SWC Forums

Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.

Notifications
Clear all

Inshore Nets

205 Posts
52 Users
0 Reactions
8,044 Views
David Ralph
(@)
Estimable Member
Joined: 13 years ago
Posts: 102
 

Fish population is declining so if there is to be any fish to be caught we all need to work together to find a solution. Look at our fishery ten years ago. I see both sides, look at other states FL and Va. dam good fishing. Not bashing commercial fishing but what percent goes overseas?? Sport fishing how many coolers never make it home? Red fish is a good example of fish management. If we do not find a solution and keep on our current path we will not be having this conversation.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Fish population is declining so if there is to be any fish to be caught we all need to work together to find a solution. Look at our fishery ten years ago. I see both sides, look at other states FL and Va. dam good fishing. Not bashing commercial fishing but what percent goes overseas?? Sport fishing how many coolers never make it home? Red fish is a good example of fish management. If we do not find a solution and keep on our current path we will not be having this conversation.

Below is the Visioning Project summary I submitted to the NCMFC and NC Legislature at the request of Senator Tillis when he was Speaker. It is the result of countless conversations with everyone from homeless at a soup kitchen to world-renowned marine biologists such as Dr. Brian Rothschild. The simple solutions offered in it would benefit everyone and the resource.

Start by figuring out how much of each species can be harvested sustainably. Let each sector decide how to manage their share of quotas with a 2/3 majority vote from participating license holders. Run hatcheries at full capacity rotating what is raised based on need and season. Take practical steps to improve water quality. Enhance habitat with things like artificial reefs. Educate fishermen about how to release illegal fish so they have the best chance of survival. Reward fishermen and consumers with higher quotas as stocks reach desired levels. In the end we should make full use of all harvested seafood.



   
ReplyQuote
Mark Clapp
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 979
 

I tried to switch from offshore to inshore fishing. Was getting tired of the ride. Bought a new $42,000 sea hunt 22 bx and all inshore gear. Fished hard for a year learning holes and the ropes. Then the netters go thru your holes and put an end to catching. I live opposite Figure 8 Island. I sold the boat for a $8 - $9 thousand dollar loss because I can't compete with netters. I will not fish inshore in NC until inshore netting is banned - as it is in every other state and rightfully so.

The fishery suffers and every cut is made to the recs. Comms won't give an inch because they think "give an inch they'll take a mile".

Eventually they will get what they deserve - after pissing off every fisherman and visitor to our inshore waters.

For now, it's back to offshore until they figure out how to net wahoo.



   
ReplyQuote
allenj
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1094
 

This has nothing to do with government pitting one group against another. People do not need to stand as one In this case. This is about localized depletion by a bunch of hacks whom most are part time supplementing their income. Two that come to mind here locally work for the town of Surf City. This is not hook and line offshore commercial fishing. Not much of anyone has an issue with that. This is a state problem and has to be addressed. "Drum are so thick you can walk on them" "they are eating all the crabs" "if you can't catch trout in nc you are doing it wrong". If it is so great, why don't we go to hook and line commercial fishing for trout, reds and striper and do away with gill nets? Currently hook and line is illegal. Daily commercial limit with no culling just like other states. I mean the fishing is so great it should not be a problem..........right? A commercial hook and line trout fishery exists in both Florida and Louisiana. THE BYCATCH PROBLEMS, LOCALIZED DEPLETION AND TURTLE ISSUES WOULD BE A THING OF THE PAST.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Why not just make more fish for everyone to enjoy? We should stand as one in our call for fishery managers to focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting our freedom to access them.

There seems to be a mindset in America that somebody must be punished to solve a problem. Most problems can be solved by advancing liberty for all rather than restricting one group's freedom for the perceived benefit of another.



   
ReplyQuote
Kenneth
(@matador)
Famed Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 3641
 

Why not just make more fish for everyone to enjoy? We should stand as one in our call for fishery managers to focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting our freedom to access them.

There seems to be a mindset in America that somebody must be punished to solve a problem. Most problems can be solved by advancing liberty for all rather than restricting one group's freedom for the perceived benefit of another.

Most problems are actually solved by addressing the root cause of the problem. Simply "enhancing" fisheries via stocking programs doesn't solve the problem. Just like the Catch Shares initiative for gulf ARS solved nothing. The thought process is the same.



   
ReplyQuote
allenj
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1094
 

Why not just make more fish for everyone to enjoy? We should stand as one in our call for fishery managers to focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting our freedom to access them.

There seems to be a mindset in America that somebody must be punished to solve a problem. Most problems can be solved by advancing liberty for all rather than restricting one group's freedom for the perceived benefit of another.

I know what you are saying and I get that......but in the case of inshore gill netting, making more fish "for everyone to enjoy" does not and will not work. My share and your share to enjoy, will wither be floating dead or thrown on the grass to die as bycatch, regulatory discards, or caught when it is too small. Chris, do you understand that as of right now, small mesh is allowed to sit 24 hours a day in most of the state? If you want to stand together brother, you have to take a stand on destructive inshore practices and go from there. Enough of the crap. This has nothing to do with liberty or restricting access. All we want is a gear change. Why is a gear change that difficult?



   
ReplyQuote
(@waterdog)
Estimable Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 45
 

Why not just make more fish for everyone to enjoy? We should stand as one in our call for fishery managers to focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting our freedom to access them.

There seems to be a mindset in America that somebody must be punished to solve a problem. Most problems can be solved by advancing liberty for all rather than restricting one group's freedom for the perceived benefit of another.

It's a nice idea, Chris. Sure hatcheries have their place and would be welcomed.

BUT - WHO IS GOING TO PAY FOR IT?

The Commercial sector that has a massive license over-capacity and yet needs every penny it can raise for a large mesh gill net fishery that isnt worth the paper its printed on? And just so y'all know - because of the turtle restrictions - it costs more money to observe the large mesh fishery than its worth. In the past zseveral years, the Zomne from highway 58 to the SC line costs TWICE AS MUCH tax-dollars to regulate as it produces in income.

But - back to hatcheries.

So NC already does this with striped bass in the Nuese/TAr/Pamlico Rivers (called the CSMA). RECREATIONAL License dollars (WITH ZERO COMMERCIAL CONTRIBUTIONS) stock a large amount of striped bass in said rivers.

Right now the harvest is 80% commercial. When you add in mortality from said destructive gill nets - it's over 90%.

Gill nets are too effective and too efficient. They are very cheap and mobile and as long as they are allowed we sill see this sort of results from program.

If you want to get rid of destructive gears, and remove all nets, and start talking H&L commercial harvest then your argument holds water.

I really like the comment from the first page about the gentleman new to the area - that NC has so much water, so much bait and so much habitat and the majority of it holds no predators.

People dont realize how much easier it is to find reds and trout, etc in other state compared to NC. That's a fact.



   
ReplyQuote
Rich
 Rich
(@squid-row)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 4097
 

This has nothing to do with government pitting one group against another. People do not need to stand as one In this case. This is about localized depletion by a bunch of hacks whom most are part time supplementing their income. Two that come to mind here locally work for the town of Surf City. This is not hook and line offshore commercial fishing. Not much of anyone has an issue with that. This is a state problem and has to be addressed. "Drum are so thick you can walk on them" "they are eating all the crabs" "if you can't catch trout in nc you are doing it wrong". If it is so great, why don't we go to hook and line commercial fishing for trout, reds and striper and do away with gill nets? Currently hook and line is illegal. Daily commercial limit with no culling just like other states. I mean the fishing is so great it should not be a problem..........right? A commercial hook and line trout fishery exists in both Florida and Louisiana. THE BYCATCH PROBLEMS, LOCALIZED DEPLETION AND TURTLE ISSUES WOULD BE A THING OF THE PAST.

