SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

Barracuda

32 Posts
20 Users
0 Reactions
1,609 Views
Alan Birch
(@onthefly)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 139
Topic starter  

copied from my post offshore 25th CBI, I think there needs to be a Barracuda fishing tournament. Two categories largest and the most total weight. Keep it simple. Only problem would be what would you do with all the fish. The tree huggers would have a cow over killing the Barracudas just for a fishing tournament. My Bad



   
ReplyQuote
Bill Royster
(@woofer)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 246
 

Fish Fry!! they are delicious



   
ReplyQuote
Bilzo
(@bilzo)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 2620
 

I too would think it senseless to kill a bunch of fish for no reason. Call me a tree hugger if you will. Life is precious. Don't kill what you can't use. Save some for the next guy.



   
ReplyQuote
Jessica Jung
(@)
Active Member
Joined: 6 years ago
Posts: 3
 

They are delicious. I love them as deep fry.



   
ReplyQuote
(@capt_dave)
Member Admin Registered
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 12511
 

I eat them from around here.....white meat and tasty



   
ReplyQuote
Nathan
(@ntbrinkl)
Reputable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 216
 

So the article brought up other reef fish and specifically grouper. Why is it people have no problem eating grouper? In this area is it just not found in them as much or something?



   
ReplyQuote
Bilzo
(@bilzo)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 2620
 

It's generally not as prevalent in them (and for what it's worth - it's really not that prevalent in the cudas up here either I don't think).

But - it CAN happen in any predatory reef fish. Just - some are more prone than others. As somebody else said, I think the black groupers are kinda bad too, but they're not terribly common.

And FWIW - Groupers are dang tasty, so I'm willing to roll the dice with them.

From the NCDHHS website: "Some fish commonly associated with ciguatera toxins include snapper, jacks, sea bass, grouper, triggerfish and barracuda. These large fish accumulate the toxins when they eat smaller fish that have been eating the toxic algae."

If you do a little google searching there's a 2007 incident where some folks were eating AJ and evidence appears to show it got passed to another as an STD.



   
ReplyQuote
drksuh
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 128
 

I don't play a physician on television. I am a physician. Barracudas can and do carry Ciguatera toxin in the Carolinas. It is true that larger ones are more likely to have Ciguatera toxin, but smaller ones can as well. The North Carolina Medical Journal once detailed a case report where a dinner party of a Carolina coastal fisherman served various kinds of fish and several attendees came down with Ciguatera poisoning. The ones who ate Barracuda were the only ones who became ill.

Ciguatera poisoning can cause a severe headache, due to swelling in the brain. It causes reverse temperature sensitivity oftentimes, in that cold objects appear to the toxic person to be hot, and hot objects appear to be cold. I don't want my brain to swell and suffer neurologic damage because I ate a piece of fish when there are dozens of other fish types which are not likely to cause Ciguatera. By the way, the treatment for Ciguatera poisoning for those who still choose to eat Barracuda is likely not known by your local physician, but Intravenous Mannitol is recommended to decrease Cerebral Edema (Brain Swelling) and was used with success in the Marshall Islands. I personally recommend that no one eat Barracuda of any size.



   
ReplyQuote
Stephen
(@chaos)
Estimable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 120
 

copied from my post offshore 25th CBI, I think there needs to be a Barracuda fishing tournament. Two categories largest and the most total weight. Keep it simple. Only problem would be what would you do with all the fish. The tree huggers would have a cow over killing the Barracudas just for a fishing tournament. My Bad

Give them to the local crabbers for bait!



   
ReplyQuote
Dave Arnold
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 842
 

I don't play a physician on television. I am a physician. Barracudas can and do carry Ciguatera toxin in the Carolinas. It is true that larger ones are more likely to have Ciguatera toxin, but smaller ones can as well. The North Carolina Medical Journal once detailed a case report where a dinner party of a Carolina coastal fisherman served various kinds of fish and several attendees came down with Ciguatera poisoning. The ones who ate Barracuda were the only ones who became ill.

Ciguatera poisoning can cause a severe headache, due to swelling in the brain. It causes reverse temperature sensitivity oftentimes, in that cold objects appear to the toxic person to be hot, and hot objects appear to be cold. I don't want my brain to swell and suffer neurologic damage because I ate a piece of fish when there are dozens of other fish types which are not likely to cause Ciguatera. By the way, the treatment for Ciguatera poisoning for those who still choose to eat Barracuda is likely not known by your local physician, but Intravenous Mannitol is recommended to decrease Cerebral Edema (Brain Swelling) and was used with success in the Marshall Islands. I personally recommend that no one eat Barracuda of any size.

Thank you very much, Dr.



   
ReplyQuote
(@capt_dave)
Member Admin Registered
Joined: 3 years ago
Posts: 12511
 

drksuh,

I would like to read that. Can you link me to it or give a date and publication name so I can can look it up?

Dave



   
ReplyQuote
David Plowden
(@mealonreels)
Prominent Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 652
 

"If it weighs it pays". Not much though in the case of 'Cuda...$1.10 back to the boat.A fish dealer once said " if a turd had scales,somebody would eat it".



   
ReplyQuote
Jeff Thomas
(@paynefish)
Honorable Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 669
 

"If it weighs it pays". Not much though in the case of 'Cuda...$1.10 back to the boat.A fish dealer once said " if a turd had scales,somebody would eat it".

:lmao:



   
ReplyQuote
Bilzo
(@bilzo)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 2620
 

Dave - the online version of that (North Carolina Medical Journal) only goes back to 2014. Might take a while to find it in hard copies or unsearchable format.



   
ReplyQuote
drksuh
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 128
 

Capt. Dave, I do not have a copy of that article anymore but have the information stored in the hard drive of my brain. LOL.

I did find an abstract from the Southern Medical Journal which talks about a seafood meal from North Carolina and locally caught fish including Barracuda, Dolphin, and Yellowfin Tuna which resulted in several getting Ciguatera toxin. This may be a restating of the article from the North Carolina Medical Journal. I can tell you that Dolphin was a very unlikely culprit to Ciguatera since dolphin fish rarely live more than five to six years and would not live long enough to have the toxin build up in their flesh. Obviously, barracuda is the prime suspect in these North Carolina caught fish.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2321066/

Here is another case report of a couple who ate barracuda caught in South Carolina who ingested Ciguatera toxin and became symptomatic.
https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/203538

Many people also cited painful intercourse as a symptom of Ciguatera toxin which may cause concern for many of the fish eating members of this forum.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 3
Share: