SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
I wanted to write a pseudo offshore fishing report for the Snowy Grouper Wreck in the Snowy Grouper Marine Protected Area. You can see where the MPA is here: https://safmc.net/safmc-managed-areas/snowy-grouper-wreck-mpa/ The Nipple is located in the NW portion of it. The MPA waters are closed to bottom fishing but trolling is fine.
For my 9-5 job I'm a remotely operated vehicle pilot and every year we conduct a two week mission for the NMFS looking at fish populations inside and outside the MPA's from Florida up to North Carolina and back. Some of you guys may have seen us on a big white ship the first week of June around The Nipple and off Morehead around the Big Rock another day. It was calm and there were a lot of folks trolling.
I just wanted to write a report about what I've personally seen on the Snowy Grouper Wreck in the MPA. The wreck is 330' long and about 30' tall and is in 850' of water. It looks to be a bulk carrier in which the hull is riveted together so it's probably from the 1930-1950's, but archaeologist don't know what it is. Currents are typically pretty strong so our team has trouble working on it, we can't work in more than 1.5knots of currents. The physical position is SE of the Nipple. The MPA went into affect in 2009 and prior to that the wreck was heavily fished by commercial fisherman. My predecessors at work dove on the wreck back around 2009 and they saw small populations of snowy grouper, 50 fish. I personally dove on it in 2016 and 2017 and saw significant increases in snowy groupers due to the closure of the area. Last week we got lucky and there was actually a 0.5knot current moving towards the west so we got to circumnavigate the wreck for the first time ever, typically we just do the north side since the currents are moving towards the NE. The bow of the ship is facing west. From what I saw the fish populations have been hit very hard lately and the numbers are looking more closely like they were in the 2009 timeframe. I saw tons of sash weights and butterfly jigs on the wreck that were relatively new with no growth. I also came across 3 snowies that were still on a deep drop rig/sash weight in which was tangled on the side of the wreck. The fish were still alive so I imagine that someone lost the gear the day before.
Recreational limit on snowies is 1 fish per vessel and commercial is 200lbs gutted so I imagine the commercial guys are the ones targeting the area. Personally my favorite thing to do in the world is fish, I'm sure you guys have seen my reports before on this site. I just wanted to make sure you local guys were aware of fishing going on there and that it's actually affecting the population of fish out there from what I see on the actual wreck.
I added a couple pics of the wreck, one of the anchor on the PORT bow and one of house which is deteriorating.

MPA’s are not very effective if they are not monitored for illegal activities. I realize that it would be difficult and expensive, but you have evidence of illegal fishing, do you have anyone to contact to at least attempt monitoring? If people fishing the area were to see some sign of law enforcement, it would go a long way towards curtailing the illegal fishing. I’m pretty sure I know the answer, but as long as people think they can get away with it, they will.
It's like speeding though. If you see a policeman, you hit the brakes.
If you see a NCDMF boat hanging out around an MPA, you're not going to deep drop on it, and if you are deep-dropping on it, and see some boat hauling ass over the horizon towards you, you'd pull up and GTFO and stow all the bottom gear.
About the only way to nail people would be to have a plane do some periodic fly-bys and relay info to a nearby boat to come do an inspection. Maybe tie it to a day with a really calm forecast. But catching people in the act that far offshore is going to be very labor intensive and expensive.
MPA’s are only effective for people that are willing to abide by the rules when no one is looking. Unfortunately there are people who will poach a resource to death if they think they can get away with it. If you have an MPA that is showing obvious signs that it is being fished illegally, and enforcement does nothing, then it just encourages the poacher. It may be expensive, but if they caught a few of these people, prosecuted them to the full extent of the law, it would let everyone know they mean business and are serious about the MPA’s, otherwise it turns into a joke.
I guess another option would to be declare Snowy Grouper protected like the did with Goliath Grouper. Of course that screws everybody because of a few greedy knuckleheads.
The area off the blackjack where all the commercials DD is routinely checked by the CG. Was checked there last year.
We’re they checking your catch, or typical safety check?
Edit. I just read an article that stated the Coast Guard started to focus on fisheries violations starting back on Sept of 2020. Maybe that will help, if the information the OP posted gets to the Coast Guard.
The area off the blackjack where all the commercials DD is routinely checked by the CG. Was checked there last year.
I appreciate the informative post. But I wouldn't single out the commercial fisherman for the blame. I have seen several charter boats fish the snowy wreck towards the end of a trolling trip. Perhaps they are supplementing the catch for their clients? Anyway, it's not just a single boat. One day I saw a line of 3 sportfishers taking turns as they "trolled" over the wreck. They would come to a complete stop for quite a while so bait would reach the bottom, hook up, then pull away while the next boat did the same.
I wrote an “informative email” to a USCG friend. They know about it but still wanted to pass the info along to you guys.
I appreciate what you are doing. I think your efforts on informing and involving the fishing community that there is illegal fishing going on is important. I’m curious though, because your job involves monitoring the MPA’s, do you not have an established protocol with a list of agencies to notify when you find evidence of illegal fishing?
I wrote an “informative email” to a USCG friend. They know about it but still wanted to pass the info along to you guys.
I’m basically a bus driver, our team pilots and maintains the vehicle. Scientist contract us out to do different missions all over and typically handle any discussions with other agencies. This just hit close to home for me so I wanted to put the word out myself just to inform folks.
I think it is important that you inform others of what is going on in the MPAs. It doesn’t matter if it is recreational, commercial or charters that are doing the poaching, what matters is that the poaching is going on and apparently nothing can or will be done about it. If the Coast Guard knows about it and others have seen it and choose not to get involved, then it just encourages the individuals doing the poaching to continue. Judging by the lack of involvement in this thread it appears there is not a lot of concern about the issue. I suspect that if somebody was poaching deer on private property the game warden would be notified immediately, poaching in an MPA should be viewed no differently.
I imagine there are some that are against MPAs, because they see it as restriction on prime fishing areas, but I see it as the equivalency of a inshore nursery area. If MPAs are respected and the fish are allowed to live unmolested, then maybe the population will increase and enhance the fisheries in surrounding areas. At least the creation of an MPA is an effort at trying to improve fisheries, but if we don’t support it, then it is doomed to failure.
I’m basically a bus driver, our team pilots and maintains the vehicle. Scientist contract us out to do different missions all over and typically handle any discussions with other agencies. This just hit close to home for me so I wanted to put the word out myself just to inform folks.
Judging by the lack of involvement in this thread it appears there is not a lot of concern about the issue.
I think this has gotten pretty good traction.
How so, 500 views, but only 6 active participants?
Judging by the lack of involvement in this thread it appears there is not a lot of concern about the issue.
I think this has gotten pretty good traction.
i mean - what's your expectation? There's a lot of people on this site who never leave site of land. 500+ views for a recent post is about normal.
