SWC Forums
Pull up a chair...let's talk fishing.
Quotas are what prevent overfishing in federally managed fisheries. It really doesn't matter how or when the seafood is harvested as long as quotas are not exceeded.
Hatcheries and habitat enhancement can produce more fish than we had in virgin fisheries. I grew up hearing about the good old days of inshore and offshore fishing. My goal is to see sustainable fisheries that are better than ever before even as we harvest more recreationally and commercially. The waters we are blessed with in NC can and should feed many more people while supporting world-class sportfishing.
allenj may make more sense than anyone I have heard knowledgeable on NC commercial fishing.
The inshore nets HAVE TO GO!
Else there will be no fish left to catch. Or sell. Or eat.
Chris the offshore fishing gotten better because of the destructive gears that were outlawed. The quotas were only a piece of management. Tell me why grouper pots, reef complex long lining and reef complex trawling was outlawed???? Because it was destructive and non sustainable. What took the place?? Rod and reel with quotas. I don't Care how many hatcheries are running full capacity. As long as destructive gear is in the wayer......it does not matter. Again I ask you to look at the striper, 90% of stripers inshore that are stocked are either harvested by gill nets or dead as gill net bycatch. You are going to tell me a rod and reel and a bag of flukes could not harvest those fish clean??? Nets have to go and I would suggest people on your side start advocating for a commercial hook and line fishery before all is lost. I hate to see it all lost, but it is coming like a tidal wave.
Cap1, that is precisely while an overwhelming majority net inshore only to supplement their income. It is not sustainable enough to scratch a living out. Chris, I am still waiting to hear how to set those nets responsibly and ethically that I listed above.
Typical... offshore fisherman commenting on inshore fisheries management and defending gill nets... I am no expert, but I believe I have enough experience and knowledge to at least weigh in on this issue. Over the last year, I have started paying more attention and learning as much as I can about current events and educating myself in NC fisheries management. I got a job as a recreational observer for DMF. I watched recreational fisherman fish for cobia, flounder, gray trout, sea mullet, croaker etc. for 7 months observing for protected species interatctions. What did I learn? Well, first off we witnessed ZERO protected species interactions with recreational hook and line fishing and we primarily watched people fish on the bottom with live or cut bait in the Cape Lookout area, which is regarded as a turtle hot spot. BUT what hit me the hardest is seeing that flounder fishing in the old reliable spots that my family and many other long-time Cape Lookout area fisherman frequented, is piss poor now, at best. I often wondered why people continue to even try to catch them in NC.
What Mr. Jernigan says about people claiming that speckled trout fishing is "a fall thing," is also true from what I have experienced personally and from what I have discovered talking to many, many experienced anglers that have fished in Eastern NC longer than I have been alive. Speckled trout are here year round and the fishing should be much better than it is during times that people now regard as poor times of the year to catch speckled trout. Summer in particular should be a great time to catch specks but our stocks are so poor, that their dispersal with the warmer water temps renders them almost impossible to find.
Every year, my family goes on a vacation to Hilton Head, SC during June or July and we trailer our 23' Sea Hunt deep vee down there to fish. When it is too windy to go out and hit the AR's for kings or cobia or whatever, I often go inshore. The fishing is so good there, that with a TERRIBLE inshore fishing boat with no trolling motor and a deep draft, I am consistently able to find speckled trout in the MIDDLE OF THE SUMMER. An average day there for us is catching easily double digits and many times we find multiple schools of them and will totally lose count catching 40, 50 or more fish. We also occasionally find some nice red drum, but without covering much water and not being able to get up shallow, we don't target them there. This is all without any extensive knowledge of the area, not hiring guides (when I was a lot younger we went on a couple tarpon/cobia trips there), and just by riding up and down the Calibogue or Port Royal sound and picking random, productive looking shorelines.
Our waters in North Carolina are very productive and fishing is still good during parts of the year, but it is not even close to what it could be and used to be. With significant changes in fisheries management it definitely will, without question be phenomenal. I won't claim that it would definitely be better, or even as good as, Louisiana or Florida etc, because their waters are so unique and in the case of Florida, it just doesn't get as cold. Although, it could definitely rival them and in my humble opinion, possibly could be better.
Just my 2 cents.......
Why not just make more fish for everyone to enjoy? We should stand as one in our call for fishery managers to focus more on enhancing our fisheries and food supply than restricting our freedom to access them.
There seems to be a mindset in America that somebody must be punished to solve a problem. Most problems can be solved by advancing liberty for all rather than restricting one group's freedom for the perceived benefit of another.
Just like a welfare queen. Not happy taking the resource at $400 a year but want recs and taxpayers to dump more fish for you to take! Build hatcheries to stock but you sure don't want to pay for it.
Not punished ~~ stop whining! Just slow down the greed of the industry. Grow a pair and go offshore, why are you afraid to be out of sight of land?
CCA frightens the industry and now RFA-NC has become deeply involved. Those along with Camo and NCWF plus others are finally speaking up. The public is seeing the truth. Legislators are listening and many are not liking much of what they were told in the past.
The "public service" line is BS. No one wants the commercial industry to end in NC but to work the same regs as their peers in other states. If the commercial industry went away tomorrow the shelves would be full. Restaurants may make menu adjustments but would not miss a beat. That 80 year old lady would still have all the sea food she wanted.
I just returned from Florida where there is a commercial fishery and I sure caught fish. I spent 5 weeks there and will be going to LA for a month mid-March. There is a huge commercial fishery there and the rec fishing is fantastic. The industry in NC provides around 4000 jobs and $430 million to the economy while recs provide 25,000 jobs and $1.6 Billion to the NC economy. Just think of the local money that would stay in NC and the amount of tourist money that passes by NC in order to fish where the fishing is much better. In reality the commercial industry is a hindrance to the state economy.
Wow you guys must have a real problem up north! I have fished between CB inlet and Little river jetties since I was old enough to get in the boat with dad and grandad and around the cape fear and southport area we have never had a problem catching our limit of flounder on hook and line. That must really suck to go trip after trip and not have any real luck!? As far the specs go before all the rain last week ole pawpaw was smoking them too. I get back in town and the water is so fresh you can drink it!! Just my luck! I have never really got into the whole commercial/ recs disagreements on fishing but I will say even though we catch our limits and most of the guys I know in my area do the same on hook and line. I don't think....... We could with hook and line supply just our local restaurants with enough flounder to support the crowds of family's from inland that come just one week out of summer to the coast for the beach and "FRESH LOCAL" seafood.
Am I correct on understanding that in Oct. all recreational flounder fishing will be closed this year?
Not saying that there aren't any fish to be caught. No one is saying there are no flounder or trout or drum. We all are saying that it isn't as good as it should be or was. It isn't. Sorry you can't honestly say there are as many flounder, trout and drum as there were "back in the day."
Let's just assume, for your argument's sake, that the fishing IS as good as ever where you are. Well... it isn't everywhere else. Also, just because you can point out a few people that are still catching fish, doesn't mean that the fishery is in good shape. I hear that all the time from gill net huggers. "Well my friend caught ## trout today. The fishing is still great!" or "Well you must not be fishing the right spots!" blah blah blah. What are we supposed to do, wait until there literally are no fish left to do something?
I'll say it again: nobody is saying there are no fish. They are saying the NETS NEED TO GO and the fishing could be much better.
Yes, the flounder supplement passed in November and large mesh gill net and recreational flounder fishing will be close from Oct. 16 to the new year.
Among other provisions
Hahaha gill net hugger never heard that one..No argument here friend, It doesn't bother me either way if they stay or go just saying we still catch our limit as we did as kids 30 years ago. Will the rec. gigging still be open after Oct. 16?
The gigs (rec and comm, I believe) come out of the water whenever the pounds reach their TAL, whether that's before or after the Oct. 16 large mesh and rec hook and line closure. Sorry I didn't clarify, I don't gig, so I tend to leave that part out.
That's great that you're catching fish and as long as you accept the fact that the fisheries ARE, without a doubt, declining greatly, we will have no problem. There is hard data proving that and plenty of it. Also plenty of anecdotal evidence that our estuaries aren't what they used to be.
Haha have a problem!? You gentlemen carry on...