SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

Snowy Grouper Marine Protected Area off Southern, NC

38 Posts
16 Users
0 Reactions
1,893 Views
Ben
 Ben
(@kcben)
Prominent Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 815
 

Does CG even check for fishing violations? Been checked by CG while fishing a few times and they never asked me a fishing related question.

they will check any commercial vessel they come across for fishing violations but not really rec or charter.



   
ReplyQuote
Ben
 Ben
(@kcben)
Prominent Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 815
 

Does CG even check for fishing violations? Been checked by CG while fishing a few times and they never asked me a fishing related question.

they will check any commercial vessel they come across for fishing violations but not really rec or charter.



   
ReplyQuote
Jon Tennant
(@jon)
Trusted Member
Joined: 23 years ago
Posts: 67
 

If it’s jigs and bank sinkers it’s not commercial boats. Don’t try to make this a political post about “how bad commercial fishermen are”. I know who most snapper boats are on this coast and they avoid that place like the plague. they have way more to loose than most if they get caught in an mpa. Commercial snapper fishermen are artisanal low bycatch fishermen that are almost regulated out of business. Every commercial boat has those coordinates in their plotter to stay away from. Many recreational guys don’t even know a regulation is when they go offshore and never check the regs before going out.

This is spot on



   
ReplyQuote
(@tegin1)
Estimable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 144
 

This is from the original post, the wreck is in 850’ of water, I don’t think you could get a jig or bank sinker down there.

I saw tons of sash weights and butterfly jigs on the wreck that were relatively new with no growth. I also came across 3 snowies that were still on a deep drop rig/sash weight in which was tangled on the side of the wreck. The fish were still alive so I imagine that someone lost the gear the day before.

If it’s jigs and bank sinkers it’s not commercial boats. Don’t try to make this a political post about “how bad commercial fishermen are”. I know who most snapper boats are on this coast and they avoid that place like the plague. they have way more to loose than most if they get caught in an mpa. Commercial snapper fishermen are artisanal low bycatch fishermen that are almost regulated out of business. Every commercial boat has those coordinates in their plotter to stay away from. Many recreational guys don’t even know a regulation is when they go offshore and never check the regs before going out.

This is spot on



   
ReplyQuote
(@tegin1)
Estimable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 144
 

This is from the original post, the wreck is in 850’ of water, I don’t think you could get a jig or bank sinker down there.

I saw tons of sash weights and butterfly jigs on the wreck that were relatively new with no growth. I also came across 3 snowies that were still on a deep drop rig/sash weight in which was tangled on the side of the wreck. The fish were still alive so I imagine that someone lost the gear the day before.

If it’s jigs and bank sinkers it’s not commercial boats. Don’t try to make this a political post about “how bad commercial fishermen are”. I know who most snapper boats are on this coast and they avoid that place like the plague. they have way more to loose than most if they get caught in an mpa. Commercial snapper fishermen are artisanal low bycatch fishermen that are almost regulated out of business. Every commercial boat has those coordinates in their plotter to stay away from. Many recreational guys don’t even know a regulation is when they go offshore and never check the regs before going out.

This is spot on



   
ReplyQuote
richard trask
(@sightseer)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 51
 

I agree that most if not all commercial guys avoid this area. They have way too much to loose as this is their full time job and they don't want to risk it by fishing in a restricted area. I can't believe that with all the big brother stuff that Uncle Sam has that they don't have a satellite watching it from time to time.

All it will take is one or two boats being caught and that will be the end of it. The Feds don't play and you do not want to get on the wrong side of them! They have unlimited resources to squash you like a bug and the bad attitude to do it! You don't have to go that deep or that far to catch snowies and you certainly don't have to risk your boat,your reputation, or your wallet to catch them either.



   
ReplyQuote
Bilzo
(@bilzo)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 2620
 

Many recreational guys don’t even know a regulation is when they go offshore and never check the regs before going out.

If we say we don't wanna make this a rec vs comm thing, then don't start pointing the finger at rec guys in the process. Nobody knows for sure who's doing it.

If the current is light enough, you can certainly get a jig or a bank sinker down 850'. Might need to keep the boat in gear against the current to position it, but it'll get down there.

I think most of us can agree - we'd just prefer they nail one or two guys and let it be known you can't be bottom fishing out there, but once again - that's going to be a hard thing to enforce.

If you were bottom fishing (and knew it was illegal to do so....you'd have at least 5-10 minutes to get you act together before being boarded for inspection. I believe the rules are that you are allowed to pass through the area, troll, surface fish, etc...just that your bottom gear must be stowed. So lets say you are in the thick of things, two lines over, one's got a fish on, one doesn't. You see the CG cutter making a beeline for you

Cut both lines, make sure they're down and out of props way. Start engine. Tie on a couple cedar plugs (who gives a crap if you don't have bimini twist knots or whatever) and start moving. Move the electric reels down into the cabin.

"What's the problem sir? Oh you can't bottom fish here? No worries. We've been trolling all day!"

It's really hard to sneak up on somebody in the ocean. Realllly hard.



   
ReplyQuote
(@tegin1)
Estimable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 144
 

The chance of getting down to a wreck at 850’ with a jig or bank sinker is going to be slim to none unless you are fishing with 5-10lb jigs or bank sinkers. The amount of current and drift will have a bank sinker or jig flapping in the breeze and require much more than 850’ of line and a lot of luck to actually be on the wreck. There is a reason sash weights are used for deep drop fishing. I don’t know who it is fishing the wreck, but you have to have serious gear and intent to have any success when fishing a wreck at that depth.

Many recreational guys don’t even know a regulation is when they go offshore and never check the regs before going out.

If we say we don't wanna make this a rec vs comm thing, then don't start pointing the finger at rec guys in the process. Nobody knows for sure who's doing it.

If the current is light enough, you can certainly get a jig or a bank sinker down 850'. Might need to keep the boat in gear against the current to position it, but it'll get down there.

I think most of us can agree - we'd just prefer they nail one or two guys and let it be known you can't be bottom fishing out there, but once again - that's going to be a hard thing to enforce.

If you were bottom fishing (and knew it was illegal to do so....you'd have at least 5-10 minutes to get you act together before being boarded for inspection. I believe the rules are that you are allowed to pass through the area, troll, surface fish, etc...just that your bottom gear must be stowed. So lets say you are in the thick of things, two lines over, one's got a fish on, one doesn't. You see the CG cutter making a beeline for you

Cut both lines, make sure they're down and out of props way. Start engine. Tie on a couple cedar plugs (who gives a crap if you don't have bimini twist knots or whatever) and start moving. Move the electric reels down into the cabin.

"What's the problem sir? Oh you can't bottom fish here? No worries. We've been trolling all day!"

It's really hard to sneak up on somebody in the ocean. Realllly hard.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 3 / 3
Share: