were the ones playing with me lol
I wont normally target them either but when I get some family members down who just want to fight some fish. Amberjacks are what they are gonna get lol luckily the big false albacore and barracudas were in a frenzy. Now that I think about it...... the amberjacks may not of been able to get to my pogies because as soon as id put a flat line with live pogie out the back it would get hit by the false albys or barracudas. maybe i dont know honestly.