SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

Bonito, Bonita, Albacore, Tunny, what?

9 Posts
8 Users
0 Reactions
1,041 Views
Lee
 Lee
(@maysalt)
Trusted Member
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 37
Topic starter   [#56320]

(I could have this totally wrong, please confirm, that’s the reason for this post)

I’m new to saltwater fishing so I’ve been taking some what of a molecular approach to things as I go along.

Although I’ve asked various people for advice on these fish, it has only added to my confusion. If you start doing research and reading articles, forums and what not, you find more of the same.

It now seems to me there is a very clear difference between a Tunny (false albacore) and an Atlantic Bonito but so many people mix this up or just don’t care to differentiate.

Last fall, I caught a false albacore (greenish color with squiggly lines along the back). I bled it immediately and it went to the ice. After trimming the blood line, I was left with very dark red flesh. I pan seared this fish rare and it was edible but robust.

Now, with an Atlantic Bonito in hand (diagonal lines along the back) treated the very same way, I can positively confirm this is the species to be eating. Very mild and just like tuna.

Has anyone else shared this experience?



   
Quote
Wayne Batten
(@cwayne)
Noble Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 811
 

If it has teeth and can bite you it’s a Bonito and you want to bite into it. If it’s a Bonita it makes great cut bait.



   
ReplyQuote
Lee
 Lee
(@maysalt)
Trusted Member
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 37
Topic starter  

Very nicely put and easy to remember!



   
ReplyQuote
Brad Honeycutt
(@cw66)
Honorable Member
Joined: 10 years ago
Posts: 659
 

Bonita = Awful to eat!
Bonito = Oh, man that's good to eat!



   
ReplyQuote
Phillip Loughlin
(@)
Honorable Member
Joined: 8 years ago
Posts: 574
 

If it has teeth, it's good to eat. That's the easiest way to explain it for folks. I know, personally, I never could remember which one had the squiggly lines and which had stripes... but the teeth thing, that stuck.

That said, I gaffed a big bonita while trolling for blackfins earlier this winter. I figured since I killed it anyway, I'd take it home and maybe make strip baits or something. When I got it on the table, I got curious and cut a filet off of one side. Besides the huge (proportionately) blood line, the meat looked pretty good, so I cut a sliver of sashimi and gave it a go. Really not bad, and definitely not what I'd always been led to believe. I seared a loin that night, and honestly would have had a hard time telling it from the blackfin.

Point is, after almost 50 years of tossing bonita back because they were "inedible", I learned for myself that they're not so bad. I'm still not targeting them, and I tossed the one back that I caught the other day... but turns out the "common wisdom" is a bit misleading.



   
ReplyQuote
Kevin Dunahm
(@kandg)
Eminent Member
Joined: 14 years ago
Posts: 25
 

I kind of like Bonita. The ones that I keep to eat I always bleed and gut as soon as it is in the boat.



   
ReplyQuote
Johnnie Sheppard
(@)
Trusted Member
Joined: 12 years ago
Posts: 41
 

I've personally never been that hungry ! But catching one is a blessing for bait. Bottom bait with a fresh one using the skin and some meat to hold it on the hook is great. Think of it this way each one is about $10 worth of bait you don't have to buy. Check out some videos on you tube about how to cut bait strips is a great for Kings, Mahi and Cobia. Fresh is always better than frozen but I will freeze some to use later. I can't keep just the meat on the hook without skin but it's always good to have when the school Mahi come around to chum with.



   
ReplyQuote
Bilzo
(@bilzo)
Famed Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 2620
 

The Fat Alberts (false albacore, bonita, little tunny) are entirely edible, and as stated above, they're not significantly different from a tuna.

The problem is, the bloodline is so gigantic that if you catch at 10 lb false albacore, you might be lucky to get 1-2 lbs of meat, and I'm not killing a fish for that much waste when there are so many better options.

Now...(and I'll admit to this)….if a fat albert gets nipped by the taxman, you can take him back to the dock for some fantastic fresh sushi - he's already been bled for you and he's gonna die anyway OR if it's the end of a long trip offshore and it's been crappy and there's nothing in the box and we see a school of false albacore on the way in - I'll put one or two in the box to take SOMETHING home to the wife so I can give her fresh fish. But those are about the only way I'm giving one a taxi ride to shore.



   
ReplyQuote
Jim Bickerstaff
(@sobachka)
Estimable Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 222
 

Has anyone else shared this experience?

Yep - stripes is tuna - squiggles is catfood/strip bait.



   
ReplyQuote
Share: