SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Hello! What's your thoughts???
I had purchased some live target cigar minnows and spanish mackerel divers for trolling and took them to the lake today to test them out. The cigar minnows are the 6" size with diving capabilities of 15-20 feet. First off, they look amazing. Spot on color wise. Secondly, they tracked straight. Ran flawless up to 9 mph. The mackerel at the 4.25" size which run up to 10' and the 6" size that run up to 25'.
Has anyone tried these? I have seen a few reviews, all good. I know everyone says you can't beat the real thing but honestly, at trolling speed, does the smell even matter at that point? I just can't see a mahi or king or wahoo hitting a trolled dead bait because of scent. Would that be the right thinking? If so and it's the action of the bait that draws the strike, why would anyone fool with rigging frozen baits when they can roll with something like this? Fish are caught all the time on spoons which are obviously far less identical to the real thing. So, if you can troll a lure that has better action than its dead frozen counterpart, looks like a picture image of the real thing, doesn't wash out and eliminates the need to deal with brining, thawing, rigging, etc...why aren't we doing it???
Created this post for input as to if anyone has tried them and how they worked and also to drum up a discussion on the topic in general of dead vs artificial bait. I think it would be interesting to hear some of the thoughts on this.
Have caught many kings on diving plugs, typically use the yozuri divers. Have pulled the yozuri Bonita plug for wahoo. I always keep the yozuri divers onboard, get pricey especially if you don’t put any wire in front of them.
we often have one in the spread. Wahoo will whack those things, but we've also caught kings and mahi on them.
We have a short wire leader on all of them (maybe 8") to prevent them getting swiped by toothy critters. We also replace the treble hooks with j-hooks. We might lose a fish every now and then as a result, but once the fish is in the boat, it's a hell of a lot safer and easier to deal with 2 hooks flying around than 6 if he manages to shake or thrash at the wrong time.
But by all means - they catch fish.
We find them easier to deal with than a planer with a bridle.
we often have one in the spread. Wahoo will whack those things, but we've also caught kings and mahi on them.
We have a short wire leader on all of them (maybe 8") to prevent them getting swiped by toothy critters. We also replace the treble hooks with j-hooks. We might lose a fish every now and then as a result, but once the fish is in the boat, it's a hell of a lot safer and easier to deal with 2 hooks flying around than 6 if he manages to shake or thrash at the wrong time.But by all means - they catch fish.
We find them easier to deal with than a planer with a bridle.
Caught several fish on rapalas. Is this what your using or is it the cigar minnow and spanish plugs?
My biggest thing is, if trolling, if we can get exact picture perfect replicas of the real deal with plugs, why are we fooling with dead baits that wash out? Why not troll a full spread with different diving depths on each?
sorry. it's the rapalas. i guess i misunderstood your question. apologies.