Very well stated allenj

WRT to Chris' post below about adding more hatchery fish, I have to disagree. Why do it? There should be plenty of natural fish in the waters we have here. There is no reason to set up a fish farming industry to supplement a commercial harvest.

The problem is too many are being killed. The waters of NC, particularly south of Emerald Isle are just not big enough to support the methods of commercial harvest that are currently in place. Pamlico and Albemarle sounds are one thing, the ICW is another.

There is no reason that NC can't move to a hook and line or gig commercial fishery for the main inshore fish and ocean striped bass.

MA has a very successful striped bass commercial hook and line fishery and other states have been successful in implementing the same hook and line commercial fishery for trout.

To me anyway, before going off on a multi million dollar stocking endeavor, we should modify what we have in place today.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

Is the problem really with nets or leaving them unattended?
Is the problem really with nets catching fish or the lack of quotas to prevent overfishing?

Waterdog makes a great point about the commercial sector needing to help fund striper stocking along with any other hatchery projects that benefit consumers.

Allenj, I respect that you are not pushing the crony capitalism of gamefish which is not much different than the catch share scheme Matador mentioned that gives a privileged few almost exclusive access to a public resource. What do you think about quotas and full retention fisheries where legal limits can be sold and overages are donated to soup kitchens while being deducted from quotas?

Squid Row, we already have hatcheries in place. We just need to run them at full capacity. I understand your purest point of view on only harvesting naturally occurring stocks at sustainable levels. I support Naturally Occurring Quotas, but also realize our waters have the potential to produce much more seafood and recreational opportunity with Hatchery Supported Quotas. Refusing to stock seafood will only result in our public officials getting more pressure to subsidize industrial fish farms.



   
ReplyQuote
allenj
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1094
 

Is the problem really with nets or leaving them unattended?
Is the problem really with nets catching fish or the lack of quotas to prevent overfishing?

Waterdog makes a great point about the commercial sector needing to help fund striper stocking along with any other hatchery projects that benefit consumers.

Allenj, I respect that you are not pushing the crony capitalism of gamefish which is not much different than the catch share scheme Matador mentioned that gives a privileged few almost exclusive access to a public resource. What do you think about quotas and full retention fisheries where legal limits can be sold and overages are donated to soup kitchens while being deducted from quotas?

Squid Row, we already have hatcheries in place. We just need to run them at full capacity. I understand your purest point of view on only harvesting naturally occurring stocks at sustainable levels. I support Naturally Occurring Quotas, but also realize our waters have the potential to produce much more seafood and recreational opportunity with Hatchery Supported Quotas. Refusing to stock seafood will only result in our public officials getting more pressure to subsidize industrial fish farms.

Chris, please do not take this conversation the wrong way, I like you and respect what you have tried to do.

Chris what shines here the most to me, is that you are very uneducated on this subject that you fight for, estrauine gill nets. I want to see a vibrant commercial fishery, you were in Morehead when I spoke at a press conference. You know this. What we need is a gear change. NC is currently spending all of their time and effort on one thing. Keeping certain gears in the water. And before other certain offshore commercial fisherman jump in on a topic they also don't know anything about, we are not talking about spot nets which are set in the fall, and attended inshore in the ICW and checked frequently. When you leave the ICW that is another story.

Chris what the fight should be about is to save inshore commercial fishing BEFORE it is too late. HOW? Change the gears that are allowed to harvest. The gill net is too messy. The discard rates are through the roof, they are not selective and kill too many other types of wildlife. A large mesh flounder net catches flounder 10" and on up? Why? Because this is how that gear works. Large mesh flounder nets are a prime example.

Strike netting speckled trout?? The daily limit is 75 per day, and the stock is in horrific shape and will be even more so later this week. The director has claimed on more than one occasion that speckled sea trout can not be successfully managed for commercial harvest. if you strike a hole, and hit the fish, you will have 300 or more speckled trout. 2/3's are going to go back dead. Soup kitchens are not the answer to this. What is the answer? A hook and line fishery with daily limits and a yearly quota.

Soup kitchens and hatcheries are not the answer to NC's problems inshore. The soup kitchen idea is a disaster, and I am pretty sure you know this. All it would do is create loop holes and the logistics alone would be a nightmare. I am all for hatcheries once the destructive gear is removed. Lets have a viable inshore commercial fishery without destructive gear. Call Nc Wildlife and talk to them about how well the striped bass hatchery and release is going, when around 90% of all released are being caught by gill nets. It is not working.
WE CAN'T PREVENT OVERFISHING, IT IS TOO LATE FOR THAT.



   
ReplyQuote
allenj
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1094
 

He is a great start....out of Louisiana's play book.

The speckled trout quota is 1 million pounds a year commercial

Now NC could not support this to start off. We don't have the fish we should. I chuckle everytime I hear someone talk about trout fishing is a fall thing. We have trout year round, but not the numbers we should or once did. The speckled trout should be the most abundant fish in our marsh year round.

In LA, guides can not hold a comm license to harvest specks. I am 100% good with that. Why can't we do away with nets on trout, and only allow those to participate in the commercial hook and line fishery if they have landings of trout in the past five years via trip tickets??

Would you say this would be a good starting point? This would build a economical sustaining commercial fishery while rebuilding the stock and allowing plenty of recreational opportunity.



   
ReplyQuote
Chip Garman
(@bluepirate)
Estimable Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 84
 

Allen speaks common sense, and since he is on the water most of the time he speaks with experience.

From my personal experience my perspective is quite simple. I lived and fished in FL before and after the net ban. The difference is beyond belief. The fish stocks came back strong and quickly.

I have since fished inshore from SC to TX and nowhere is it like it is here in NC which is quickly turning into an inshore desert. And for sure those states do not allow gill nets on the scale that we do, if at all. All we need to do is to look south and west of us to see how the other states have successfully managed the resource. Until the nets are either banned or the gear and use behavior is amended accordingly we will continue to suffer the same malaise.

Remember the definition of insanity. Continuing to do the same thing over and over and expecting different results.

I live here now and I see the devastation that is being done. I've seen it before and it is hard to watch again knowing that the answer is right there for the taking. Letting small mesh nets remain in the water full time right now unattended is a travesty on our resource. And downright shameful.



   
ReplyQuote
Chris McCaffity
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 15 years ago
Posts: 1424
 

allenj, I know from setting nets that they can be selective when used responsibly.

It seems as if we are the same page with wanting to preserve NC's commercial fisheries and the consumer's freedom to eat local seafood before it is too late. As for your idea about setting a quota for trout, I agree. Only allowing hook and line harvest is something else. What about gigging trout? Maybe we could follow the model for longlining Golden Tilefish by allowing nets to harvest trout with higher possession limits until 75% of the quota has been landed and then go to a hook and line fishery. This would greatly reduce regulatory discards.

Would you support stocking if we had quotas or only if nets are banned even if the same amount of fish are eaten?



   
ReplyQuote
allenj
(@)
Noble Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 1094
 

Gigging trout is already legal. It will never work, the trip ticket program is broken. i am speaking from experience on that one. We don't have the stock to support your idea. Please tell me how to responsibly/and or ethically set a large mesh gill net. Please tell me how one knows the difference between 16" reds or 16" trout while setting for trout. As I said brother, you guys are out of touch with both the inshore crowd and with what goes on inshore. Commercial fishing with nets inshore has to stop. If it is so great hook and line should not be a problem right???????? After all it works for grouper, sea bass, wahoo, tuna and so forth does it not? Do you know why? Because we no longer fish grouper pots or a myriad of other destructive gear out there, that is why.



   
ReplyQuote
Page 5 / 14
Share: