SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Divers - Please contact SAFMC, state representative, senator, etc. This closure is a result of bad data. SAFMC claims that recs harvested 224,566 lbs in March and April. To give perspective on how bad this data is. 2012, 2013, and 2014 combined for 280,490 lbs total. Yet they claim nearly 225k lbs in two months?
This is the start of more asinine regulations coming down the pipe and the fictitous data sets used to make it happen. Speak up or loose your right to spear hogfish.
Seriously? How did we go from no limits, to 5 per person, to nothing in a 3 year period. Asinine, YES.
This SUCKS!
One last chance for the year this weekend.
Time for a Hog slaughter! 🙂
need an extra hand?
I was looking at the fish regs for something else but noticed they say Hogfish are closed as of today. Am I seeing this the right way?
http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/mf/recreational-fishing-size-and-bag-limits.
The proclamation is effective 12:01am on 8/24
http://portal.ncdenr.org/web/mf/proclamation-ff-43-2015
how about that guy's, is the boat out of Florida still up here commercial diving the hogfish, guess it will not be so crowded now.
Is Hogfish still open to commercial harvest? I'm pretty pissed and bummed as it is but if the commercial boats that are the biggest impact are still at it thats just ridiculous!
Yep. Commercial season still open
Agree with HogWild26, absolute insanity. Dr. Louis B. Daniel III, Director, Division of Marine Fisheries, Is a complete idiot to think recreational fisherman are doing the damage and letting the commercial guys continue to fish.
Some homework may need to be done before attacking the commercial sector.
Also this is a South East Atlantic Fishery not managed by the State.
Commercial ACL is 49.469lbs with 20.011lbs landed so far this year. That fish is not much targeted by hook and line boats.
If you divide that quota by the number of Snapper Grouper permits that would be less than 80 lbs per boat per year...
Recreational ACL 85.355 lbs with estimated landings of 227.719 lbs.
Many more boats target this species these days from NC to Key West and it easy to understand how that number can be reached!
Nicely done Marlin.
I looked at past years catch and Rec was over or close.
Comms never got near quota. Not many comm boats target Hogs unless divers on board, even then it is considered a bonus. Unless they are in Fl or the Gulf. I think it's BS how the SAFMC closed it without much warning but they also closed Dolphin on comm's the same way(both have not been before). I think Ring Tails will be next.
there have been florida boats up here in the winter and they were targeting our hogfish, that's when NC made a weak attempt to limit them how may pounds they could off load at a time, comical really, the boats just went above and below us to offload and kep rolling on, one of the boats may have been called Rolling Thunder, someone will remember it, the only way to manage a species is it is either open or it is closed, period, for everybody.
Some homework may need to be done before attacking the commercial sector.
Also this is a South East Atlantic Fishery not managed by the State.Commercial ACL is 49.469lbs with 20.011lbs landed so far this year. That fish is not much targeted by hook and line boats.
If you divide that quota by the number of Snapper Grouper permits that would be less than 80 lbs per boat per year...Recreational ACL 85.355 lbs with estimated landings of 227.719 lbs.
Many more boats target this species these days from NC to Key West and it easy to understand how that number can be reached!
And some may need to complete their homework......
In 2015, the REC ACL was nearly tripled in a single two month monitoring period. March and April, the MRIP estimated 224,566 lbs. This info was clearly spelled out in the orginal post above. January and February Rec harvest was 3,153 lbs. NMFS MRIP survey data went into a model that resulted in an increase of 7022% to 224,566 the next month? Utterly ridiculous.
Yet you seem to understand how rec hogfish number could be reached.
The rec harvest numbers on hogfish from May, April, June, and July have not been released yet as of this morning.
http://sero.nmfs.noaa.gov/sustainable_fisheries/acl_monitoring/recreational_sa/index.html
2014 Had the exact same scenario when NMFS MRIP survey went into some kind of model that says rec hogfish harvest in the south atlantic was 83,458 lbs for January and February alone. That was nearly the entire ACL in the two months of the year that recieves the least amount of REC participation. Especially considering the grouper closure. For reference, the same March/April time frame above that was estimated at 224,566 lbs in 2015 was only 632 lbs in 2014. A 35,432% ESTIMATED increase during the same time frame from year to year.
Yet you seem to understand how rec hogfish number could be reached.
The MRIP ESTIMATES that recs accounted for 227,719 lbs of hogfish during the first four months of 2015. As of 8/25/15, there have been 180,323 lbs of commercially caught gag grouper in the same managed area.
Yet you seem to understand how the rec hogfish number could be reached.
MM2 - The SAFMC has proposed under Amendment 37, Action 4, Alternative 2 - Set the commercial hogfish ACL to +/- 21,000lbs. The currently ACL is 49,469lbs. This proposed action to cut the hogfish ACL by nearly 60% (without a valid stock assessment) would be devastating to your commercial fishing commrades in NC, SC, and GA along with the dive boats, etc. Please contact the SAFMC and request that NO ACTION take place until legitimate stock assessments are conducted.
Here is the link to some proposed actions of Amendment 37:
Here are a list of email addresses to send letters in opposition:
joshua.bowlen@mail.house.gov (joshua.bowlen@mail.house.gov); joe_nolan@tillis.senate.gov (joe_nolan@tillis.senate.gov); wills_denton@burr.senate.gov (wills_denton@burr.senate.gov); SAFMC (safmc@safmc.net); Amber Vonharten (Amber.Vonharten@safmc.net); Mike Collins (mike.collins@safmc.net); Kim Iverson (Kim.Iverson@safmc.net)
NC SAFMC members;
Anna Beckwith
1907 Paulette Road
Morehead City, NC 28557
252-671-3474 phone
AnnaBarriosBeckwith@gmail.com
Dr. Michelle Duval
N.C. Division of Marine Fisheries
P.O. Box 769
Morehead City, NC 28557
252-808-8011 phone
252-726-0254 fax
michelle.duval@ncdenr.gov
Jack Cox
(At-Large Seat)
2010 Bridges Street
Morehead City, NC 28557
252-728-9548
Dayboat1965@gmail.com
EMAIL CALL Be Heard!