SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
there have been florida boats up here in the winter and they were targeting our hogfish, that's when NC made a weak attempt to limit them how may pounds they could off load at a time, comical really, the boats just went above and below us to offload and kep rolling on, one of the boats may have been called Rolling Thunder, someone will remember it, the only way to manage a species is it is either open or it is closed, period, for everybody.
Yep. On Tuesday August 17, 2010, NCDMF issued a proclamation limiting hogfish harvest in NC for both REC and COMM. This action was a direct result of the Florida commercial dive boats impact on hogfish population. I have the meeting minutes of SAFMC and NC DMF member/s attesting to the fact.
http://fryingpantower.com/ftopict-19523-.html
there have been florida boats up here in the winter and they were targeting our hogfish, that's when NC made a weak attempt to limit them how may pounds they could off load at a time, comical really, the boats just went above and below us to offload and kep rolling on, one of the boats may have been called Rolling Thunder, someone will remember it, the only way to manage a species is it is either open or it is closed, period, for everybody.
What about increasing the size limit? I would have been fine with 16", 18" or larger -- something that would still let us take a stud hogfish or two.
I won't argue that there are fewer hogs out there off NC that a few years ago, but there are still plenty. Far, far more of them than red snappers.
there have been florida boats up here in the winter and they were targeting our hogfish, that's when NC made a weak attempt to limit them how may pounds they could off load at a time, comical really, the boats just went above and below us to offload and kep rolling on, one of the boats may have been called Rolling Thunder, someone will remember it, the only way to manage a species is it is either open or it is closed, period, for everybody.
What about increasing the size limit? I would have been fine with 16", 18" or larger -- something that would still let us take a stud hogfish or two.
I won't argue that there are fewer hogs out there off NC that a few years ago, but there are still plenty. Far, far more of them than red snappers.
The proposed Amendment 37 would split the hogfish stock in two. Creating a Florida, Florida Keys stock (FLK/EFL) and a Georgia to North Carolina stock (GA-NC). Under this Amendment, Action 8 Alternative 2 has proposed increased length limits of hogs. Here are the proposed length limits in fork length:
2a. 13 inches
2b. 14 inches
2c. 15 inches
2d. 16 inches
2e. 17 inches
2f. 18 inches
2g. 19 inches
2h. 20 inches
2i. Increase the minimum size limit from 12” to X” in year 1, to Y” in year
2, and to Z” in year 3. Council to specify X, Y, and Z.
SC and Ga currently do not have regulations on length nor creel. NC has a 12 inch 5 fish limit.
Increasing the length limit from 12 to 16 inches in FLK/EFL population would cut harvest by nearly half according to hogfish SEDAR. Ga-NC hogfish....... Don't have an assessment and regulations would be made up as they go.
there have been florida boats up here in the winter and they were targeting our hogfish, that's when NC made a weak attempt to limit them how may pounds they could off load at a time, comical really, the boats just went above and below us to offload and kep rolling on, one of the boats may have been called Rolling Thunder, someone will remember it, the only way to manage a species is it is either open or it is closed, period, for everybody.
Yep. On Tuesday August 17, 2010, NCDMF issued a proclamation limiting hogfish harvest in NC for both REC and COMM. This action was a direct result of the Florida commercial dive boats impact on hogfish population. I have the meeting minutes of SAFMC and NC DMF member/s attesting to the fact.
http://fryingpantower.com/ftopict-19523-.html
I seem to remember a little about that, but wasn't it just a trip limit if landing them in NC, 2010 was a long time ago.
there have been florida boats up here in the winter and they were targeting our hogfish, that's when NC made a weak attempt to limit them how may pounds they could off load at a time, comical really, the boats just went above and below us to offload and kep rolling on, one of the boats may have been called Rolling Thunder, someone will remember it, the only way to manage a species is it is either open or it is closed, period, for everybody.
