SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I started a new post for some who may not read all the way to the bottom. It is key we get everyone we know to participate in sending input.
Guys, I had a good conversation with Myra on the phone yesterday. She made it clear they have no data on our area and this closure is reactionary to their lack of understanding of the data they do have. The fact they closed the season sucks but it has nothing to do with amendment 37. She said they value our input so we need to give it to them.
She asked you to include your suggestions on management of our fishery. I for one wouldn't mind giving them a closure to coincide with grouper. I hate cold water anyhow. 3 or 4 fish per person is fine by me and so is an 18 inch fork length. I also think more action has to be taken against commercial diving operations that utilize bigger boats and onboard compressors (the floridians) allowing multi day trips. I believe these commercial boats in their growing numbers are the biggest threat to our local hogfish habitat.
Her email outlining the facts or lack there of:
Beck,
It was a pleasure chatting with you on the phone this afternoon. I will make sure that the Council is aware of your concerns when they discuss hogfish at their upcoming meeting in Hilton Head, SC (September 14-18).
So, to clarify why recreational hogfish harvest is currently closed: the recreational ACL for hogfish is currently 85,355 pounds (whole weight). This is the amount allowed to be landed recreationally for the entire South Atlantic region (Carolinas, GA and east Florida). As of April of this year (waves 1 and 2 of the Marine Recreational Information Program), recreational landings of hogfish were 227,719 pounds, that’s 167% over the allowed amount. For comparison, 2014 recreational landings of hogfish for the whole year were 111,803 pounds. There was still an overage of 31%, but that was for the whole year. So, this year, the National Marine Fisheries Service had to close recreational harvest of hogfish for the year because the landings have been so high (and we don’t even know how much has been landed since April!).
The current closure is not tied to development of Amendment 37, however. The Council is preparing Amendment 37 in response to a stock assessment that was recently done on hogfish. Also, there was research done in 2014 that shows two genetically-different stocks of hogfish: one off the Carolinas and Georgia and the other one off East Florida and the Keys. So, the amendment would officially split the hogfish stock into two units that would be managed separately with their own catch limits and commercial and recreational management measures (trip limits, bag limits, etc). The problem is that the stock assessment was not deemed to be useful for managing the GA-NC stock so the catch limits have to be set based on landings history. For the stock off Florida, the assessment determined the stock is overfished and undergoing overfishing so the Council is mandated to put in a rebuilding plan for that stock.
Clearly there are access issues in this fishery: if the entire recreational ACL for 2015 was landed by April, then most of those landings likely come from Florida, not the Carolinas. This is one of the issues the Council struggles with: how to provide equal access to fishermen across the region. But once the hogfish stock is split, then the Council will have a better chance to address the access problem since they could put in place a recreational season that makes sense for that area and different size and bag limits off Georgia and the Carolinas. So, if you and your fellow fishermen have some suggestions for the Council regarding management measures, by all means send them in!
The issue you mentioned about Florida boats harvesting hogfish off the Carolinas is of concern and I will make sure the Council is aware of it. I also happen to help the Council with law enforcement issues so I will talk to my law enforcement contacts as well.
Thank you again for your input and your willingness to be involved in the fishery management process. Please feel free to call/email anytime!
Best,
Myra
Myra Brouwer
Fishery Scientist
South Atlantic Fishery Management Council
4055 Faber Place Drive; Ste 201
Charleston, SC 29405
(843) 571-4366
www.safmc.net
Thank you for taking the time to contact SAFMC. We will need all the help we can get.
I respectfully request that you reconsider the suggestion of a seasonal closure and 18 inch fl limit.
There is no science, data, proof, etc. That a seasonal closure would benefit Hogfish in any way. Just because you don't like diving in cold water does not mean the fishery should shut down 4 months. Any seasonal closure is not wise. A closure that coincides with the grouper closure would royally screw your brethren that enjoy jigging for Hogfish in the winter. No grouper, no hogs, wtf else do you suggest taking away? Putting these arbitrary ideas in their minds is counterproductive. Hogfish off NC and SC spawn in June. Further proof that a winter closure is a bad idea.
An 18 inch fl limit would destroy your opportunity to harvest hogs. Have you read the hogfish sedar? If an 18 limit goes through, it is estimated that alot of the annual acl (once established) will go to discarded fish (SAMFC claims jnearly as many hogs caught on hook and line as speared). Do you want such a substantial reduction before a hook has been wet or a dive has been made?
The best option for all of us - no change until an adequate stock assessment has been completed for the GA-NC population.
Amendment 37 has alternatives for a commercial trip limit. According to the hogfish sedar nearly 80% of all hogfish targeted commercial trips were less than 250lbs. The writing is on the wall for this action.
I didn't include in that post but did recommend any changes be based on an accurate stock assessment. That's the most crucial part of the equation and judging by their flunked up FL data I'm not sure it will ever be a reality. He'll, half the fish in NC don't officially range here if you look them up. I think our stock is healthy and I told them that. Interesting point on the 18 inch fork if what you say is really the case. I just know I rarely have ever shot smaller ones personally. My input was just an individual opinion. Personally I don't care about going out before grouper opens. I'll catch wahoo. They did ask for alternatives if they make changes so I gave them a few I could live with. I think it's important as many people as possible give their individual input at this point. By in large it will paint a picture that they have no knowledge of what goes on up here. I think you should call Myra and talk to her as well. I may try and meet with one of the board appointees in the near future. I think the future of our lifestyle lies with us organizing some and working with these people to insure our kids get to live it up like we do now.
Beck
What's the best way to contact Myra, by the phone number above?
Myra Brouwer
Fishery Biologist
myra.brouwer@safmc.net
(843) 571-4366
She has been very good about responding to email as well.