SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
What is the deal with all the Barracudas in the last four trips offshore we’ve caught at least 80? They are everywhere you can’t get away from them. anyone else having the same problem? I’ve been told that some people eat the small one’s and don’t worry about ciguatera poisonings.
I see people cleaning them all the time at the marina.
i've eaten two in my life. One small one caught in the inlet in Florida near Pompano beach. it swallowed a spoon with a treble hook and was unlikely to survive. Another smallish one in aruba just to try it.
The one in FL was because he was tiny, inshore and gonna die so I figured limited risk of ciguatera and hate throwing back a dead fish.
The one in Aruba was just to try it out because the locals seemed to eat it.
Honestly - I think you're probably fine here in NC, but it's just not really that good of meat. I found it to be too easy to dry out. Maybe if you deep fried it? But I'd just throw them back. They're a pain sometimes on the wrecks, but they're just like us...they gotta eat. Send 'em back and let 'em live.
Warm water = 'cudas.
Eating them is not usually a problem, although I think most folks recommend eating the smaller ones. I think it tastes fine, but like a lot of folks, I've been pretty intimidated by the ciguaterra risk.. minimal as it may be.
We went out of Charleston on 7/11 and caught at least 20 'cudas. The first few were fun, the rest were annoying.
They show up thick when the water gets hot, no doubt.
We ate them a lot when I was a kid in Puerto Rico, and here in NC too. They're really tasty fish. Never had problems, but now that I'm a bit older and I know someone who's been through ciguaterra (from reef fish in the Bahamas, not from barracuda), I'm a little gunshy about eating them and generally toss them back. Probably silly of me, but there are so many other tasty fish out there, I don't see the point in messing with it.
I know! From what I hear they are delicious but is the risk worth the reward.......I don't think so! I hear that disease will mess you up in a terrible kind of way
Okay! I must be a "fish snob", I fish a lot and we eat so much fish, my wife says we are fishaterians. This is NC, we have an abundance of trigger fish, mahi, tuna, beeliners, wahoo, etc. I can not think of any reason to eat any fish that is known to cause ciguatera. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ciguatera_fish_poisoning
fishaterians???? I like that
So cooking to certain temp doesn't get rid of the threat? I'm not interested in eating them, just curious about temp/cook
nope. Cooking does not cause it to break down (which kinda surprises me because it's a long chain of cyclical subunits), but no - cooking it doesn't save you.
It's a chemical produced by (I think) dinoflagellates on the reef, and then it bio-accumulates in predators. It's not a bacteria or a virus - just a chemical produced by micro-organisms.
Basically - it's like mercury in big tuna and swordfish. The little fish absorb it. The medium fish eat the little fish and it collects. The big fish eat the medium fish and it collects. No amount of cooking will get rid of it.
Nope, not taking the chance.
we live baitfished the atlas tanker sunday morning and the cudas were thick,you think you have a smoker on then mr. cuda skies out of the water they can haul ass.
Isn't everyone aware that all of the predatory fish that consume reef species of fish can get the same poisoning? Grouper are among some of the best eating fish and they can have it. I personally really like the meat of a small cuda and compare it to a Black Grouper. Nothing under 10lbs gets throwed back. It takes a long time for them to collect enough in their meat to be harmful to humans with a small portion of meat every now and then. It's like the PCBs that are in our lakes and streams … I can't eat an older / large catfish from a local lake due to the high levels in them. I can eat a smaller 2-10lb one and not have to worry about it.
If you are eating fish all the time whether it be a grouper or cuda, you have a higher chance of the poison building up in your system over time and causing issues.