Yep. On Tuesday August 17, 2010, NCDMF issued a proclamation limiting hogfish harvest in NC for both REC and COMM. This action was a direct result of the Florida commercial dive boats impact on hogfish population. I have the meeting minutes of SAFMC and NC DMF member/s attesting to the fact.
http://fryingpantower.com/ftopict-19523-.html
I seem to remember a little about that, but wasn't it just a trip limit if landing them in NC, 2010 was a long time ago.
You are correct. As a result of the August 17 2010 proclamation. DMF enacted a 12 inch 5 fish limit for recs and a 150 lb single day limit (plus 100lbs per day up to seven days) for commercial.
Whitelakebuc, I believe we have several friends in common so trust me I think we are on the same page...
I too have always wondered how estimates could be accurate on the rec landings.
My post was more regarding the fact that some folks automatically jump on the Commercial sector while both sectors are being hammered.
You bring up the gags and there too I love twitching numbers.
Here are a couple facts
There are 118 Snapper grouper 225 lbs permits and 556 unlimited S/G permits. So from NC to Key West 674 boats are allowed to sell their catch.
The gag quota is 326.722lbs. If every boat caught an equal "share" that would be 484 lbs for the year... A little hard to make a living on that!
The rec sector on the gags is 340.060lbs and how many boats target these?
Lets say if 5000 boats caught gags on the whole South East atlantic it would mean just 68 lbs per boat for the year.... Did these boats only fish once!?
We'll do our share of emails again to avoid this never ending reduction of quotas for both sectors which really don't seem to be justified.
We'll do our share of emails again to avoid this never ending reduction of quotas for both sectors which really don't seem to be justified.
Thank you
there have been florida boats up here in the winter and they were targeting our hogfish, that's when NC made a weak attempt to limit them how may pounds they could off load at a time, comical really, the boats just went above and below us to offload and kep rolling on, one of the boats may have been called Rolling Thunder, someone will remember it, the only way to manage a species is it is either open or it is closed, period, for everybody.
Yep. On Tuesday August 17, 2010, NCDMF issued a proclamation limiting hogfish harvest in NC for both REC and COMM. This action was a direct result of the Florida commercial dive boats impact on hogfish population. I have the meeting minutes of SAFMC and NC DMF member/s attesting to the fact.
http://fryingpantower.com/ftopict-19523-.html
I seem to remember a little about that, but wasn't it just a trip limit if landing them in NC, 2010 was a long time ago.
You are correct. As a result of the August 17 2010 proclamation. DMF enacted a 12 inch 5 fish limit for recs and a 150 lb single day limit (plus 100lbs per day up to seven days) for commercial.
so what is their trip limit if they land their fish on further down to the south, like sc or ga or fla?
there have been florida boats up here in the winter and they were targeting our hogfish, that's when NC made a weak attempt to limit them how may pounds they could off load at a time, comical really, the boats just went above and below us to offload and kep rolling on, one of the boats may have been called Rolling Thunder, someone will remember it, the only way to manage a species is it is either open or it is closed, period, for everybody.
Yep. On Tuesday August 17, 2010, NCDMF issued a proclamation limiting hogfish harvest in NC for both REC and COMM. This action was a direct result of the Florida commercial dive boats impact on hogfish population. I have the meeting minutes of SAFMC and NC DMF member/s attesting to the fact.
http://fryingpantower.com/ftopict-19523-.html
I seem to remember a little about that, but wasn't it just a trip limit if landing them in NC, 2010 was a long time ago.
You are correct. As a result of the August 17 2010 proclamation. DMF enacted a 12 inch 5 fish limit for recs and a 150 lb single day limit (plus 100lbs per day up to seven days) for commercial.
so what is their trip limit if they land their fish on further down to the south, like sc or ga or fla?
SC and GA nothing. No limits on length or trip limit. Fla is a bit different. Some of the counties in south Florida have their own regs. Some of those counties have outlawed spearfishing out to 3 miles. I am not educated enough on the FLK/EFL population to know what all their regs are. For recs, they have the same regs as NC.
