SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

learned behavior of fish…(grouper)

31 Posts
17 Users
0 Reactions
2,521 Views
(@catfish)
Estimable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 126
 

Can we use j hooks in NC on the crab and squid decoys? I thought we had to use circle hooks when bottom fishing. And assuming that we can, what is your preference Tim? Thank you Tim for all your help not only on this thread but so many others as well.



   
ReplyQuote
Jason Dunkley
(@jdunk)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 413
 

All I will say is listen to Tim if you Want to catch Grouper. We caught over 10 keepers last year on several trips using his Crab Jigs (5 in one trip). You have to do your part as well and he has given everyone valuable Information in this thread... Get you some jigs and go slay some Grouper!



   
ReplyQuote
Andy
 Andy
(@ebbtideandy)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 655
 

As Tim and many of you already know, I'm a definite convert to all of the decoy jigs that Tim makes.

Tim makes a great point about learned behavior, and I have alluded to it in earlier posts.

One particular trip that I've written about before really highlights this aspect of this learned behavior.

I was fishing on the Shelf with Dave and we had 80 head on the boat that day. There were exactly 2 grouper caught, both by me, and both on decoy jigs, including my biggest red grouper ever, a 28 pounder!

Think about that. At any one time there were up to 160 baited hooks, some with cigar minnows, on the bottom, but the groupers sought out and were caught on the decoy jigs over all the others.

As for the bite, my experience has been that the grouper really pounce on them and there is no mistaking the grouper bite from the other fish just pecking at it. The ARS seem to pick it up and move it, not the hard pounce of the grouper, so it definitely feels different.



   
ReplyQuote
Tim Barefoot
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 942
Topic starter  

Can we use j hooks in NC on the crab and squid decoys? I thought we had to use circle hooks when bottom fishing. And assuming that we can, what is your preference Tim? Thank you Tim for all your help not only on this thread but so many others as well.

The law says that when you use live or dead bait, you must use circle hooks
J Hooks have a MUCH better hook-up ratio
I'll put it to you this way… I've never been questioned boat side about this, and even if I were, they would have a difficult case PROVING I had bait on the jig…"I'm just jigging my jig sir"
If it ever gets to the point where they are enforcing this , it's time to drum and bream fish.

Furthermore, the reason for this silly rule was that the offshore grouper/snapper complex would not be gut hooked using J hooks…BS

I'm not going to say "thousands", but the "many hundreds" of grouper, american reds and hogs we've caught on these J hooks were all lip hooked... except one gag and one big red Taylor caught
If I can find the photo of that gag, I'll post it
This one gag was mentally retarted…it swallowed the jig/bait combo, and broke my buddy off in the ledge. On the very next drop, I caught the gag. When I opened up his mouth to dig the jig out, I saw Barry's jig beside mine.
That was the ONLY gag I've ever gut hooked
This dumbazz gag needed to be removed from the gene pool… which I did.
I can name you more occasions when we've gut hooked grouper on offset circle hooks more than the j hooks

Catfish….Go fishing, catch 'em up!



   
ReplyQuote
Scott Armstrong
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 967
 

Tim,

I've had some really good days using the Decoy. I tend to document all my Gags..when, where and how caught. Right now I have 32 gags, including shorts, caught on a Decoy over the past few years. Not one has been gut hooked. Majority in the upper jaw. I believe this to be because of how the jig tends to rest on the sea floor. Hook sits upwards.

Thoughts?

Also, I've tried the squid decoy with minimal results. WTF am I doing wrong? I also have had very limited success in deeper water with the Scamps, Reds and Gag with the Crab Decoy.

Thoughts?



   
ReplyQuote
Jason Dunkley
(@jdunk)
Reputable Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 413
 

Tim,

I've had some really good days using the Decoy. I tend to document all my Gags..when, where and how caught. Right now I have 32 gags, including shorts, caught on a Decoy over the past few years. Not one has been gut hooked. Majority in the upper jaw. I believe this to be because of how the jig tends to rest on the sea floor. Hook sits upwards.

Thoughts?

Also, I've tried the squid decoy with minimal results. WTF am I doing wrong? I also have had very limited success in deeper water with the Scamps, Reds and Gag with the Crab Decoy.

Thoughts?

I too have experienced the same things RodeoV has.... everyone hooked with the big hook in the upper jaw on the Crab Decoy's, but also I have had very little sucess using the Squids... Im sure it's somthing Im doing but IDK what it could be, I am also yet to catch a RED or Scamp. Over 30 Gags easy on the Crab Decoys.



   
ReplyQuote
zigzag
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1863
 

so how do you order some jigs without going thru paypal?



   
ReplyQuote
steve brewer
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 1094
 

It is hard for me to use the crab decoys in deeper water. Seems like there is always enough current to miss your spot with the lightness of the decoy. Especially if you put a live decent size grunt or pinfish with it. Scamps do like it if you can get it down but I have more success using a knocker rig with cigar minnows on scamps. I would love to see the decoy in 6 and 8 ounces.



   
ReplyQuote
Josh Benton
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 841
 

Tex's tackle sells them



   
ReplyQuote
Tim Barefoot
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 942
Topic starter  

Tim,

I've had some really good days using the Decoy. I tend to document all my Gags..when, where and how caught. Right now I have 32 gags, including shorts, caught on a Decoy over the past few years. Not one has been gut hooked. Majority in the upper jaw. I believe this to be because of how the jig tends to rest on the sea floor. Hook sits upwards.

Thoughts?

Also, I've tried the squid decoy with minimal results. WTF am I doing wrong? I also have had very limited success in deeper water with the Scamps, Reds and Gag with the Crab Decoy.

Thoughts?

RODEOV
About the deepest I've fished the crab is 135ft. due to the "drift" as stack mentioned
I was out at the shop Sunday night "tinkering" and made a batch of 5 oz. crabs (for personal stash), but ask myself… why don't I make a 6 oz.
I'm tinkering with that idea and seeing if the hooks fit the mold, so I'l keep you posted
When I'm fishing the deeper water I fish the 7 or 11 oz. squid… see above post regarding hooks
Let it touch the bottom and reel it up a few feet.
If you feel the slightest "tick" on the line and it goes slack, SET THE HOOK!
Scamps, and yellowmouths typically bite it coming up, and the line goes slack
I missed quite a few bites at first, but quickly adjusted.
I can remember years ago (2001) we renamed May as NC Yellowmouth month. It was good to me in the deeper water.
Kinda like the first time I threw a mirrolure in the surf for speckled trout….
when you feel the "tick" set the hook

If you ever feel the slightest "tick" on the line,in the deeper water and the jig feels "light" set the hook



   
ReplyQuote
Frank Smith
(@wildcard)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 1573
 

This Barefoot fella is a pleasure to talk/deal with from my end of things. Haven't heard him brag or boast yet, he just knows his game. In my limited experience fishing I have found, those that brag the least catch most of the fish. They are too busy trying to keep doing it better. There maybe something to that. Good luck Tim.



   
ReplyQuote
Ratical
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 88
 

Thanks for the good read guys...... one of the most interesting topics I've red in a while and yes this bait presentation does work . I have witnessed it with my own eyes.....



   
ReplyQuote
Patrick
(@schooney)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 120
 

Purchased some decoys for the fall Gags. Wind is keeping me from playing with my new toys.... I know they work cause I've seen them work just never had any of my own and now the wind just won't quit!



   
ReplyQuote
Chip Pocock
(@)
Active Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 8
 

All I know is I fished trip after trip looking rock piles, wrecks or any kind of structure, then anchor and drop down all kinds of "traditional" grouper rigs with very limited success. One day a guy on the boat had a decoy jig in his box and put a live cigar minnow on it. We hadn't caught anything worth mentioning but let me tell you what. When that Decoy jig hit the bottom he didn't even have time to jig it before it got slammed! I didn't buy into it at first but time after time he dropped down and brought keeper fish up when the rest of us didn't do anything more than watch our bait disappear. I am now a believer!
Recently I added a skirt I got from Barlows with crab claws and a little bling.. But the decoy jig will get the grouper when nothing else will..



   
ReplyQuote
George Golinski
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 1371
 

I met Tim back in the old FishFest days. He's a straight shooter and a standup guy. I've caught scamp on his squid decoy jigs at night.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 3
Share: