SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Storms can "hide" bottoms and ledges.
Thx all -- in fact, I just chatted with the author, Captain Chip Berry, for a couple minutes on the phone. I'm just genuinely curious about the chart: by no means am I trying to diminish it, or anything. His 'user guide' (which is free on his website) describing bathymetry is worth the price of the chart, alone, IMO.
I think the accuracy of the numbers depends on where/how/who provided them, and as Curmudgeon said, error has been compounded through conversions in many cases....And with some of the seismic data, it's in the 'area' of a live bottom and was just chosen as a marker rather than an actual sounding.
So pretty much as y'all say: it's a general starting point. But that said, I think with contour lines, and studying the proximity of data points....I suspect there's some gold in there too. We'll see -- I'll try fishing it as much as I can.
The Bottom Topo in Bluewater Supermap is Science Grade data.
It is dead on in most cases.
The Numbers in Supermap....So are good....Some are not so good.
As a general rule...look at the last 3. If they are 000 then take them with a grain of salt.
Dave
Today's echarts from the gps manufacturers (I use garmin) are a lot more accurate for wrecks and marked reefs, as well as some of the better known rocks.
Good luck,
SeaBiscuit
I added a garmin as a backup and have been very pleasantly surprised at the accuracy of the bathymetric gradients as well as some of the more well known features. I have made some tweaks to the way I run the boat - definitely a positive.
feral,
Send me one of the numbers you think is off in the format that is on the chart. Let me know what it is, and I'll tell you how close it is.
MU is a good chart. Some places you have to ride around a little to get dead on. Some are spot on.
Like Dave said, anything ending in 000 is not right.
Good Luck
been reading this thred and now I'm getting confused! - on my maps unique - everything is listed as say: xxxx.xxx format - is that the same as xx xx.xxx?
everything is listed as say: xxxx.xxx format - is that the same as xx xx.xxx?
For Maps Unique, yes ...
xxxx.xxx is not the same as xx xx.xxx
DAve
well.....with all due respect to previous post....capt dave - what does xxxx.xxx from unique maps translate to in terms of the xx xx.xxx format?....for example, lets use maps unique #: AR362 "concrete pipe #1": 3415.766 7730.433 , what should that look like in the xx xx.xxx format?
thanks
Captain Dave -- you're correct, except Maps Unique kinda breaks the rules, with its format. This confused the hell out of me, too, which is why I ended up calling Capt. Chip Berry.
The conclusion I came to is:
The numbers are supposed to be entered as degrees, minutes.decimal minutes, even though they're listed (kinda) in the decimal degree format.
All that said, *some* numbers are accurate -- for example, if you plot that AR362 mark in Cullowhee's example as: N34 15.766 W77 30.433 you're dead on top of it (at least according to Garmin Homeport).
Other numbers for wrecks are less accurate, but if you muck with converting the coordinates to any other format, you're now *way* off....So dunno.
And finally, to make things more confusing, many numbers don't contain the last significant digit, so the instructions say to add a '0' at the end. I'm a little suspicious of these, but haven't been over enough to form a firm opinion.
-Steve
thanks steve - being fairly new to the near/off shore stuff - i have a maps unique that i have used to get some numbers off of for starter points...of course i mark my own once out there and see stuff on the bottom, etc...but, using the maps unique as you said and just converting to gps as in the example you listed, i was able to know i was on the right number at 362 because the bouy was marking it anyway so it seemed to check out....but, when going to some "bottom" places on the maps #'s, get out there to find "nothing" ...so I too have been confused...this thread has at least helped understand that i'm not THAT crazy! there is obviously some discrepancy...now, that being said - another question for capt dave....you mentioned that the blue water super map is "scientific grade accurate"...would it be safe to say/assume that if i pick out a point on the supermap, zoom all the way in, place the cursor on the center of the mark, read the name on the bottom right corner and look at the numbers in the left corner...that so long as the last numbers aren't 000, - that i am in fact looking at a pretty accurate read on that spot? - ie: I could trust those numbers with a fair degree of certainty (idk: 50-75' radius)?
thanks again for all the feedback guys...i have wondered about alot of these things for the past year, just never bothered to ask....
MM
About Supermap....
The Waypoints themselfs.....Some are good and some suck. They are from all over the place added by many people over time.
The Bottom Topography is science grade data. It is from what is called the Coastal Releif Model.
It takes in eavery bit of bottom data the GOV has....and uses the BEST data they have for that location.
Are there errors in it. YEs....but overall it is pretty dead nuts on.
An example of this is my own personal waypoints. The Ledge lines I have line up dead nuts on the changes in depth in Supermap.
Maps Unique...
I don't know if Chip screwed something up or not. I will ask him today but I can tell you with 100% certainty that the formats in question are NOT the same.
xx.xxxx does not equal xx xx.xxx
Maybe I need to sit down and write an article on Data formats.
Dave
PS....I just dailed Chips Number.
Soooo...
I just got off a long phone call with Chip.
He has this printed on his map...
3434.450 7658.500
This SHOULD BE READ AS
34 34.450 76 58.500
The format is DDD MM.MMM
There is a space missing.
It is written as DDD.DDDD but should be read as DDD MM.MMM
Dave
Even with the space missing, it should be pretty clear to anyone trying to use it that the intended number is 34 degrees 34.45 minutes, not 3434 degrees. If any are not extremely familiar with GPS coordinates and the different formats, it's a good idea to study them and become extremely familiar with all formats and converting them. Heaven forbid you're out there and SHTF and you have to give out or relay coordinates and you don't know what you're looking at or hearing and try to tell the CG that you're at 3434 degrees...
And with regards to seeing nothing on the bottom, there are times you will see nothing. However, search for threads discussing live bottom, hard bottom, ledges, etc. and using your FF to find it. If you're not in tune with how to manually operate your FF, you very well could be over some good bottom, yet think you're over nothing on your FF because of the settings. There have been multiple discussions on that topic recently here and on THT in the Carolinas section.
thanks for all the reply's gang - like steve and now capt Dave said - I have indeed been interpreting it as there is a space missing - as for not seeing things on certain points - prob part me missing the spot exactly and part learning my depth finder - which i got a new one last year (lowrance HDS 5) pretty good display, but don't claim to know exactly every inch of it and all it will do...as for last guys post - agreed - such was my concern - thinking i'm in one spot and maybe in fact being in another or at least off the mark quite a bit...I'm confident now that all's well and I can trust the numbers i'm putting in - thanks again guys....now, if anybody wants to give me all the good numbers that aren't on maps unique they have out of new topsail inlet i can practice this craft!!....HA!!