Proposed actions in Amendment 37 would install a commercial trip limit for the GA-NC population.
Guys, I had a good conversation with Myra on the phone yesterday. She made it clear they have no data on our area and this closure is reactionary to their lack of understanding of the data they do have. The fact they closed the season sucks but it has nothing to do with amendment 37. She said they value our input so we need to give it to them. Here is her summary of what is going on:
She asked you to include your suggestions on management of our fishery. I for one wouldn't mind giving them a closure to coincide with grouper. I hate cold water anyhow. 3 or 4 fish per person is fine by me and so is an 18 inch fork length. I also think more action has to be taken against commercial diving operations that utilize bigger boats and onboard compressors (the floridians) allowing multi day trips. I believe these commercial boats in their growing numbers are the biggest threat to our local hogfish habitat.
Beck,
It was a pleasure chatting with you on the phone this afternoon. I will make sure that the Council is aware of your concerns when they discuss hogfish at their upcoming meeting in Hilton Head, SC (September 14-18).
So, to clarify why recreational hogfish harvest is currently closed: the recreational ACL for hogfish is currently 85,355 pounds (whole weight). This is the amount allowed to be landed recreationally for the entire South Atlantic region (Carolinas, GA and east Florida). As of April of this year (waves 1 and 2 of the Marine Recreational Information Program), recreational landings of hogfish were 227,719 pounds, that’s 167% over the allowed amount. For comparison, 2014 recreational landings of hogfish for the whole year were 111,803 pounds. There was still an overage of 31%, but that was for the whole year. So, this year, the National Marine Fisheries Service had to close recreational harvest of hogfish for the year because the landings have been so high (and we don’t even know how much has been landed since April!).
The current closure is not tied to development of Amendment 37, however. The Council is preparing Amendment 37 in response to a stock assessment that was recently done on hogfish. Also, there was research done in 2014 that shows two genetically-different stocks of hogfish: one off the Carolinas and Georgia and the other one off East Florida and the Keys. So, the amendment would officially split the hogfish stock into two units that would be managed separately with their own catch limits and commercial and recreational management measures (trip limits, bag limits, etc). The problem is that the stock assessment was not deemed to be useful for managing the GA-NC stock so the catch limits have to be set based on landings history. For the stock off Florida, the assessment determined the stock is overfished and undergoing overfishing so the Council is mandated to put in a rebuilding plan for that stock.
Clearly there are access issues in this fishery: if the entire recreational ACL for 2015 was landed by April, then most of those landings likely come from Florida, not the Carolinas. This is one of the issues the Council struggles with: how to provide equal access to fishermen across the region. But once the hogfish stock is split, then the Council will have a better chance to address the access problem since they could put in place a recreational season that makes sense for that area and different size and bag limits off Georgia and the Carolinas. So, if you and your fellow fishermen have some suggestions for the Council regarding management measures, by all means send them in!
The issue you mentioned about Florida boats harvesting hogfish off the Carolinas is of concern and I will make sure the Council is aware of it. I also happen to help the Council with law enforcement issues so I will talk to my law enforcement contacts as well.
Thank you again for your input and your willingness to be involved in the fishery management process. Please feel free to call/email anytime!
Best,
Myra
Myra Brouwer
Fishery Scientist
South Atlantic Fishery Management Council
4055 Faber Place Drive; Ste 201
Charleston, SC 29405
(843) 571-4366
www.safmc.net
Agree with HogWild26, absolute insanity. Dr. Louis B. Daniel III, Director, Division of Marine Fisheries, Is a complete idiot to think recreational fisherman are doing the damage and letting the commercial guys continue to fish.
They should stop fishing for rec and commercial fishing. I wonder where they get these numbers for rec fishing. I know none of you report how much you shot in a day. Do they just estimate?