SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Caught this in about 100' of water out of Southport. I've seen something calling it a lightening or yellow cheek wrasse, but searching the interwebs shows me much smaller fish that look significantly different. I filleted it, and the meat is bluish green as well. Anyone know what it is, and whether it's edible?
I've caught a few of these also. Not sure what it is but it might be a razorfish. Crazy blue meat.
It's certainly a wrasse, and my googling says the yellow cheek wrasse can get almost a foot long (perhaps you were looking at salt-water aquarium sites?).
Here's the link I looked it up on: https://ncfishes.com/marine-fishes-of-north-carolina/halichoeres-cyanocephalus/ (which by the way - is a great site to go look for stuff, because generally, if it's in NC and you're not the first one to catch it, it's on that list somewhere, and you knew enough to know it was a wrasse, so that narrows down the hunting).
Anyway - it didn't cite any similar species, so I think that's it. Also - remember - a mahimahi can look beautifully blue/green in the water and then is that drab yellow once it's dead. Fish pigmentation often changes slightly after death or removal from water, and what i'm seeing is consistent with patterns of what you got. Also with wrasses, males/females can have different coloration (see stoplight parrotfish) or juveniles can look different too.
As for eating it...Umm...I know that in Hawaii some wrasses are avoided for ciguatera poisoning concern. But here in NC, some wrasses are eaten and targeted (Hogfish, sand tilefish), so take a shot if you want. But honestly - my approach when I catch something that I don't know what it is - is to get a picture, throw it back, and then see what it is so I know whether or not to keep it in the future. I'm not too worried about throwing back the best ever tasting fish in the world. I figure if I don't know what it is, odds are there aren't too many of 'em down there and better to send 'em back rather than keep something that I'm going to throw away. That's not me criticizing you keeping it - you were totally within your legal right to do so and getting dinner is one of the reasons we go fish.
If you do eat it - please share what you think. Blue flesh sounds a little off, but I know that the lingcod they get in the pacific have green flesh and people love them.
Wrasse for sure. Have caught quite a few of them this year.
Thanks for the thoughtful reply Bilzo. Apparently my Google skills are lacking, because all the varied searches really only got me to aquarium listings. I have that ncfishes site saved for future reference. Thank you!
Your reference to mahi losing their color reminded me that I thought I had a mahi as it got close to the surface. I saw that yellow/blue/green and thought, "Did I really just catch a mahi bottom fishing?" That was a split second thought before I pulled it out of the water. Also to your reference, the wrasse did not lose much color at all between being caught and fileted. I suspect that thick layer of slime - they are slippery.
Some years back, I threw something back that turned out to be a great eating fish. I forget now what it was, but it changed my attitude. This may change it again.... Just need to fish more so I don't feel like I'm throwing back a dinner-
As to eating the fish, I'm going to be throwing these back in the future. The meat was very light tasting, but the texture was somewhat sponge-like, and it was still light green after cooking. I had a small amount just in case, but I haven't felt sick/uncomfortable and it's been 12 hours. My .02.
Now, on the other hand, I did see that specimens over 4-6 inches go for several hundred per some of those aquarium sites.
Don't know what it is, but it is a pretty fish. I have caught one of these before that was about 6" long, but I threw it back and didn't eat it.
oh well. sorry it was a dud of a meal. But maybe you're on to something with sneaking one to an aquarium retailer in the future!